LPG - pros and cons?
Author
Discussion

6fire

Original Poster:

406 posts

182 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Yes, I've done a search. And no, nothing very useful comes up.

So, I have a Saab 9-5 Aero on 150k miles. I like it, I want to keep it - and I see no reason it won't double that mileage. What I'm not quite so keen on is the fuel consumption having sold a TDi Passat that averaged 50mpg, I'm disliking the amount of money I'm spending on fuel.

As I'm doing roughly 25k miles/annum at the moment, I've calculated that a conversion would pay for itself within about 10 months. That's a Prins sequential system conversion, set up to auto switch to LPG - and then back to petrol under heavy load.

It therefore seems to make sense. Pros are:-

Its a lot cheaper
Cleaner burn

Cons are:-

The price might go up (not quickly enough for me to to get a RoI I don't think)
The lower calorific value and small tank (62 litres will fit in the spare wheel well) mean frequent fuel stops
There aren't that many fuel stations (this seems to be getting a lot better)
It means running without the (space saver) spare wheel - or having it loose in a bag in the boot.

Unknowns are:-

What effect will it have on a higher mileage engine
Will the Saab suffer from valve seat recession (so should I have a flashlube system fitted)

So, can anyone answer the unknowns and / or give any other comments.

PS I'm not worried about resale value, and although I can afford to fuel it on 'proper' petrol, I don't see why I should give the government any more of my 'hard earned' (and already taxed) than I need to in extra tax and duty.

If there is another thread that provides all the information I need, then if someone can point me in the right direction, I would be very grateful.

Glyn84

668 posts

211 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
6fire said:
Cons are:-

The price might go up (not quickly enough for me to to get a RoI I don't think)
The lower calorific value and small tank (62 litres will fit in the spare wheel well) mean frequent fuel stops
There aren't that many fuel stations (this seems to be getting a lot better)
It means running without the (space saver) spare wheel - or having it loose in a bag in the boot.

Unknowns are:-

What effect will it have on a higher mileage engine
Will the Saab suffer from valve seat recession (so should I have a flashlube system fitted)
I have a Prins twin vaporiser system on a 6.0L Monaro and done roughly 50k with it so I'll give you my thoughts.

The LPG fuel consumption will drop a few mpg compared to petrol and the small tank is a pain. It will go back to petrol if you run out of gas though so running it close to empty isn't really a problem providing you have some petrol in the tank. pocketgpsworld.com have a good points of interest map for lots of satnavs which makes finding a station fairly easy, and quite a lot of motorway service stations have it now and don't rip you off as much as they do with petrol.

For the spare wheel, when you have it converted they should give you a can of tyre weld which is better than nothing if you don't want the spare in your boot.

A high mileage engine shouldn't be a problem, but LPG will show any weaknesses in your ignition system which might need addressing. I would recommend some Magnecor leads. Valve seat recession really only effects engines with soft valves and seats but you will get a bit of extra wear. Prins have a list of engines which suffer at http://amrautos.co.uk/database_problem_cars.pdf which you can check.

The only other thing I'd recommend is fitting some NGK LPG spark plugs. They aren't cheap, but they make a world of difference and last much longer - cheap plugs don't last long at all on LPG.

jr502

487 posts

205 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
An old system with no flash lube (~14 years old) has been on my dad's ford explorer for 100k miles and it hasn't missed a beat. Given it does <20 MPG (LPG and petrol) it has more than earned its keep by a long way!

rswift

1,181 posts

206 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
I am a big fan, and see no cons IF it is a good system, fitted well, preferably by someone who has done the same car before, so they know the pitfalls.

I have a 4.2 Jag XJ8 , converted at 40k, not on 95K, Jeep Cherokee, converted 13 years ago, now on 150k miles, and my old Jag converted at 80, sold at 325K miles.

A mate had a Saab 900, did over 350K on a very basic & old LPG system, including two trips from Peterboro' to Belarus.

I filled the Jeep this morning at 72.9p litre, and that was Motorway prices

sparkyhx

4,200 posts

235 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
rswift said:
I am a big fan, and see no cons IF it is a good system, fitted well, preferably by someone who has done the same car before, so they know the pitfalls.

I have a 4.2 Jag XJ8 , converted at 40k, not on 95K, Jeep Cherokee, converted 13 years ago, now on 150k miles, and my old Jag converted at 80, sold at 325K miles.

A mate had a Saab 900, did over 350K on a very basic & old LPG system, including two trips from Peterboro' to Belarus.

I filled the Jeep this morning at 72.9p litre, and that was Motorway prices
ditto,
get a decent system, no real disadvantages above what you have already said other than don't forget its an extra fuel system that needs 'servicing' regularly.

- loose boot space = space saver or tyreweld
- insurance can be a bit of a pain as its classed as modified and some insurance companies rate it as such. You just need to shop around a bit more.
- less places to fill up but there are phone apps to tell you where they are. a bit of advanced planning before setting off on long journeys means its not a problem fill up before you set off, or find out where the stations are at the other end.
- lower MPG, and lower range
- Valve seat recession is only a problem on certain cars - my installer won't use Flashlube as he says it doesn't work very well. It only works when running +ve pressure so if you do a lot of motorway miles its not working. No idea if thats true or not. There are other alternatives that actually go inside the tank.


Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Many people seem to buy a powerful car and then detune it by fitting LPG. Might as well just buy a small eco-diesel to start with.

I guess some folks like to be seen in a big car.
I guess there's also the "comfortable car to sit all day on the motorway" angle.

stemll

5,652 posts

231 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
You can't go on Eurotunnel. May not be of any consequence to you but it a potential con.

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Don't think it really effects the performance. I was going to put it on my old ML500 but decided against it after weighing everything up, and then, there would have always been at the back of my mind.... 'if this takes off, the government will tax it more'.

I'm not a gambler.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Many people seem to buy a powerful car and then detune it by fitting LPG. Might as well just buy a small eco-diesel to start with.

I guess some folks like to be seen in a big car.
I guess there's also the "comfortable car to sit all day on the motorway" angle.
This is why LPG isn't successful in the UK, people haven't got a clue about it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Bit out of date there, a modern LPG system does not lose you any power at all so no-one is detuning anything by fitting LPG. These sequential multi-point injection systems have been the norm for years now. Only the really old systems result in power loss.

Be careful with converting your Saab - some of the engines are on the Prins list of no-nos for conversion IIRC, but an installer will have access to the latest lists and be able to advise.

It won't switch back to petrol under heavy load, as long as it's been set up properly, again that's only the very old systems which cut back to petrol on powerful cars under load.

10 months seems like a very quick payback time - check your maths and expect about a 20% drop in MPG not 10% as many people seem to quote. LPG contains quite a lot less energy per litre so you need to burn more for equivalent performance.

Either way as long as you're sure the engine is sound and the ignition components are in good order there's no reason not to convert a high miler as long as you're going to keep it a good while. No point if you're going to get shut after 25k miles, yes you'll have broken even on the conversion, but why go to the hassle unless it's actually going to save you a good wedge?

Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 18th January 17:42

sparkyhx

4,200 posts

235 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Many people seem to buy a powerful car and then detune it by fitting LPG. Might as well just buy a small eco-diesel to start with.

I guess some folks like to be seen in a big car.
I guess there's also the "comfortable car to sit all day on the motorway" angle.
eh?
you lose about 10% which is just about noticeable
I'd sooner have a big V8 petrol than a modern Diesel waiting to cost big bucks and you get better consumpion than a big diesel

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
yonex said:
This is why LPG isn't successful in the UK, people haven't got a clue about it.
Or maybe they noticed the "backfire" and "burnt valve" problems which risk severe engine damage.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=200908...

http://www.lpgforum.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=33&t...

http://www.landyzone.co.uk/lz/f10/lpg-backfire-577...

But do please enlighten us rather than chucking a brick and running away....

zip929

670 posts

208 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
sparkyhx said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
Many people seem to buy a powerful car and then detune it by fitting LPG. Might as well just buy a small eco-diesel to start with.

I guess some folks like to be seen in a big car.
I guess there's also the "comfortable car to sit all day on the motorway" angle.
eh?
you lose about 10% which is just about noticeable
I'd sooner have a big V8 petrol than a modern Diesel waiting to cost big bucks and you get better consumpion than a big diesel
I had an RS6 with LPG. Hardly noticed the difference in power compared to petrol.
Main issue with the LPG was having to fill up every 120 miles or so.


Edited by zip929 on Friday 18th January 17:57

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
I converted my 2000 161k 530i with a good quality kit and, eventually, did 30k trouble free.

I will touch upon a few cons I experienced that were outweighed by the pros.

You need a perfect running car before hand. By BMW was fine on petrol but would misfire on gas, requiring new coil packs and spark plugs.

You can only ever fill 80% of the tank so get as big as you can. I recommend for a big saloon a cylinder tank.

Careful at what temp the petrol switches to gas. Mine was a little low and if I pulled out of a junction quickly at that point it would stall.

MPG was 27 on petrol 22 on gas.

In winter I still used lots of petrol.

Finding a LPG station with the range and mileage I did was sometimes a pain.

It takes AGES to fill!

Worry that if something went wrong dealer blames LPG, LPG man blames car. I experienced this initially with misfire.

That said it was great, good talking point, no loss of power, and refreshing no fill up so cheap. I created a comprehensive spreadsheet and broke even at 22000 miles and did an equivilent of 43mpg out of a big 530iA. Would I do it again? Probably not, but was a fun experiment which paid for itself.

Oh, and at trade in time, for me at least, it made no difference in car value.

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
sparkyhx said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
Many people seem to buy a powerful car and then detune it by fitting LPG. Might as well just buy a small eco-diesel to start with.

I guess some folks like to be seen in a big car.
I guess there's also the "comfortable car to sit all day on the motorway" angle.
eh?
you lose about 10% which is just about noticeable
I'd sooner have a big V8 petrol than a modern Diesel waiting to cost big bucks and you get better consumpion than a big diesel
You need to sit down with a cup of coffee and do some man math:
I'll take my old car for example:

ML270d BHP= (Power to weight? but there wont be much in it.) 163bhp. MPG: at best: 35.3mpg

ML500 BHP= 292bhp. MPG 25.2mpg

The 500 is cheaper to buy, has the noise, the power delivery, the only thing you lose is boot space. Something at the time I couldn't. I needed a 7 seater, the last thing I wanted to lose was boot space.

The only thing that put me off was the government not having any kind of capping on what their intentions were with LPG pricing. At that time there was much scare mongering about taxation. If everyone had gone LPG I have no doubt whatsover they would have re-evaluate things considerably. Against anyone who had just spent £2.5k on an LPG system. Also at that time Githead Brown was deciding to put extra road tax on anything with a big engine, so I sold up before I lost too much. I played that completely wrong as my car was pre 2006.

Anyhow, LPG go for it. If you can live with a reduced boot and you do the miles. It doesn't make your smoker into a soda stream.

6fire

Original Poster:

406 posts

182 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the answers.

It seems that those who have done it seem to like it and those who haven't are scared of it. An interesting question - why don't I buy a diesel. Well I had one of those and I wasn't overly fond of the power delivery or the 'dag dag dag' noise or the constant feeling that I was driving a (not very) fast tractor. I came to the conclusion that I just prefer petrols. But whilst I don't mind filling them all the time, I do object to lining the chancellor's pockets.

charltjr said:
10 months seems like a very quick payback time - check your maths and expect about a 20% drop in MPG not 10% as many people seem to quote. LPG contains quite a lot less energy per litre so you need to burn more for equivalent performance.
Mileage = 25k/annum
MPG = 30
Petrol = £1.30/litre
Therefore cost / annum = 25000/30/0.22*1.30 = £4,924 or £410/month

LPG = £0.729/litre
Fuel consumption estimated at 90% of 30 mpg = 27mpg
Therefore 25000/27/.22*0.729 = £3,068 or £255/month

The saving is therefore £155/month

I have been quoted £1,400 (inc VAT) to fit the system. Which at a saving of £155/month would take just over 9 months to pay for itself.

Now, I know that there would be times when the car was running on petrol - and indeed I would want to do that from time to time anyway to stop the fuel going stale and varnishing up the inside of the injectors, but 12 months is certainly a reasonable time frame. In fact, that is a reasonable time frame even if LPG's calorific value is only 80% that of petrol - everyone so far has told me that 90% is a reasonable assumption to work on.

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
zip929 said:
I had an RS6 with LPG. Hardly noticed the difference in power compared to petrol.
Main issue with the LPG was having to fill up every 120 miles or so.


Edited by zip929 on Friday 18th January 17:57
Shirley that was due to you having a rather small errr.....

confused_buyer

7,143 posts

212 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Or maybe they noticed the "backfire" and "burnt valve" problems which risk severe engine damage.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=200908...

http://www.lpgforum.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=33&t...

http://www.landyzone.co.uk/lz/f10/lpg-backfire-577...

But do please enlighten us rather than chucking a brick and running away....
A car should run on LPG just the same as it does on petrol if (a) the car is suitable for LPG in the first place and (b) it is installed properly. Most LPG installations are trouble free, but it is the few installed by idiots which you hear about.

confused_buyer

7,143 posts

212 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
6fire said:
Now, I know that there would be times when the car was running on petrol - and indeed I would want to do that from time to time anyway to stop the fuel going stale and varnishing up the inside of the injectors, but 12 months is certainly a reasonable time frame. In fact, that is a reasonable time frame even if LPG's calorific value is only 80% that of petrol - everyone so far has told me that 90% is a reasonable assumption to work on.
I've only ever run large V8's on LPG and I'm currently smoking a LS400 running on LPG. I can't tell the difference between petrol and LPG when driving and even in this weather switches in under a mile from stone cold and instantly if the car has any residual heat when starting. Basically, it switches before the heater comes on.

MPG wise it varies. In mixed driving a LS400 around town with a bit of stop and start will do about 18mpg on petrol and probably 16-17mpg on LPG so very little loss. Add in a bit of motorway work and 23mpg on petrol and 20ish on LPG seems about it. Where it seems to lose more is on very long motorway journeys where the petrol mpg can creep up to high 20's and sometimes even 30. The LPG never seems to get much over 23mpg no matter how and where you drive it so there is a 5-6mpg loss.

Basically, it does 350-375 miles on about £50 (tank takes ~70 litres) worth of LPG on a run and about 275 in run around day to day driving (I do a lot of short journies). On a run, that's about 14p a mile which you'd need a diesel doing 45mpg to match, in mixed worst case about 17p a mile so roughly 37mpg equivalent.

It may be "man maths" but believe me filling up with £50 and doing 275 miles is a lot easier on the nerves than filling up with £90 and doing 320 miles. smile

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Friday 18th January 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Many people seem to buy a powerful car and then detune it by fitting LPG. Might as well just buy a small eco-diesel to start with.

I guess some folks like to be seen in a big car.
I guess there's also the "comfortable car to sit all day on the motorway" angle.
roflroflrofl

Another well informed post.

I have owned many LPG converted cars over many years and have never noticed any performance drop when using a modern multipoint ECU controlled system (Prins, BRC, OMVL etc)

An LPG car doesn't have any of the risks of the high costs that affect diesels such as pump, injectors, DPF etc and isn't affected by fuel strikes nor does it drive / smell / sound like a diesel.

I've run many Yank V8s which give the equivalent of 30mpg on LPG and a Leon Cupra with 180bhp giving the equivalent of 50+mpg and recently converted my wife's car (Mazda6 Sport) done correctly there really is no down side and her car's conversion paid for itself within a year.