Insurance issue - they want to cancel policy
Insurance issue - they want to cancel policy
Author
Discussion

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,660 posts

210 months

Wednesday 30th January 2013
quotequote all
Well, got an issue to sort for my brother in the morning as his insurance co (student specialist) want to cancel his insurance....

This policy was started in early November and has been nothing but trouble until now...dispute costing the best part of £1k paid up front.

First the request list: MOT, full license (both parts) for all drivers and a copy of the V5 and student ID, all supplied when asked with the exception of the V5 due to a burglary, although the new keepers supplement was sent and a new V5 ordered after paying £25. They were contacted re only new keepers bit being sent and acknowledged the reason, asking for a copy of the full doc to be sent when received. (sent day after it came last week).

Brother then has a call saying policy will be cancelled today due to the documents not being sent promptly (dispite the above) and according to a letter sent in December (never received any letters at this time). They then said that with further analysis a claim of my dad's hadn't been disclosed from may 2011!!! (there was none) and he is a named driver. Only thing at about this time was a motorbike accident in June/July 11 (non-fault and did not put this down on car insurance quote as not relevant).

So how do I get this resolved for him (I did quote and have been permitted to contact them on his behalf) do motorbike accidents have to be disclosed???

Is there anything saying that this is immaterial to the policy and due to hassle and if a problem just taking him off (never drives car) - surely if they still do cancel they need to give a refund as no policy doc's or any hard copy information was ever sent?

Any help from PH much appreciated!

Badgerboy

1,794 posts

222 months

Wednesday 30th January 2013
quotequote all
Without commenting on the other areas, any insurance claim needs to be stated. I have to declare my non-fault car accident every time I re-new my bike insurance.

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,660 posts

210 months

Wednesday 30th January 2013
quotequote all
Badgerboy said:
Without commenting on the other areas, any insurance claim needs to be stated. I have to declare my non-fault car accident every time I re-new my bike insurance.
Oh pants, I didn't know that at the time but...they currently state the wrong month also....

May just get him removed from the policy for ease and hope they re-instate....main thing is getting the funds back pro rats if they cancel.

Was paid on a CC which may help...

Badgerboy

1,794 posts

222 months

Wednesday 30th January 2013
quotequote all
There will be some chaps far better versed in this than I on tomorrow no doubt.

Steffan

10,362 posts

258 months

Wednesday 30th January 2013
quotequote all
Badgerboy said:
Without commenting on the other areas, any insurance claim needs to be stated. I have to declare my non-fault car accident every time I re-new my bike insurance.

Uberrima fides or utmost faith requirement covers all insurance policies. You cannot decide the relevance of what must be disclosed. I am sorry to say the insurance company can cancel this cover at will. No redress.

rigga

8,806 posts

231 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
Whilst its a pain that you can't transfer ncb from bikes to cars and vice versa, accidents to do with either need to be disclosed when renewing any insurance, .

Noger

7,117 posts

279 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
What did the question say ? Was it clear ?

Did you try to answer it truthfully ? Or didn't you really care ?

They have the right to cancel, but should still treat you fairly.

If the question was clear, and you have not answered truthfully, combined with failing to send the docs .... You may be in bother.

The insurer can keep your premium if there is evidence of fraud.

collateral

7,238 posts

248 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
rigga said:
Whilst its a pain that you can't transfer ncb from bikes to cars and vice versa, accidents to do with either need to be disclosed when renewing any insurance, .
Seems a bit out of order

ikarl

4,064 posts

229 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
Normally the question is asked have you (or your father in this instance) had any accidents or claims in the last x amount of years. At this point it is best to advise of all motor related accidents or claims and let the advisor advise what is or isn't needed.

Unfortunately, because the insurance has been runnin for the last few months, they may see the accident as reason enough to keep the majority of the payment.

example - Insurance was quoted at £1,000 for the year. Paid all at once by CC. 6 months later, new information means that the insurance quote would have been £2,000 if they had all the relevant information at inception, therefore for the 6 months of cover you have had, they would charge the £1,000 you have already paid (if you see what I mean?!)

ikarl

4,064 posts

229 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
collateral said:
rigga said:
Whilst its a pain that you can't transfer ncb from bikes to cars and vice versa, accidents to do with either need to be disclosed when renewing any insurance, .
Seems a bit out of order
Not really, the insurance company need to make a 'best guess' risk assessment of your ability to interact with other road users and generally get a picture of your safety on the road.

If I had had 5 fault accidents in cars and then decided to take to two wheeels, you better believe the insurance company want to know how well I get on unsupervised on the road.

Porkupine

1,722 posts

195 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
Just call and ask them....tell them you want a full refund.

I think you may find removing your father may in fact increase the premium.

Let us know what happens.

collateral

7,238 posts

248 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
ikarl said:
collateral said:
rigga said:
Whilst its a pain that you can't transfer ncb from bikes to cars and vice versa, accidents to do with either need to be disclosed when renewing any insurance, .
Seems a bit out of order
Not really, the insurance company need to make a 'best guess' risk assessment of your ability to interact with other road users and generally get a picture of your safety on the road.

If I had had 5 fault accidents in cars and then decided to take to two wheeels, you better believe the insurance company want to know how well I get on unsupervised on the road.
True, but at the same time making no claims not transferable seems like a case of having their cake and eating it

rigga

8,806 posts

231 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
collateral said:
rigga said:
Whilst its a pain that you can't transfer ncb from bikes to cars and vice versa, accidents to do with either need to be disclosed when renewing any insurance, .
Seems a bit out of order
Such is life .....






And when money is involved.

Lee540

1,586 posts

174 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
I had an arguement RE: motorbike claim on car insurance...

I had a motorbike accident in 2008, 6 months later I bought my BMW 540i, I did the online insurance quote and didn't state it. I took train 200 miles to collect the car and after handing over the money and I then called the insurnace company. They said they would charge me £500 more becuase of a claim I didn't declare. WTF!

I didn't argue it at the time but when I got home, calm and relaxed, gave another call, explained it was on a motorbike and if you can't transfer motorbike NCB then how can a motorbike claim affect a car insurance premium? They refunded me back all of the difference and it hasn't affected me since.

Some of these robots of the end of the phone don't know what circumstances of the claim were, just that there was one.

littleredrooster

6,412 posts

226 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
Lee540 said:
I had an arguement RE: motorbike claim on car insurance...

I had a motorbike accident in 2008, 6 months later I bought my BMW 540i, I did the online insurance quote and didn't state it...
So what part of the question 'Have you had any accidents, claims or convictions in the past three years?' did you not understand?

PH seems to have multiple threads running at the moment with people who lack a basic understanding of motor insurance.

Rick_1138

3,947 posts

208 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
My car insurer wasnt fussed about my fault claim on my bike, i informed them about it but they said it was fine.

This was about 4 years ago so they maybe felt enough time had passed, it didnt effect my premium, but i had told them.

Though if push came to shove i bet they would use it to not cover.

I find honesty is best policy with insurers.

Though i have had issues with some insurers regarding licence copies etc, especially after i passed my bike test in 2000, but renewed my licene in 2010, as a result my A1 licence showed from 2002, i.e. when my 33bhp restriction ended, they asked for another £20 as apparently i hadnt stated my test date correctly, they got told to f.off and lost me and my dads business.

Lee540

1,586 posts

174 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
littleredrooster said:
Lee540 said:
I had an arguement RE: motorbike claim on car insurance...

I had a motorbike accident in 2008, 6 months later I bought my BMW 540i, I did the online insurance quote and didn't state it...
So what part of the question 'Have you had any accidents, claims or convictions in the past three years?' did you not understand?

PH seems to have multiple threads running at the moment with people who lack a basic understanding of motor insurance.
I understand the question and chose to ignore it.

FlashmanChop

1,300 posts

236 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
kiethton said:
claim of my dad's hadn't been disclosed from may 2011!!! (there was none) and he is a named driver. Only thing at about this time was a motorbike accident in June/July 11 (non-fault and did not put this down on car insurance quote as not relevant).

Is there anything saying that this is immaterial to the policy and due to hassle and if a problem just taking him off (never drives car) - surely if they still do cancel they need to give a refund as no policy doc's or any hard copy information was ever sent?

Any help from PH much appreciated!
Non Disclosure. Thats a good enough reason form them to cancel. Could be classed as insurance fraud - so wehn you get another quote, or take out insirance and they ask if you have ever had insurance declined/refused etc you will ahver to say "YES" ??

personally, it isnt immaterial to the policy, its non disclosure. imagine if you had a crash and they then said your policy was invalid (which i hope you dont need them shortly...)


off_again

13,917 posts

264 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
Never quite understood insurance. Have a bike and a car, both insured. I have to tell the bike insurer about any accidents in the car and vice versa. Yet any no claims on a bike doesnt transfer to the car... all the penalties and none of the gains. Their rules, we loose.

Odd.

FlashmanChop

1,300 posts

236 months

Thursday 31st January 2013
quotequote all
Always rememeber, that when they say calls are/may be recorded, they are. This can go against you, or for you.

I have used it twice to my benefit.

One insurance company were trying to wriggle out of increasing my property insurance 40%, which I hadn’t noticed for 10 Months. The girl on the phone went back and listened to my conversation taking out the policy at the time. I was correct, sales guy had made an error.