Have I done a 'what car?' before?
Have I done a 'what car?' before?
Author
Discussion

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
Which would you choose?

A3 S-Line 2.0TDi;
Volkswagon CC (non-GT) 140PS Bluemotion;
Volkswagon Golf GTD;
BMW 118d M Sport.

BMW comes out slightly cheaper, all are circa £23-26k - BIK plays a role and there's a fuel card so not particularly an issue with slight MPG fluctuations.

Taking into account I have an E46 330Ci which I will be keeping (or perhaps changing to something more hardcore like an Elise/VX220 but that's another story for another day) so have my 'more fun' car sorted.

Is there anything else worth looking at which will cost me similar amounts per month? There's not a car list as such as they just buy the car.


longblackcoat

5,047 posts

211 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Which would you choose?

A3 S-Line 2.0TDi;
Volkswagon CC (non-GT) 140PS Bluemotion;
Volkswagon Golf GTD;
BMW 118d M Sport.

BMW comes out slightly cheaper, all are circa £23-26k - BIK plays a role and there's a fuel card so not particularly an issue with slight MPG fluctuations.

Taking into account I have an E46 330Ci which I will be keeping (or perhaps changing to something more hardcore like an Elise/VX220 but that's another story for another day) so have my 'more fun' car sorted.

Is there anything else worth looking at which will cost me similar amounts per month? There's not a car list as such as they just buy the car.
If it's just a get-you-to-work car and you'll spend most of the time on the motorway, the Passat CC (or normal Passat) for general waftiness and nice interiors. Or you could save a bit and go for a Skoda.

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
Looking at the Scirocco GT too. 2.0 TDi.

Got to be a diesel.

Would still like something a little bit interesting though.

AyBee

11,269 posts

230 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
Out of your original list, probably the Passat CC, I may be swayed by the Scirocco though but I think we'd have to know more about what you're using it for. I wouldn't bother keeping the 330 if I had a Passat for example but the Passat and an Elise would be a good combo smile

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
Visits to clients/potential clients so the Scirocco, for example, wouldn't be in one of the garish colours.

330Ci would probably go and make way for something for the weekend.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

218 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Which would you choose?

A3 S-Line 2.0TDi;
Volkswagon CC (non-GT) 140PS Bluemotion;
Volkswagon Golf GTD;
BMW 118d M Sport.

BMW comes out slightly cheaper, all are circa £23-26k - BIK plays a role and there's a fuel card so not particularly an issue with slight MPG fluctuations.

Taking into account I have an E46 330Ci which I will be keeping (or perhaps changing to something more hardcore like an Elise/VX220 but that's another story for another day) so have my 'more fun' car sorted.

Is there anything else worth looking at which will cost me similar amounts per month? There's not a car list as such as they just buy the car.
When you say fuel card, does that mean you are getting some/all of your fuel paid for? If so, wouldn't something a little more juicy be in order?

AyBee

11,269 posts

230 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Visits to clients/potential clients so the Scirocco, for example, wouldn't be in one of the garish colours.

330Ci would probably go and make way for something for the weekend.
The Scirocco would have to be in that blue (can't remember the exact name) biggrin

Still think I'd go for the Passat though for the waft factor although a trip to the VW dealer would definitely be on the cards to test drive both. The only Scirocco I've been in was an R so probably very different to the standard TDi version, although I loved the R.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

218 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Visits to clients/potential clients so the Scirocco, for example, wouldn't be in one of the garish colours.
Why?? Would it really matter, maybe they wouldn't like someone with bond hair either or someone wearing a striped shirt.... I mean come on..

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AyBee said:
The Scirocco would have to be in that blue (can't remember the exact name) biggrin

Still think I'd go for the Passat though for the waft factor although a trip to the VW dealer would definitely be on the cards to test drive both. The only Scirocco I've been in was an R so probably very different to the standard TDi version, although I loved the R.
Yeah it'd be the 150bhp R-Line I think. Definitely in the blue colour!

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
When you say fuel card, does that mean you are getting some/all of your fuel paid for? If so, wouldn't something a little more juicy be in order?
Yeah fuel paid for but they won't fund me to burn through a st load or I'd take the allowance and the fuel card and use my 330Ci as a daily.

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Why?? Would it really matter, maybe they wouldn't like someone with bond hair either or someone wearing a striped shirt.... I mean come on..
Tell it to my boss.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

218 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
300bhp/ton said:
Why?? Would it really matter, maybe they wouldn't like someone with bond hair either or someone wearing a striped shirt.... I mean come on..
Tell it to my boss.
Sure, got and email address I can send it to wink

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

218 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Yeah fuel paid for but they won't fund me to burn through a st load or I'd take the allowance and the fuel card and use my 330Ci as a daily.
ok then, is there an mpg threashhold you need to meet? Anything else about the cars, like how many doors, seats and do you need a boot?

Personally I'd take the BMW as it's the only RWD one you've listed. But a 120d or older 123d might be more fun and no worse to run (are the new only vehicles?)

RevolveR

227 posts

168 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
Volvo D4 and D5 engines are pretty good

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
ok then, is there an mpg threashhold you need to meet? Anything else about the cars, like how many doors, seats and do you need a boot?

Personally I'd take the BMW as it's the only RWD one you've listed. But a 120d or older 123d might be more fun and no worse to run (are the new only vehicles?)
I've never had a new car and I did wonder if they'd lease something older for me.

Need a boot and to be 'respectable' and relatively efficient, no thresholds but the director is no mug so I won't get a 135i past him biggrin

I suppose the easy thing to do is to ask, but I don't want to seem more eager about the car than the job at this point.

Looking at cars up to 18 months old on BMW AUC website (diesel, manual, 3 door or coupe) gives loads of 320d M Sports with the latest facelift (E9x) for £25k as well as some 123d M Sport Coupe variants. A nice 320d (or 325d) M Sport would be amazing.

I have a feeling if I start thinking about them though I'll be disappointed.

TEKNOPUG

20,437 posts

233 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
They all seem terminally dull - are they no other options?

AB

Original Poster:

20,319 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
They all seem terminally dull - are they no other options?
Company cars define dull though, don't they.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

218 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
I've never had a new car and I did wonder if they'd lease something older for me.

Need a boot and to be 'respectable' and relatively efficient, no thresholds but the director is no mug so I won't get a 135i past him biggrin

I suppose the easy thing to do is to ask, but I don't want to seem more eager about the car than the job at this point.

Looking at cars up to 18 months old on BMW AUC website (diesel, manual, 3 door or coupe) gives loads of 320d M Sports with the latest facelift (E9x) for £25k as well as some 123d M Sport Coupe variants. A nice 320d (or 325d) M Sport would be amazing.

I have a feeling if I start thinking about them though I'll be disappointed.
Honestly I truly don't get this "respectable" thing. Surely the car you are in is likely to be the least important factor to the client, ok if it was a new Ferrari maybe... but even then I'm not fully convinced.


Would something like a GT86 be on the cards or even a 1.6 base model Elise?

Madmatt74

273 posts

185 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
RevolveR said:
Volvo D4 and D5 engines are pretty good
Ive got an V60 D5 and love it.
Well build, high spec, Two turbos for pub amo wink, Boot a bit small but looks good for an estate.
215BHP and 800 miles to the tank if i dont push the pedal too hard.
Fantastic booster seats in the back if you have kids.

Only about £400/Month for the D5 2.4D 215 Se lux which is about the same as your options listed.

Shame i've only got mine for another 6 weeks frown

TEKNOPUG

20,437 posts

233 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2012
quotequote all
AB said:
Company cars define dull though, don't they.
Is there not a cash alternative that you can take?