Cars for a young driver
Cars for a young driver
Author
Discussion

E55 Max

Original Poster:

1,189 posts

192 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
We are just coming to the point of having to buy and insure a car for OH's son.
Rather than take the usual line of Corsa/Fiesta/207 are there any cars out there that are cheap to insure?
Sometimes things slip through the net and something like an old rep mobile might be cheaper.
Any thoughts?

SirSamuelOfBuca

1,353 posts

177 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
how old is?

old rep mobile is a good bet. Maybe an old volvo t4 if he wants some fun smile

E55 Max

Original Poster:

1,189 posts

192 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
He will be 17 shortly, my thinking is that sometimes the obvious answer is not the answer!

Shaw Tarse

31,820 posts

223 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
E55 Max said:
He will be 17 shortly, my thinking is that sometimes the obvious answer is not the answer!
This has been covered before, cars that are not popular with young drivers seem to be better on insurance. Don't forget to add yourself & Mrs Max as named drivers.

Shaw Tarse

31,820 posts

223 months

J4CKO

45,369 posts

220 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
SirSamuelOfBuca said:
how old is?

old rep mobile is a good bet. Maybe an old volvo t4 if he wants some fun smile
A 200 plus bhp aging repmobile for a 17 year old that has just passed, hmm, dont think that is a great idea really. Think really any new driver should be worrying about getting places in their own car, within the speed limits without worrying too much about fun. Trouble is they come on here and read about dabs of oppo, lift oversteer and cadence clutching biggrin and then go and try it on the road, they end up building a load of knowledge but no actual experience and then they get talked into a Cerbera (Only the Speed Six, obviously, he is inexpereinced)

The older Volvo thing does work but I think it is for drivers with a couple of years under their belt versus something more obviously sporty.

Citroen C1/Aygo/107 for a couple of years, lowest insurance group, 50 mpg and reasonbly safe.


StottyZr

6,860 posts

183 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
E55 Max said:
We are just coming to the point of having to buy and insure a car for OH's son.
Oh really? My advice would be to tell him to get a job and buy his own!

Krikkit

27,727 posts

201 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
MX-5 on a classic policy!

swiftsport07

83 posts

175 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
An old Suzuki swift is a good bet for cheap insurance and reliability but there not the best looking of cars. that just means ther not popular with young men even thow ther great fun to drive and with ther 1300 engine abit quicker than most fiestas and courses of the same engine size. I had one and I loved it my 1st years insurence was 1200 and compered with my friends paying 2000 TPFT for ther corses and fiestas it was abit of a bargain.


I've got a 07 swift sport now and it's a great car. It's quicker than my friends fiesta Zetec S and C2 vst and it holds on to a fiesta st and in my opinion abit more sporty and just aswell equiped and im paying a lot less on the
insurance than any of them and I'm 20. And thats because it's a Suzuki .


Ray meerkat

197 posts

162 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
998cc classic mini
That was my first car. Good fun, 80mph top speed.
Moved onto 1275cc mini
10 years on, I got an Audi s3 Quattro. 250bhp. Never had a claim. Insurance is £290 for a group 15 car. smile

E55 Max

Original Poster:

1,189 posts

192 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
StottyZr said:
E55 Max said:
We are just coming to the point of having to buy and insure a car for OH's son.
Oh really? My advice would be to tell him to get a job and buy his own!
Really?!
Aged 17 in full time education living 5 miles from the nearest bus stop....Yep great advice!
I chose to live in the sticks, it is unfair on him to suffer because of my choices.

danjama

5,728 posts

162 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
E55 Max said:
Really?!
Aged 17 in full time education living 5 miles from the nearest bus stop....Yep great advice!
I chose to live in the sticks, it is unfair on him to suffer because of my choices.
Well said. Wish my step-dad was as considerate.

He's improved a lot though to be fair.

ez64

245 posts

182 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Ray meerkat said:
998cc classic mini
That was my first car. Good fun, 80mph top speed.
Moved onto 1275cc mini
10 years on, I got an Audi s3 Quattro. 250bhp. Never had a claim. Insurance is £290 for a group 15 car. smile
Problem is though chances are he is going to have a crash. If you have it in a perfect classic mini and most of them are not you are going to be crushed.

Vectra 4 door with a 2.0; tdi is built like a tank so he will be fine and insurance is dead cheap.

E55 Max

Original Poster:

1,189 posts

192 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
ez64 said:
Problem is though chances are he is going to have a crash. If you have it in a perfect classic mini and most of them are not you are going to be crushed.

Vectra 4 door with a 2.0; tdi is built like a tank so he will be fine and insurance is dead cheap.
That is what I am after!
Thanks everyone, keep them coming!

Foofighter

1,431 posts

195 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Mk2 Ford Mondeo. 1.8 petrol, shouldn't be too pricey nowadays. Not the obvious choice for the boy racer, but cheap to work on, not so great on fuel, and I can't imagine too expensive on insurance. Add to that, handy for hauling you and the Mrs to the airport or pub if you ever need a lift wink

Pontoneer

3,643 posts

206 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Mercedes W123 200 Diesel - slow as a week in jail , but solid , safe and reliable , besides being that bit different and not something he will feel he needs to park round the corner out of sight .

190D is another possibility , but 190's are already popular with young drivers and higher insurance as a result .

LouD86

3,288 posts

173 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
K11 Micra, done and dusted!

bigandclever

14,165 posts

258 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Isn't it still a VW Beetle (the old one) that's cheapest for young driver insurance?

Twincam16

27,647 posts

278 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Seem to recall doing some back-of-an-old-envelope totting up and working out that the cheapest car to buy, run and insure - for anyone - in terms of overall outlay and likely longevity was an Audi 80 1.9 diesel.

Slow, yes, but he's 17, it's a car, he'll be grateful. Also, it's a big old Audi so all his mates will call him 'Gene Hunt'.

They're also big enough to be very safe in a crash should he stuff it into a ditch. Lifetime anti-perforation warranty should mean strong metal too, and the Audi procon-ten steering column actually works better than an airbag.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/search/used/cars/audi/...


V10Mike

607 posts

226 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Hyundai Getz, surprisingly good to drive, practical, reliable but desperately unfashionable and hence even the 1.6 is dirt cheap to insure.