How low should you go?
Author
Discussion

thismonkeyhere

Original Poster:

11,850 posts

262 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
I've always been in the habit of re-ruelling once the fuel light has come on. However, a read of the handbook for my recently acquired commuting-thing says something along the lines of 'It is a good idea not to drop below a quarter of a tank'.

Is there a car-wellbeing reason for this that I have not heard of, or are they just trying to protect the hard-of-thinking from running out of fuel?

sunbeam alpine

7,251 posts

219 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
We've got some tractors and vans with common-rail diesel engines. I know the garage says that running out of fuel is a bad thing, something about lubrication?

crosseyedlion

2,382 posts

229 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
All the detritus tends to gather at the bottom of the tank. Running it really low increases the likely hood of this ending up in your fuel lines. Yes the filter should catch it, but then that's more blocked up than it could be. Not good.

Running a performance car with less than perfect fuel delivery can cause severe wallet lightening.

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
Always been told it can dredge up the crud at the bottom of the tank.

thismonkeyhere

Original Poster:

11,850 posts

262 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
Interesting - it is a common rail diesel, also the tank sludge aspect hadn't occurred to me.

Maybe I'd better re-think my refuel plan, which is currently based around 'can't be arsed to go to a filling station more often than I absolutely must'.

Charlie Michael

2,753 posts

215 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
What happens if you regularly let it go to say 15-20 miles left (hovering above the red in my car) all the time - surely there won't be any dregs or crud to be sucked up into the fuel lines?



Edited by Charlie Michael on Friday 1st March 13:31

wolf1

3,103 posts

281 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
All fuel tanks draw fuel from the lowest part of the fuel tank so the crap in your tank myth is exactly that.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
crosseyedlion said:
All the detritus tends to gather at the bottom of the tank. Running it really low increases the likely hood of this ending up in your fuel lines. Yes the filter should catch it, but then that's more blocked up than it could be. Not good.

Running a performance car with less than perfect fuel delivery can cause severe wallet lightening.
However isn't the fuel line also at the bottom of the tank in most cases?

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
crosseyedlion said:
All the detritus tends to gather at the bottom of the tank. Running it really low increases the likely hood of this ending up in your fuel lines.
Yes, I know most fuel pumps only take their fuel from the top of the tank...

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
I tend to refuel at/just below a quarter of a tank, mainly because the last time I let it go lower i got stuck in a traffic jam and almost ran out.

HustleRussell

26,711 posts

191 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
wolf1 said:
All fuel tanks draw fuel from the lowest part of the fuel tank so the crap in your tank myth is exactly that.
I agree.
That said, you don't want to run out of fuel with a modern diesel engine because it can cause damage to the fuel pumps which are lubricated only by the fuel oil, Also priming the fuelling system with diesel after it has drawn air can be a total pain.

crosseyedlion

2,382 posts

229 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
crosseyedlion said:
All the detritus tends to gather at the bottom of the tank. Running it really low increases the likely hood of this ending up in your fuel lines. Yes the filter should catch it, but then that's more blocked up than it could be. Not good.

Running a performance car with less than perfect fuel delivery can cause severe wallet lightening.
However isn't the fuel line also at the bottom of the tank in most cases?
Yes but when its really low there's a greater probability of it pulling fuel + crud rather than just fuel. When low the fuel at the bottom will also move around much more unsettling it, rather than when there's more fuel and it'll remain fairly stationary.

You've never looked at the bottom of a fuel tank?
Get a glass with some sort of loose sediment in the bottom, fill it up half way with water and move it around. Observe the sediment.
Now do the same with barely any water and do the same. wink

HustleRussell

26,711 posts

191 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
crosseyedlion said:
never looked at the bottom of a fuel tank?
Yep. It was a 1998 Skoda Felicia which had done 90,000 miles and there was perhaps a teaspoon full of grit at the bottom.
Fuel tanks are made of plastic these days, and the fuel is cleaner.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
I go as low as my next journey + 50%. If I can't do it, it get's brimmed.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
crosseyedlion said:
never looked at the bottom of a fuel tank?
Yep. It was a 1998 Skoda Felicia which had done 90,000 miles and there was perhaps a teaspoon full of grit at the bottom.
Fuel tanks are made of plastic these days, and the fuel is cleaner.
Not to mention that you've got a very decent fuel filter that can more than absorb that much crap. Nowadays it's the ballache of having to re-prime fuel systems etc (and possible damage to pumps etc)

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
crosseyedlion said:
Get a glass with some sort of loose sediment in the bottom, fill it up half way with water and move it around. Observe the sediment.
Now do the same with barely any water and do the same. wink
you could half the amount of washing up by doing it in the other order

yellowjack

18,551 posts

197 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
Got the Mondeo home last night with a range of 7 miles remaining. Wife got out, and I reversed it up the (narrow) driveway. By the time it reached the top (three car lengths) it said 0 miles remaining. Cursing myself for not refuelling on the way home I nipped back out to fill it up. 5 miles later I pulled in to a forecourt, and put £95 worth into the tank. Ford reckon the Mondeo has a "usable capacity" of 70 litres, but I could only squeeze 66 into the tank. That should mean that I was 4 litres away from running out of fuel, and it definitely means that the gauge/fuel computer is a pessimistic beast. Even at a low 40mpg, 4 litres should carry me 35 miles. As it is, as soon as the indicated range drops below 70 miles, the refuelling light illuminates on the screen.

I only ever ran out of fuel once. In my first car, a Ford Cortina MkV estate, in the New Forest. We were approaching either Brockenhurst or Lyndhurst, and the wife was going mental about being stranded in the middle of nowhere. The car was spluttering and coughing, and eventually ran out at the top of a hill. Fortunately for me, at the bottom of that hill was a filling station, to which we coasted gently. After pushing it the last few yards to the pump and bunging a tenner's worth in, it fired right up and off we went again. In stony silence, on account of how "I warned you this morning you should have put some petrol in, but you never listen to me!".

I think that these days, with the distance between garages larger, as a result of the drop in the numbers of independent forecourts, and with more diesel cars about, fuel gauges have actually got less accurate in the hope that they persuade you to fill up before it's absolutely essential. Running out of fuel would not be a good idea in a diesel, but at six months old there shouldn't be too much sediment sloshing around at the bottom of the tank. Still, I don't think I'll make a habit of running things that low again.

ETA: I did run out of fuel a second time. But that was my own fault. I deliberately decided to drive past the forecourt with the 'expensive' fuel because I knew there was a cheaper supplier 2 miles up the road. I nearly made it too, but for all the money I saved at the second supplier, I ended up spending more to buy a plastic can to get enough fuel to the car to drive onto the forecourt. Lesson learned. These days I have a better developed ability to estimate my range, and like it's been mentioned above, I make sure that I have more than enough fuel to complete my next journey before I set out.

Edited by yellowjack on Friday 1st March 13:59

HustleRussell

26,711 posts

191 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
yellowjack said:
Got the Mondeo home last night with a range of 7 miles remaining. Wife got out, and I reversed it up the (narrow) driveway. By the time it reached the top (three car lengths) it said 0 miles remaining. Cursing myself for not refuelling on the way home I nipped back out to fill it up. 5 miles later I pulled in to a forecourt, and put £95 worth into the tank. Ford reckon the Mondeo has a "usable capacity" of 70 litres, but I could only squeeze 66 into the tank. That should mean that I was 4 litres away from running out of fuel, and it definitely means that the gauge/fuel computer is a pessimistic beast. Even at a low 40mpg, 4 litres should carry me 35 miles. As it is, as soon as the indicated range drops below 70 miles, the refuelling light illuminates on the screen.
I wouldn't worry, I once ran my Mondeo TDCI 38 miles beyond the OBC telling me I had '0' miles! I have also definitely squeezed more than 70L in the tank before...

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
wolf1 said:
All fuel tanks draw fuel from the lowest part of the fuel tank so the crap in your tank myth is exactly that.
hehe

There is actually a very good reason not to run my car (MY2012 Merc SLK250CDi) out of diesel, as I discovered coming back from Cadwell Park last year. This will probably be the same for any new Merc.

I ended up running the car right down - I really thought I was going to run out, however out in the wilds of Lincs sometimes petrol stations are hard to come by. Running it so low (the car was still running fine and I did get fuel) caused the engine management light to come on, necessitating a visit to MB to get it sorted out. I won't do that again!


Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Friday 1st March 2013
quotequote all
wolf1 said:
All fuel tanks draw fuel from the lowest part of the fuel tank so the crap in your tank myth is exactly that.
Yes. Such risk as there is comes from anything which may be FLOATING on the fuel in the tank.