Change or not to change?
Change or not to change?
Author
Discussion

Andy ap

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

203 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
I'm thinking of changing my Cupra for something with four doors, estate possibly a decent big enough engine with a nice sound track, but has got to be comfortably with 45 or above profile tyres and critically be good on insurance. As the cupra keeps complicating things by the insurance dropping every year even though i want to change it. Budget is less than 4000, and ideally around 3500 i'd like to pay for the replacement.

The shortlist is:

Mk1 Ocatvia Vrs (estate or hatch)
X-type 3.0 (estate or saloon)
MG ZT 190 (no sold on the ZT-T for some reason)
Mondeo ST220 (estate would be nice)
last of all a WRX as its not kind on insurance being in Liverpool

I don't use my car that much, mainly at weekends but id say 75-80% of my driving is in built up areas and the roads around here are appalling so ride quality is a major concern. Again fueling doesn't bother me too much but a car that can run happily on 95 ron would be nice. Id like to be able to easily fit two mountain bikes in the back and with the exception of the MG keep the overall size down as we like to go walking so don't want to go piloting a barge down narrow lanes. I understand insurance is subjective but the cupra looks like its dropping to below 700/yr now and most of the others in the list are around a grand to insure!!!

Fleckers

2,880 posts

232 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
x type is a Mondeao in a dress, not bad
ST220 is a jag not in a dress, not bad

I had a ZT-T SE260 loved it
I had a Scooby loved it

what would I get, depends on money and condition, MG ZT-t or the X type


Andy ap

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

203 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Mg zt is better value for money than the x type and easier to find. Definately tempted by one.

Andy ap

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

203 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Think i've decided on a mk1 Octavia vrs with around 60-70k on the clock. Same basic car as my Cupra but with working suspension laugh and 'proper real world' tyres so all the usuall 1.8t traits are known and should be looked for.

Dont know how hard i can test drive it so any pointers from experienced owners with relation to brakes, handling, bushes and steering. Etc.