Greatest Manufacture v Real World mpg variance
Greatest Manufacture v Real World mpg variance
Author
Discussion

Billybluenose

Original Poster:

5 posts

164 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Both my dad and I are both looking at buying new cars at the moment and the sad git that I am, I traul the forums to find as much information as I can for both sets of cars. I'm after a hot-hatch (probably a new focus ST) and my dads after a big petrol german estate. What is surprising me at the moment is the enormous difference between quoted economy and real world.

Ford moved from the 5 pot 2.5 ST to the 4 pot 2.0 with the intention of getting better economy figures (as well as other emmissions regs). Ford are quoting 39mpg, but if you speak to people who own one, they are saying more like 24-27mpg. That's 35% less!

When I've looked at this in the past BMW were terrible culprits but seem to be ok (on petrol at least) from what I've seen compared to the Ford "lies" on the ST.

Are turbo's the reason? i.e. a manufacturer can get the car round a predefined circuit without the turbo turning on, but in real life driving you tend to use it all the time.

Can anyone claim greater descrepencies than the focus ST?

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Who says the people with them are driving them properly?

I kind of doubt someone with a new ST is driving it sensibly.

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Billybluenose said:
Are turbo's the reason? i.e. a manufacturer can get the car round a predefined circuit without the turbo turning on, but in real life driving you tend to use it all the time.
It's not so much the turbos as it is the tests themselves bearing no resemblance to real-world driving.

All manufacturers follow an EU mandated test so, in theory, their quoted figures are comparable to other manufacturers quoted figures. What they are not comparable to is actual driving conditions that you will encounter on a daily basis.

So, like for like, the figures are useful, for finding out actual mpg, pretty much useless.

Edited by Centurion07 on Wednesday 27th March 14:25

Andy665

4,217 posts

259 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
The manufacturers do not carry out the tests

All done by a third party on a rolling road with totally consistent conditions

The figures quoted in brochures / adverts etc are therefore not the manufacturers figures

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Only an indication but could be useful
http://www.honestjohn.co.uk/realmpg/

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
currybum said:
A best of 28mpg..worst of 26mpg and an average of 27mpg.
Alright, Carol Vorderman, no need to show off.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
Billybluenose said:
Are turbo's the reason? i.e. a manufacturer can get the car round a predefined circuit without the turbo turning on, but in real life driving you tend to use it all the time.
It's not so much the turbos as it is the tests themselves bearing no resemblance to real-world driving...
Or it's the real world driving that fails to take advantage of the way the cars have been optimised.

The governments have developed tests to help you save fuel.
The manufacturers have developed cars to excel in the tests.
The drivers haven't changed at all. Maybe they should consider driving like they are on the NEDC. It's easy, but dull.

SuperchargedVR6

3,138 posts

251 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Billybluenose said:
Are turbo's the reason? i.e. a manufacturer can get the car round a predefined circuit without the turbo turning on, but in real life driving you tend to use it all the time.
That's had me pondering the same ever since the recent move to smaller engines with turbos.

I can understand a reduction in mpg in dropping from a V8 to a V6 turbo whilst cruising. 2 fewer cylinders worth of friction and 2 fewer injectors. But if the n'asp V8 made say, 400hp at wide open throttle @ xxxxrpm, and so does the V6 turbo, then surely the same energy is required (i.e. fuel) to make 400hp? I.e. 6 larger injectors injecting the same fuel as 8 smaller ones.

So in other words, I don't think these smaller engines are any more efficient when in boost than an older, larger n'asp engine. And as modern turbo engines are all about lag free motoring, they're in boost frequently.

But claimed mpgs have always been wide of the mark under normal driving conditions. Really babying the engine and never exceeding any speed limits is the only real chance you'll get of achieving the claimed mpg.


tim2100

6,288 posts

288 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
BMW 120d. Quoted 60.1

At the moment I'm getting 34-35.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
I know the tests are quite interesting if you look into them. The one fact that I remember from reading an article in Evo about them is that for manual transmission cars the tests dictate a gear that you need to be in, regardless of the gearing of the car or efficiency profile of the engine at different revs. If the car is an automatic, then the automatic box is allowed to select the most appropriate gear. This means that autos get more favourable results than manuals.

Personally I've always found that for my cars my average mpg has been what they quote for urban, and my best motorway mpg is what they quote for extra-urban. So yes, they always estimate high, but I find it predictably high.

Billybluenose

Original Poster:

5 posts

164 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Captain Muppet said:
Or it's the real world driving that fails to take advantage of the way the cars have been optimised.

The governments have developed tests to help you save fuel.
The manufacturers have developed cars to excel in the tests.
The drivers haven't changed at all. Maybe they should consider driving like they are on the NEDC. It's easy, but dull.
My girlfriends 1.6 petrol car is the perfect example of this - it's quoted as about 55mpg or something, but the gearing is so "geared" towards these tests that the car is effectively useless in the real world. You have to be in 1st gear to get up a moderatly steep hill, so much so that the cars werr recalled in Mexico because people couldn't get up hills in them and were therefore deamed dangerous! You need to rag it so hard everywhere that it gets no more than low 30's mpg.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Billybluenose said:
You need to rag it so hard everywhere
I have a sneaking suspicion that this is an inappropriate use of the word 'need'.

SuperchargedVR6

3,138 posts

251 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
It's all a crock. If they quote 60mpg, then you should get 60mpg.

Maybe if I take out a car on finance, tell them I can pay £400 month, extra urban, £200 a month urban, but actually give them £100 a month.....

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Billybluenose said:
Both my dad and I are both looking at buying new cars at the moment and the sad git that I am, I traul the forums to find as much information as I can for both sets of cars. I'm after a hot-hatch (probably a new focus ST) and my dads after a big petrol german estate. What is surprising me at the moment is the enormous difference between quoted economy and real world.

Ford moved from the 5 pot 2.5 ST to the 4 pot 2.0 with the intention of getting better economy figures (as well as other emmissions regs). Ford are quoting 39mpg, but if you speak to people who own one, they are saying more like 24-27mpg. That's 35% less!

When I've looked at this in the past BMW were terrible culprits but seem to be ok (on petrol at least) from what I've seen compared to the Ford "lies" on the ST.

Are turbo's the reason? i.e. a manufacturer can get the car round a predefined circuit without the turbo turning on, but in real life driving you tend to use it all the time.

Can anyone claim greater descrepencies than the focus ST?
What is real world??

All MPG figures use NEDC to attain them.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Billybluenose said:
Captain Muppet said:
Or it's the real world driving that fails to take advantage of the way the cars have been optimised.

The governments have developed tests to help you save fuel.
The manufacturers have developed cars to excel in the tests.
The drivers haven't changed at all. Maybe they should consider driving like they are on the NEDC. It's easy, but dull.
My girlfriends 1.6 petrol car is the perfect example of this - it's quoted as about 55mpg or something, but the gearing is so "geared" towards these tests that the car is effectively useless in the real world. You have to be in 1st gear to get up a moderatly steep hill, so much so that the cars werr recalled in Mexico because people couldn't get up hills in them and were therefore deamed dangerous! You need to rag it so hard everywhere that it gets no more than low 30's mpg.
Part of the NEDC equates to an acceleration rate of 0-60 in 118 seconds.
If that is slower than you want to go then expect to buy more fuel.

What you lose going up hill you gain coming back down again. Not all of it, but that's what you get for not living in the Fens, and some would say it's worth every penny on fuel to not be in the Fens.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
SuperchargedVR6 said:
It's all a crock. If they quote 60mpg, then you should get 60mpg.

Maybe if I take out a car on finance, tell them I can pay £400 month, extra urban, £200 a month urban, but actually give them £100 a month.....
My MX5 is currently doing 0mph. It's claimed maximum speed is 112mph - that's 112mph wrong! Even when I was driving it this morning it wouldn't do more than 60mph, which is still only 54% of the speed it should be doing.

Unless somehow we all understand that to match performance figures we have to drive for performance.
In which case why do I struggle when I try to tell people that to match economy figures we have to drive for economy?

German

203 posts

178 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
They arent really "lies", if they were they would have been sued. They are given a test, make sure the car is good at it, and then tell you the MPG over the test. Its the test that is far removed from reality, which causes this discrepancy. Turbocharging helps during the test as with the ECE cycle at least you dont go anywhere near the RPM to be using the turbo. Google'd a picture of the curve, its up to 15km/h, stop. Up to 30, stop. up to 50, stop. Do that a few times, then up to 120km/h and back to zero. The rate of acceleration is also glacially slow. http://www.seai.ie/images_upload/Grants/Electric_V...

Fastdruid

9,413 posts

183 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Don't forget that roughly half of the test is spent stationary, so cars with stop start appear to be really good. Even if they're actually worse in the real world.

M Powered

349 posts

240 months

Wednesday 27th March 2013
quotequote all
Andy665 said:
The manufacturers do not carry out the tests

All done by a third party on a rolling road with totally consistent conditions

The figures quoted in brochures / adverts etc are therefore not the manufacturers figures
Sorry, but they do - the tests are independently witnessed by a third party. The witnessing party/agency varies depending on the country in which the test is conducted and the market for which you are doing the test.

It is just one test and intended to provide comparator data between vehicles.

GoneAnon

1,703 posts

183 months