Is it fair to fear the modern common rail turbo diesel?
Is it fair to fear the modern common rail turbo diesel?
Author
Discussion

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Morning all.

A question I often ponder over, and always forget to make a thread on. Not the typical PH thread, but a current one.

Is it right to fear the modern turbo diesel cars? Because I do, and I hope that with this thread, I will either feel safe that others fear the same, or proven that they aren't much to fear at all.

Let me start by saying what exactly it is that scares me about the modern diesel engines:
  • DPFs, diesel pollution filters - introduced by the EU to cut emissions and black soot from derv engines, are they still a problem? I know a lot of people say they will only fail if you do little miles, but I've heard of them going on high milers just the same.
  • Complicated transmission - Dual Mass flywheels are nothing new, but they're still bloody expensive if they fail. This was the main reason I sold my 320d, as I thought I had a rattle from it (turns out it was a heatshield lol) but it was enough to put me off the car.
  • Common rail injectors - anyone with an early 2.0TDi VAG engine should be well aware of these failing, but they seem to be common on most things, and they are again, blooming expensive
  • Turbos - okay turbos need looking after in any application, but it's safe to assume you're average torque happy commuter in their cdti will ignore/not be aware of that
  • Manufacturers are clearly investing a lot of money, trying to squeeze the best fuel economy and performance from these engines, theyre bloody complicated and I dont understand them laugh
  • If any of the above break, you can pretty much kiss good bye to any fuel saving costs, and you've still got a very dull driving derv
I think about 10 years ago, VW sort of nailed it with their PD engines. Taxi drivers still favour the Octavia of that era in my area with the 1.9tdi. Previous to that, Peugeot made excellent, but frugal engines (made famous by the 405 Taxis and the 306 Dturbo). It is only in the past 10 years that manufacturers have evolved into making performance diesels, and they scare the st out of me.



I believe that manufacturers and consumers saw diesel engines as the economic, and reliable. I.e, the blue zone.

But where do modern diesels fit? The BMW 335d for example. 286bhp diesel engine delivering 40+ mpg. Surely that cannot be reliable? But then if you line it up next to a 335i, exactly how more reliable is a modern petrol engine? They have turbos, fancy clutches and gearboxes, complicated engines I don't understand lol.

I feel like theyre trying to get more and more into the centre, and theyre doing this with diesels. But buying any car hypothetically from that zone without a warranty is surely financial suicide.

I could have done with adding more points to that, such as comfort (ie toys) and handling characteristics, but you get the idea.

A diesel car I'm considering is a BMW E46 330d, or possibly a 5 series 530d. I've had a 320d before, and as I said previously, I sold it as I was too damn scared it would break and shaft me. I adored the chassis, but was feared of big bills to come. I ended up selling it for an old Honda with hope that I would just be trouble free for a while (Of course, I have been) but as I've just taken a new job with a pay rise, I'm considering getting back into the BMW game.

Have I got right to fear these engines? I am from Yorkshire, change is not good etc, but if any engineers of PH could put my mind at ease, or confirm my fears, please go ahead.

Discuss!

Dan


ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
go and get a nissan leaf

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Get the 3lr petrol n/a with a manual, much better car and much lower bork factor

Pig benis

1,076 posts

212 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
ging84 said:
go and get a nissan leaf
laugh

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Crusoe said:
Get the 3lr petrol n/a with a manual, much better car and much lower bork factor
I wonder what the running costs would be of a 330i vs an E36 M3 3.0 scratchchin

rumple

15,426 posts

182 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
DanielJames said:
Crusoe said:
Get the 3lr petrol n/a with a manual, much better car and much lower bork factor
I wonder what the running costs would be of a 330i vs an E36 M3 3.0 scratchchin
I looked into this, for me it was servicing costs, the economy and insurence were similar but the M3 needs servicing more often and you pay the M TAX on parts. I think the M3 is worth it, I just have other priorities these days.

cptsideways

13,902 posts

283 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
That graph needs an outer circle for age, as depreciation kicks in bork v value becomes a lot more of a problem.

Also it very much depends on the make of car, some are dreadful & true liabilities, others not so




AV12

5,346 posts

239 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
I think you have some good well reasoned points there Dan.

As ever the most reliable car is a normal aspirated engine, However all the clever tech (much of it still in it's infancy) will have its bearing on the used car market.

Cue this discussion turning into another derv arguement - instead of a technical one as it should do!

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
rumple said:
DanielJames said:
Crusoe said:
Get the 3lr petrol n/a with a manual, much better car and much lower bork factor
I wonder what the running costs would be of a 330i vs an E36 M3 3.0 scratchchin
I looked into this, for me it was servicing costs, the economy and insurence were similar but the M3 needs servicing more often and you pay the M TAX on parts. I think the M3 is worth it, I just have other priorities these days.
With an M3 though I could just have a one car garage in stead of the planned 2. I'll have to do some numbers

Can someone please explain what a "bork factor" is nuts

Bear Phils

891 posts

167 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
DanielJames said:
I wonder what the running costs would be of a 330i vs an E36 M3 3.0 scratchchin
Parts are the big problem, M parts hold a big premium. Otherwise, apart from insurance there can't be a big difference.

Edit: And bork factor is the rate at which your bank account funds will disappear if something goes wrong.

AnotherClarkey

3,698 posts

220 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
It is why I bought a Prius. Simpler and more reliable overall.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
DanielJames said:
Can someone please explain what a "bork factor" is nuts
Remember Captain Kirk?

This is b0rk factor 1 (sixth gen Fiesta):


...and this (the Audi RS6) is b0rk factor 9:

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Bear Phils said:
DanielJames said:
I wonder what the running costs would be of a 330i vs an E36 M3 3.0 scratchchin
Parts are the big problem, M parts hold a big premium. Otherwise, apart from insurance there can't be a big difference.

Edit: And bork factor is the rate at which your bank account funds will disappear if something goes wrong.
Just found this, I think I'm in love. I usually hate black cars with light interiors too, but this is so nice.

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/b...

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
AnotherClarkey said:
It is why I bought a Prius. Simpler and more reliable overall.
hehe

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Remember Captain Kirk?
I don't hehe

But I get what the bork factor is now. I presume the Audi Q7 V12 TDi is quite high up.

Pesky derv

SimonV8ster

13,039 posts

259 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
I think we need more graphs to understand this.

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
SimonV8ster said:
I think we need more graphs to understand this.
I could make one showing how your MX5 looks like a canal boat if you want? hehe

SimonV8ster

13,039 posts

259 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all

skyrover

12,700 posts

235 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
wouldn't touch a modern diesel with a barge pole...

Apart from the potential bills... I just prefer a large capacity petrol in every single way apart from fuel economy, and I don't really do enough miles to where that is a big factor.

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
DanielJames said:
Bear Phils said:
DanielJames said:
I wonder what the running costs would be of a 330i vs an E36 M3 3.0 scratchchin
Parts are the big problem, M parts hold a big premium. Otherwise, apart from insurance there can't be a big difference.

Edit: And bork factor is the rate at which your bank account funds will disappear if something goes wrong.
Just found this, I think I'm in love. I usually hate black cars with light interiors too, but this is so nice.

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/b...
eta

330ci insurance @ 21 - £840
M3 3.0 insurance @ 21 - £1490


frown