why do people choose saloons?
why do people choose saloons?
Author
Discussion

CoolHands

Original Poster:

22,408 posts

219 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
I mean, most of them are simply more impractical than their hatchback sibling. Take the ford focus saloon. Yes! There really is one. What's the point?





Edited by CoolHands on Saturday 26th May 18:49

matthias73

2,900 posts

174 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Because I chose to, problem?

As a travelling freelance pharmaceutical sales rep, I need a propper boot, to safely store pharmaceutical products, and dead hookers.

SSBB

698 posts

180 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
They are generally quieter than a flat back vehicle. Cargo is more secure in the back in a crash.

veevee

1,458 posts

175 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
I think they get bought in some places in Europe.

Disco You

3,741 posts

204 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Mostly because they are quieter I think.

In most cases though you aren't comparing like for like. Most saloons are 3 Series sized or bigger, whereas hatchbacks are Golf sized or smaller.

A more sensible question would be "why does everyone buy saloons, estates are the same size and more practical".

EDLT

15,421 posts

230 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
matthias73 said:
Because I chose to, problem?

As a travelling freelance pharmaceutical sales rep, I need a propper boot, to safely store pharmaceutical products, and dead hookers.
PH's last pharmaceutical salesman used a hatchback.

Wafflesmk2

1,347 posts

178 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Disco You said:
Mostly because they are quieter I think.

In most cases though you aren't comparing like for like. Most saloons are 3 Series sized or bigger, whereas hatchbacks are Golf sized or smaller.

A more sensible question would be "why does everyone buy saloons, estates are the same size and more practical".
+1

Im torn between an E90 saloon and touring at the moment. I loved the vectra estate i used to have, so roomy behind me and more cosy too with rear tints.

I get a feeling people will scoff at me for buying the touring (when i have no kids/wife/dog) instead of the saloon though frown

BigNige

2,584 posts

248 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
PH's last pharmaceutical salesman used a hatchback.
Shows what he knew.

HeatonNorris

1,649 posts

172 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Disco You said:
Mostly because they are quieter I think.

In most cases though you aren't comparing like for like. Most saloons are 3 Series sized or bigger, whereas hatchbacks are Golf sized or smaller.

A more sensible question would be "why does everyone buy saloons, estates are the same size and more practical".
The small / mid sized saloons generally have significantly bigger boots than the hatch equivalents.

Ferg

15,242 posts

281 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
BigNige said:
EDLT said:
PH's last pharmaceutical salesman used a hatchback.
Shows what he knew.
I thought 'pharmaceuticals' were sold from blacked out 4X4s.

rohrl

8,984 posts

169 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
The small saloons aren't very popular in the UK are they? They're probably a little bit quieter inside due to better isolation of the rear wheels but it'll be marginal. Maybe a little safer in a rear-end crash.

Things like the Nova saloon and VW Derby look a bit odd to my eyes and personally I'd choose the hatchback in that class. It's not the Jetta which has consistently sold in it's millions is it?

FreeLitres

6,123 posts

201 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Ferg said:
I thought 'pharmaceuticals' were sold from blacked out BMWs.
Fixed that for you.

Herman Toothrot

6,702 posts

222 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
I prefer the look of saloons but they are impractical compared to estates, so I'll always buy an estate as the practical car.

Alfanatic

9,339 posts

243 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Saloon versions were more popular in SA. Don't know why. The sporty one would be a hatch (and hardly ever 3 door) and the exec one would be the saloon version with the same engine but more kit and more leather. That held true for Astras, golf/jetta, corolla, sunny...

jbi

12,698 posts

228 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Saloon Advantages:

1. Cargo more secure (contents are hidden and can be locked away with valet function)
2. Quieter due to enclosed cabin space
3. Looks (subjective)
4. Sometimes lighter
5. Some cars have more boot space in saloon form than hatch e.g toyota corolla
6. Safer in rear impact collisions

Vitorio

4,296 posts

167 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
I like how they look, somehow they look more like a proper car to me then hatches/wagons. Take the new Focus for instance. I LOATHE the design on the hatchback, the guy who designed the back end of that must have been blind, on LSD and having a seizure at the time of drawing that monstrosity. I like the wagon well enough, at least it doesnt have the gimpy tail lights of the hatch. The saloon though, i think looks the best of the three, even if it really is 20 cm too short to really make the saloon line work well.

I drive a Focus wagon though, there is no arguing with the cavern that unfolds before your eyes when you open the tailgate, especially if you have small kids. The practicality is just untouchable by a hatch/saloon.

If it werent for the needed practicality, i'd be driving either something smaller all together, or a focus saloon, or perhaps a megane coupe, just for the looks of em.

FreeLitres

6,123 posts

201 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Is a saloon Chimaera, a Cerbera?

Fox-

13,548 posts

270 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
I chose a Saloon because I like Saloons and I do not like hatchbacks.

Debaser

7,636 posts

285 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
CoolHands said:
What's the point?
Greater torsional rigidity?

sleep envy

62,260 posts

273 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
PH's last pharmaceutical salesman used a hatchback.
I thought he had a white carrera gt?