Nissan qashqai 4x4 or Nissan x trail
Nissan qashqai 4x4 or Nissan x trail
Author
Discussion

brough74

Original Poster:

130 posts

192 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Im looking for a 4x4 for going down farm tracks, lonnings and crossing a wet field now and again. I wont be using it for towing just need a decent boot for 3 springers.

After looking at a qashqai, qashqai+2 and an x trail this moring all would fit the bill.

The only difference are that the x trail has hill decent which would be good for winter on slippery hills also the boot lid lifts higher on an x trail where as on the qashqai i would bang my head, until i was used to it.

So which will be best ? FIGHT lol

It wont be brand new and my maximum budget is £20k and it will be a tekna spec for the leather and xenons.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
brough74 said:
So which will be best?
Freelander 2

HTH smile

slinky

15,704 posts

280 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Freelander 2

HTH smile
Did you not read the OP?

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
slinky said:
Did you not read the OP?
Yes. They said they have £20k for a used vehicle. They only said they were looking at Nissans, not they it had to be one. From the use they describe I think an FL2 would be a better vehicle.

Andurron

1,599 posts

168 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
QQ is unlikely to be that much help. I'd also avoid the +2 as there's next to no space in the back, even for those in the 2 seats. Stick with X-trails or Freelanders or the like, mate.

brough74

Original Poster:

130 posts

192 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
It has to be a nissan NOT a freelander as ive had bad experiences in the past with land rover.

It would be a qashqai with 4wd to clear that point up am i right to think that the qashqai pan roof does not open where as the xtrail does.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Ok, just curious why a Nissan though?

Personally I prefer the Rav4 to the Nissan offerings. Either that or go for the new to the UK Dacia Duster, it's basically an X-Trail drive system on what I think is a version of the QQ's platform. And for a heck of lot less money too.

SeldomSeenKid

525 posts

184 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Ok, just curious why a Nissan though?

Personally I prefer the Rav4 to the Nissan offerings. Either that or go for the new to the UK Dacia Duster, it's basically an X-Trail drive system on what I think is a version of the QQ's platform. And for a heck of lot less money too.
This isn't a bad shout, the Duster has been getting decent reviews.

It's basic, sure, but for me, that adds to the charm of it. Reminds me of a 'baby Defender' in the sense that it doesn't try to hide it's utilitarian purpose. smile

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
SeldomSeenKid said:
This isn't a bad shout, the Duster has been getting decent reviews.

It's basic, sure, but for me, that adds to the charm of it. Reminds me of a 'baby Defender' in the sense that it doesn't try to hide it's utilitarian purpose. smile
Actually it's not all that basic and a million miles away from a Defender in utilitarian feel.

excel monkey

4,814 posts

258 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Andurron said:
QQ is unlikely to be that much help. I'd also avoid the +2 as there's next to no space in the back, even for those in the 2 seats.
Surely a Qashqai would cope with the very light off-road use that the OP has described? Agree that the third row of seats is useless in the QQ+2, but its a longer car than the standard QQ with more bootspace for the OP's 3 dogs when the third row of seats is folded into the boot floor.

billzeebub

3,912 posts

230 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Neither of those. Trust me, it's a Subaru Forester you need! Ideally the XT model

welaye

72 posts

172 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
If it has to be a choice from Qashqai or X trail then I would choose X trail everytime.

I had both of these as a company lease car during my time at Nissan and I couldn't stand the Qashqai with its oversized wheels as standard.

skyrover

12,700 posts

235 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Qashqai is built just down the road from me so do the right thing and support your local countrymen wink

On the other hand it does share an uncomfortable amount of DNA with Renault

Might be best to stick with a proper jap car

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Mazda CX-7

A3tdi

268 posts

214 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Buy something a bit more 'proper'..



2008
4x4
33,000 miles
Automatic
3.0LDiesel
£18k

When taking into account the cars you are looking at in comparison to this, over the period of ownership you're most likely to lose an equal amount of money (with a bit of man maths).

excel monkey

4,814 posts

258 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
A3tdi said:
Buy something a bit more 'proper'..

[picture of 5 year old Touraeg]
I saw the "man maths" caveat, but are you suggesting that the running costs of an out-of-warranty Touraeg are even remotely comparable to a new-ish small Jap 4x4?

They're nice looking cars, but not cheap to run, no?

Edited by excel monkey on Friday 8th February 14:17

brough74

Original Poster:

130 posts

192 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Need a bit more clearence than an estate car can give, not keen on the Rav 4 side opening rear door and not keen on the Dacia as the qashqai+2 and x trail have a bigger boot than it.

A nissan is nice and compact (not to wide) so it fits into a standard car park space and garage, plus the nissan garage is only a few miles away.

RichTBiscuit

440 posts

182 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
Subaru Legacy Outback.

End of discussion wink

Luke.

12,043 posts

281 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all
RichTBiscuit said:
Subaru Legacy Outback.

End of discussion wink
Which is what I went for. Amazing car, but f'ing thirsty. Far more so than my old Boxster S.

RichTBiscuit

440 posts

182 months

Friday 8th February 2013
quotequote all