£15k on a Z4M Roadster or S2k with s/c?
£15k on a Z4M Roadster or S2k with s/c?

Poll: £15k on a Z4M Roadster or S2k with s/c?

Total Members Polled: 127

Z4M Roadster: 64%
S2000 Supercharged (c.350-400bhp) : 36%
Author
Discussion

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

207 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
I'm doing some car changing early in the new year and want to keep a convertible in the stable. Left field choice is an AC Cobra recreation by say Dax but the spec I'd likely want would come in at £30k+ even second hand, although it's still very tempting!

On the assumption that I only wanted to spend £15k, which of the above would you choose? £15k seems to get you into a good Z4M Roadster, but would also get you a lovely S2000 to which you could give the power it deserves.

I like the idea of the Beemer as the engine is a work of art, but, I also will likely go through an E46 M3 in the future so am tempted to wait until then.
I like the idea of the S2000 as I loved my one I had a while back, it's a bit different and the interior is now retro cool. With proper power and torque I think it's be a hoot. Downside is, you're never gonna get more than a fraction of your money back from the mods.

What would you do? And probably more importantly, why?!

ETA to clarify after GroundEffect's post: I'm not talking about body kits, phat wheels and the like for the S2k, literally just the engine/drivetrain


Edited by Mario149 on Thursday 11th October 11:16

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Z4M.

I don't like modified cars.

vinopete

932 posts

227 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Z4M all day long judge
just a much better all rounder, and you would be able to sell it after, unlike modified s2000

Edited by vinopete on Thursday 11th October 11:20

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Vtec.
BMWs make me want to take a nap.

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
And I know what you mean by modification...

I don't like any aftermarket powertrain modification - you don't know how it's been designed. Nope.

tyrewrecker

6,419 posts

183 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
GroundEffect said:
Z4M.

I don't like modified cars.
Me either.

Looks boring

http://roadmagazine.blogspot.co.uk/2011/12/undergr...

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

185 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
PSBuckshot said:
Vtec.
BMWs make me want to take a nap.
S54 revs to 8000rpm, sounds like a race engine and produces 345PS.

Yup. Boring.

TimmD

278 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
How about an elise, far more fun then either of those two.

Faster in the real world and will hardly lose any money. Cheep to run, won't use much fuel (can you tell I am please with mine!)

Like this one:

http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds/use...


anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
GroundEffect said:
S54 revs to 8000rpm, sounds like a race engine and produces 345PS.

Yup. Boring.
Looks boring, I have no doubt at all that they drive amazing.
Just meh.

nonuts

15,855 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Z4, no question and if you get bored get that supercharged.

PSBuckshot said:
Vtec.
BMWs make me want to take a nap.
Drive both, Z4m is WAY better, especially the engine.

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

207 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
S2k engine revs to 9k and produces 118bhp/litre in standard form, so in terms of tuning pedigree it's prob on par with a Z4M engine. Its probably why I like the idea of either of them a lot smile

deltashad

6,731 posts

226 months

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

207 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
TimmD said:
How about an elise, far more fun then either of those two.

Faster in the real world and will hardly lose any money. Cheep to run, won't use much fuel (can you tell I am please with mine!)

Like this one:

http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds/use...

Good shout, but a little more impractical than I was thinking. This would be an every day car. I used an Elise daily a couple of years back and it does become a bit of a pain after a while. Bet I wouldn't have said that before my 30th birthday hehe

996 sps

6,165 posts

245 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Z4 M and wouldn't even take a second look at the other car, can't even remember what it was!

mmm-five

12,352 posts

313 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
How about a bit of both?

£10k on leggy Z4MR, and £5k on a supercharger for 440bhp hehe

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Z3M Coupe is more interesting than either....but obviously its not a ragtop. I cant imagine an S2K with 300Hp+, they cant deploy what they have in the first place!

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

207 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
yonex said:
Z3M Coupe is more interesting than either....but obviously its not a ragtop. I cant imagine an S2K with 300Hp+, they cant deploy what they have in the first place!
Huh? I don't remember having unusual problems with oversteer etc on my prev S2k?

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

207 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
deltashad said:
Mental! But I think 400 bhp is enough for an everyday car hehe

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Mario149 said:
Huh? I don't remember having unusual problems with oversteer etc on my prev S2k?
Not to get into this debate again but IME the S2K was a bit of a disappointment, which turned into a 'bit of a handful' when it was wet. I cant imagine a supercharger helping things. It's dead money unless you want a project to keep you busy.

LuS1fer

43,508 posts

274 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Mario149 said:
Good shout, but a little more impractical than I was thinking. This would be an every day car. I used an Elise daily a couple of years back and it does become a bit of a pain after a while. Bet I wouldn't have said that before my 30th birthday hehe
The Vauxhall **220 (sorry my mind has gone a blank) might be more practical.
Not a fan of the Z4 styling and though I voted SC S2000, I probably wouldn't myself.