Accident advice (head on, one way street!)
Accident advice (head on, one way street!)
Author
Discussion

fatsuperman

Original Poster:

41 posts

164 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Hi there,

Apologies if this is in the wrong forum, I can't remember my details so had to create a new account and can't post in speed, plod etc...!

Yesterday during the snow carnage, a 4x4-owning friend had kindly gave me a lift home. On his way back to his he drove around a blind corner and crashed head-on into a car being pushed up the hill. As in, a car on the wrong side of the road. The road is actually splits into two one-way roads, it's not clear to me yet whether the other guy was on the wrong side or on the wrong road, but I guess that should be immaterial - either way he's going the wrong way!

Insurers are suggesting it's my friend's fault, since he's crashed into the other party! This boggles my mind, especially since technically they crashed into each other, at varying speeds (one at 15 mph, one at 1 mph). Nobody was hurt, both cars drove away (well, the other guy continued pushing his) but there is a lot of cosmetic damage to the front of both vehicles

Anyone got any advice or links to somewhere that might help shed some light on the fault here?

Thanks,
Dave

R0G

5,037 posts

186 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
If the other vehicle was stationary or virtually so at the time just prior to impact then your friend has hit a stationary vehicle no matter which way it is pointing

Kong

1,503 posts

202 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like your mate is at fault if he couldn't stop for a car going 1mph in the other direction. I could be wrong though smile

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Agreed. You should be able to stop in the distance you can see to be clear.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
If the other car was almost stationary then it's going to be the same result as crashing into a parked stopped car.

Sounds like you mate was overdriving his brakes and visibilty.

The exact layout if the blind corner might change things a little though.


fatsuperman

Original Poster:

41 posts

164 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Thanks chaps... I may not have made this clear - it has been snowing non-stop, this is on a blind bend, he braked and just slid into the other car. He was only going about 15mph and probably didn't expect to meet a car going the wrong way.

The car wasn't stationary but that may be a technicality. I'm surprised that people have this opinion, but obviously I'm massively biased!

Notes on cars as stationary objects from citizens advice:

Stationary or fixed objects

If someone hits a stationary object, either on the road itself or alongside the road, they should consider the following:-

was the object adequately marked or lit to enable the driver to see it clearly and in time to avoid it, for example, an unlit car, skip or roadworks. If not, it will be necessary to find out who was responsible for failing to do so. For example, if the object was a parked car, the responsible person is the owner.

had the object been left on the road either unlawfully or in an unsafe way, for example, a car parked on a blind corner. If so, the owner of the object or vehicle may be liable


R0G

5,037 posts

186 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Why would anyone elect to push a car up a hill?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Is 15mph too fast for a blind corner in the snow?

Was it dark?
Was the other car lit?

How blind was the corner?
How far did the car slide before impact?

Had it not been snowing would you mate have been able to stop in time?

fatsuperman

Original Poster:

41 posts

164 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
A good question R0G, I'd go the other way! I assume he lives at the top. To be fair he actually had other people pushing, he was in the car steering. I suppose I'd go uphill as well - if someone else was pushing smile

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Your friend was driving too fast for the conditions if he was unable to stop for or avoid a static (or near static) object, regardless of its positioning or direction. If it was a blind bend in the snow, he should have backed off to a near walking pace, he would then have been able to stop.


kambites

71,701 posts

252 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
There's no law against reversing down a one-way street - it would make parallel parking on them rather hard if there was. Sounds like your friend was just going too fast for the conditions - just because he was only doing 15mph doesn't mean he wasn't going too fast.

Edited by kambites on Tuesday 12th March 11:37

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
fatsuperman said:
Thanks chaps... I may not have made this clear - it has been snowing non-stop, this is on a blind bend, he braked and just slid into the other car. He was only going about 15mph and probably didn't expect to meet a car going the wrong way.

The car wasn't stationary but that may be a technicality. I'm surprised that people have this opinion, but obviously I'm massively biased!
He has my sympathies, and in the same situation most people may well have met the same fate, but the principle remains: he couldn't stop in the distance he could see to be clear.

A more precise definition of that might be, 'the distance he could see to be, and reasonably expect to remain, clear'. So, if a car came around a bend on a one way street at speed, the distance he could see to be clear one second might be unexpectedly shortened the next, and he could have a case. In this instance the other car was effectively stationary.

You could argue that the other driver was doing something irresponsible and dangerous, and you might reduce liability in this way (I'm not a lawyer), but fundamentally your friend drove in a manner that led to the accident.

R0G

5,037 posts

186 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
To the OP -

How would you view this if your mate had collided with a stationary vehicle which had earlier spun around and was facing the wrong way ?

I think we can say that 1 mph would be deemed as stationary ?

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Snow carnage?

OH COME ON YOU LOT.

fatsuperman

Original Poster:

41 posts

164 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all


Hmmm, ok thanks for opinions folks. I must admit I'm pretty surprised at the amount of people saying it would be my friends fault. Frankly nobody should have been out in the conditions, but you don't know they haven't gritted the roads until it's too late - you are out and need to get home. I left my car at work as it would have been a disaster.

Have found the road on G maps, the guy was apparently at this junction (below), being pushed into the one-way st (the bit where the no entry sign is)

http://goo.gl/maps/cOJu7

So it's not totally blind, but it's dark and snowing. He should have been going slower - at 5mph he still would have hit the guy unfortunately.

kambites

71,701 posts

252 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
If he still would have hit it had he been travelling at 5mph, he was lucky not to cause a pretty serious injury at 15!

fatsuperman

Original Poster:

41 posts

164 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
"How would you view this if your mate had collided with a stationary vehicle which had earlier spun around and was facing the wrong way ?
I think we can say that 1 mph would be deemed as stationary ?"

R0G, personally I wouldn't deem anything moving as stationary, but I take your point. tongue out

The 15mph bit I've just estimated, he wasn't sure but he knows it wasn't fast - it could have been a bit faster or slower. The damage is only cosmetic so I can't imagine it would be much faster.

I'm not saying my friend is in the right here, I think he's accepted it's going to be on him, I'm just asking for second opinions and whether anyone's been in a similar situation.

Sump

5,512 posts

198 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Was there snow carnage?

We had a light dusting up north, but nothing even remotely close to carnage?

Xtremescoobys

123 posts

165 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Give me strength!
Simple maths Snow + Car = No Stoppy
Would give you advice but havent take my Touretts pills today

fatsuperman

Original Poster:

41 posts

164 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
I was being a bit facetious on the carnage front – that’s how it’s been reported. But yep, it started snowing heavily and settled. There roads hadn't been prepared, or not well at least.