Three attempts for dealer to fix used car
Three attempts for dealer to fix used car
Author
Discussion

eatontrifles

Original Poster:

1,442 posts

265 months

Monday 25th March 2013
quotequote all
The OH bought a used car around a month ago and at the time we noticed a squeal from the PAS at almost full lock so asked the seller (a normal medium sized independent used car place, not main dealer) to fix it before we collected, which they agreed to do and it was written on the sale receipt.
When we picked the car up it was warm (the weather!) so there didn't seem to be a problem but on starting the car from cold the following morning the squeal was still present, even when not on lock. I took the car back for it to be fixed and the dealer told us that they replaced two belts and the car was returned to us. This still didn't fix it, so it went back again and this time the seller told us they had fitted a new alternator. The car hasn't been driven since then due to the weather and I have just tried it this evening, and while it is a little better the squeal still isn't gone.
With the headlights on, turning the wheel to around 80% lock causes a noticeable dimming of the lights and the squeal starts. Put the heated screen on and the squeal is almost ever present when turning the wheel. I know that when the car warms up the squeal goes away and can only be reproduced in extreme circumstances (AC, heated window, PAS on max load, lights etc). It's a 1.5 2006 Suzuki Swift with FSH and we paid pretty much top money for it so I wouldn't expect there to be any faults (and to be fair this is the only thing).

The OH is going to call the garage tomorrow to express her displeasure and I've told her that she needs to tell them that they've had enough chances to fix it themselves (they have a small on-site workshop) and we now want it to go to a main dealer to be fixed. If they don't agree then we want a refund.

What are the PH opinions?


(TLDR; Bought a used car, trade seller agreed to fix small fault as a condition of sale but didn't, have had it back twice now to fix and it still isn't sorted.)

eatontrifles

Original Poster:

1,442 posts

265 months

Tuesday 26th March 2013
quotequote all
I should probably point out that the car has only done around 200 miles since we bought it and most of that was on a single motorway journey.

Edited by eatontrifles on Tuesday 26th March 12:53

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Tuesday 26th March 2013
quotequote all
I'm no expert, but I don't think that you'll be getting a full refund for that.

Tim

crmcatee

5,808 posts

258 months

Tuesday 26th March 2013
quotequote all
If you're turning the wheel to full lock without moving the wheels forward that's a sure way to knacker a PAS pump. I'd be complaining too smile

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Tuesday 26th March 2013
quotequote all
Maybe worth getting someone to tell you what the actual problem is, that way you can be a bit more informed about what the garage is up to when the car gors back in.

curlie467

7,650 posts

232 months

Tuesday 26th March 2013
quotequote all
They wont send it to a main dealer so forget about that one.

It is tough as hell getting a full refund, I did it once after the garage refused to do the job (cracked head that they failed to diagnose after it going back 5 times and having lots of time and parts thrown at it).

You need to give them the chance to fix it (even if it has been back a few times).

Don`t worry about it, it` just a car. wink

eatontrifles

Original Poster:

1,442 posts

265 months

Tuesday 26th March 2013
quotequote all
catman said:
I'm no expert, but I don't think that you'll be getting a full refund for that.

Tim
A partial refund would be fine - just enough to pay for whatever is causing the noise (I suspect a pulley or tensioner).
crmcatee said:
If you're turning the wheel to full lock without moving the wheels forward that's a sure way to knacker a PAS pump. I'd be complaining too smile
The wheels are only being turned like that to check for the noise - not that the car has to be stationary for it to occur, it happened a few times pulling out of the drive. Often when cold, the screech appears on it's own and lasts for a couple of minutes in normal driving.
Matt UK said:
Maybe worth getting someone to tell you what the actual problem is, that way you can be a bit more informed about what the garage is up to when the car gors back in.
Agreed - and I'd pass the info straight on to the garage to help them.
curlie467 said:
They wont send it to a main dealer so forget about that one.

It is tough as hell getting a full refund, I did it once after the garage refused to do the job (cracked head that they failed to diagnose after it going back 5 times and having lots of time and parts thrown at it).

You need to give them the chance to fix it (even if it has been back a few times).

Don`t worry about it, it` just a car. wink
We don't want to have to try and return it - other than this it's a good car and we saw a fair few of the same model before deciding.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Usually(ho ho - assumption being the mother of all sorts of mistakes wink ) the PAS and Alternator are driven by seperate belts. The HRW being 'on' may well have brought the engine revs down? This will then put the PAS belt under duress and may have made it squeal due to a comparative lack of torque, and that condition is a pink fish (red herring)?

Replacing the Alternator is another pink fish - the "squealing belt" still happens under duress, doesn't it? - when the engine and environment is cold and the steering is turned, as the belt will be less flexible than when all is warm scratchchin . Nowt to do with the Alternator wink .

Easy check is to spray some Duck Oil on the PAS belt and see how it behaves - one can do this one's self wink . WD40 will have a similar effect. The squealing sound should stop, albeit temporarily.

Then report back to the garage and ask for a new PAS Belt to be fitted and see how that goes... Could be a stiff PAS Pump, but that will become apparent...

I can't believe they have picensoreded about thus far, it's not complicated rolleyes .

405dogvan

5,329 posts

296 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
You can forget the car going to a main dealer and forget getting a full refund - the best you're going to get is the fault fixed IF it's actually a fault.

Consumer law suggests you should return the car and say you don't want it back until the fault is rectified and they're demonstrated that. That puts the ball in their court completely.

In the event they decline to accept it or fail to demonstrate a repair in a reasonable timeframe (not defined but 1-2 weeks is about right) then you can start making a fuss about loss of use of the car and all that stuff, but ideally they'll just fix it, show you it's fixed and you can all get back to dancing in the moonlight.

Remember that they could just say "they all do that and it's not a problem" and you're then into a world of farting about getting 2nd opinions and other nonsense which will cost you more in time and effort than taking it to a main dealer and being reamed by them - sometimes you should maybe cut your losses, use the fking thing and see what happens...

Edited by 405dogvan on Wednesday 27th March 01:05

eatontrifles

Original Poster:

1,442 posts

265 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
405dogvan said:
you should maybe cut your losses, use the fking thing and see what happens...
The lack of miles isn't anything to do with the noise - just a coincidence of timing & the weather. The OH still gets the train to work until she gets up a bit more driving confidence. For sure, the noise isn't helping but it's not the main reason.
aw51 121565 said:
Usually(ho ho - assumption being the mother of all sorts of mistakes wink ) the PAS and Alternator are driven by seperate belts. The HRW being 'on' may well have brought the engine revs down? This will then put the PAS belt under duress and may have made it squeal due to a comparative lack of torque, and that condition is a pink fish (red herring)?

Replacing the Alternator is another pink fish - the "squealing belt" still happens under duress, doesn't it? - when the engine and environment is cold and the steering is turned, as the belt will be less flexible than when all is warm scratchchin . Nowt to do with the Alternator wink .

Easy check is to spray some Duck Oil on the PAS belt and see how it behaves - one can do this one's self wink . WD40 will have a similar effect. The squealing sound should stop, albeit temporarily.

Then report back to the garage and ask for a new PAS Belt to be fitted and see how that goes... Could be a stiff PAS Pump, but that will become apparent...

I can't believe they have picensoreded about thus far, it's not complicated rolleyes .
Good info - thanks. thumbup

THE OH spoke to the garage and it's going back in next week. They said that they'll keep trying until it's fixed and they were genuinely sure that a new alternator would sort it, or they wouldn't have spent £120 on one. If I get a chance at the weekend I'll have a look myself & see if I can work out where the noise is coming from, although I'd expect - and hope - that the mechanics at the garage would have more of an idea than me. I do suspect a tensioner or pulley though.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Or the belt tensioner itself not doing it's job.

On a side note. VAG stuff has an issue with the alternator pulley mechanism seizing. (The actual pulley not the shaft of the alternator has a one way freewheel on it) Not sure if it affects other makes

confused_buyer

7,143 posts

212 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
On a 7 year old car with a bit of a noise they could probably tell you to get lost under any consumer legislation. A 7 year old car does not have to be perfect.

They seem like they're trying to help so I'd recommend letting them help you.

pmjg66

2,789 posts

245 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
crmcatee said:
If you're turning the wheel to full lock without moving the wheels forward that's a sure way to knacker a PAS pump. I'd be complaining too smile
That could be difficult with EPS wink

Dodsy

7,175 posts

258 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
I had a fault with my last car, a used Jag XJ8. All the fault lights would come on and the PAS would cut out while driving. This started within a week of me buying the car. Ended up spending nearly 4 months out of 6 off the road while they tried to fix it, in the end they had to repair the main ECU and replace the entire instrument cluster, in total around £1500. When they finally fixed it they demanded £500 towards the cost before they would release the car. I had to pay ad I needed the car back. And they managed to break the glovebox when they took the dash apart which I had to get fixed at my own cost.

The deadline for them to refund all my costs is friday this week but they arent playing ball so we will be off to court in April.

My point ? Make sure they confirm that they are fixing at their cost to save you a trip to court.


750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
aw51 121565 said:
Usually(ho ho - assumption being the mother of all sorts of mistakes wink ) the PAS and Alternator are driven by seperate belts. The HRW being 'on' may well have brought the engine revs down? This will then put the PAS belt under duress and may have made it squeal due to a comparative lack of torque, and that condition is a pink fish (red herring)?

Replacing the Alternator is another pink fish - the "squealing belt" still happens under duress, doesn't it? - when the engine and environment is cold and the steering is turned, as the belt will be less flexible than when all is warm scratchchin . Nowt to do with the Alternator wink .

Easy check is to spray some Duck Oil on the PAS belt and see how it behaves - one can do this one's self wink . WD40 will have a similar effect. The squealing sound should stop, albeit temporarily.

Then report back to the garage and ask for a new PAS Belt to be fitted and see how that goes... Could be a stiff PAS Pump, but that will become apparent...

I can't believe they have picensoreded about thus far, it's not complicated rolleyes .
FFS, we have a real mechanic in our mists, do not let him escape. wink

Seriously OP, listen to this man.

pmjg66

2,789 posts

245 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
750turbo said:
aw51 121565 said:
Usually(ho ho - assumption being the mother of all sorts of mistakes wink ) the PAS and Alternator are driven by seperate belts. The HRW being 'on' may well have brought the engine revs down? This will then put the PAS belt under duress and may have made it squeal due to a comparative lack of torque, and that condition is a pink fish (red herring)?

Replacing the Alternator is another pink fish - the "squealing belt" still happens under duress, doesn't it? - when the engine and environment is cold and the steering is turned, as the belt will be less flexible than when all is warm scratchchin . Nowt to do with the Alternator wink .

Easy check is to spray some Duck Oil on the PAS belt and see how it behaves - one can do this one's self wink . WD40 will have a similar effect. The squealing sound should stop, albeit temporarily.

Then report back to the garage and ask for a new PAS Belt to be fitted and see how that goes... Could be a stiff PAS Pump, but that will become apparent...

I can't believe they have picensoreded about thus far, it's not complicated rolleyes .
FFS, we have a real mechanic in our mists, do not let him escape. wink

Seriously OP, listen to this man.
The general advice here is good,although the car does not have a pas pump as its electric.

Its electrical so turning the steering causes more current draw on the alternator which causes the belt to slip and exaggerates with lights/hrw etc.

If new belts have been fitted and correctly tensioned all should be fine,but I think the garage has just tried tightening the old worn belts without success.

Tell the garage to keep it and test for a few days.



MitchT

17,166 posts

240 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
Would this car have PAS fluid or is that just for ones with a pump system? Sorry, I'm no mechanic! I've found that low PAS fluid results in an unpleasant noise when applying a lot of lock or cornering hard. Might be irrelevant for this car though.

405dogvan

5,329 posts

296 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
eatontrifles said:
405dogvan said:
you should maybe cut your losses, use the fking thing and see what happens...
The lack of miles isn't anything to do with the noise - just a coincidence of timing & the weather.
I more meant something like - use it and see what happens - if something actually breaks, go back and say "your repair didn't work too well then" wheras if it just keeps working, where's the loss

How often do you get to full-lock anyway? Since my first car was a heap which knocked-like-mad on full lock I've avoided it ever since smile

eatontrifles

Original Poster:

1,442 posts

265 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
MitchT said:
Would this car have PAS fluid or is that just for ones with a pump system? Sorry, I'm no mechanic! I've found that low PAS fluid results in an unpleasant noise when applying a lot of lock or cornering hard. Might be irrelevant for this car though.
I didn't realise an 06 Swift had electric power steering! Are those who are saying it has sure of that?

405dogvan said:
I more meant something like - use it and see what happens - if something actually breaks, go back and say "your repair didn't work too well then" wheras if it just keeps working, where's the loss

How often do you get to full-lock anyway? Since my first car was a heap which knocked-like-mad on full lock I've avoided it ever since smile
I don't see the logic in waiting for something to potentially break and putting up with the noise. The fault was pointed out before we bought the car and the seller recognised it and agreed to rectify as part of the sale.

It's not just happening on full lock either (I did say this in my first post) - if the car is started from cold, quite often the squealing will just happens on its own when pulling off with partial steering input and stays for 1-2 minutes of normal driving.

I use full lock every time I go into and out of my drive, as well as pretty much every time I park. So that would equate to pretty much every time I drive... wink

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Thursday 28th March 2013
quotequote all
eatontrifles said:
MitchT said:
Would this car have PAS fluid or is that just for ones with a pump system? Sorry, I'm no mechanic! I've found that low PAS fluid results in an unpleasant noise when applying a lot of lock or cornering hard. Might be irrelevant for this car though.
I didn't realise an 06 Swift had electric power steering! Are those who are saying it has sure of that?
The Swift has a purely electrically assisted steering rack, no hydraulics at all. You'll find an 'EPS' light on the dashboard which should illuminate when you switch the ignition on, and should go out when the engine is started.