The customer is always wrong...
Discussion
Had an exchange of emails today with a dealer that (to me at least) just beggars belief. I've copied it in below so you can tell me what you think, but first some background.
I'm shipping my Jaguar to New Zealand in a couple of weeks, where I'm going to spend a year, so I need a temporary replacement to use here in the UK while it's on the boat. By happy coincidence, an old friend, who now lives in Texas, wants a car to use while he's spending a few months back in the UK this summer. He's very particular about the exact model he wants, but it would work very well for me too, and he's sending me the money (£2500) for it up front, so I'll have free use of it until I leave the UK. So I have this cash to spend on this good, quality barge, and one good looking example pops up about 40 miles away. Not so far away, but not a trivial trip, so I dropped him a quick email to see if it was worth a trip....
Maybe I'm being unreasonable, but I don't think I am. It just frustrates me when, during a recession, a potential customer waving a wad of cash under your nose is seen as a nuisance. Obviously, this dealer will not be getting my business, the only shame is that the dealer will probably see this as proof that his initial assumption that I was a timewaster was right.
tl:dr - Reply below saying "Quite right! What a feckless eejit that dealer was - top rant: 10 out of 10"
I'm shipping my Jaguar to New Zealand in a couple of weeks, where I'm going to spend a year, so I need a temporary replacement to use here in the UK while it's on the boat. By happy coincidence, an old friend, who now lives in Texas, wants a car to use while he's spending a few months back in the UK this summer. He's very particular about the exact model he wants, but it would work very well for me too, and he's sending me the money (£2500) for it up front, so I'll have free use of it until I leave the UK. So I have this cash to spend on this good, quality barge, and one good looking example pops up about 40 miles away. Not so far away, but not a trivial trip, so I dropped him a quick email to see if it was worth a trip....
My Email said:
Hi,
I'm interested in the <car> you have in at the moment. Would you be able to answer a few questions about it for me?
1. Does it have a full service history? If so, is it at <brand> dealers or specialists?
2. Are there any faults with the equipment or any warning lights showing on the dash?
3. Does it have road tax?
4. Are there any cosmetic defects?
5. What condition are the tyres and what brand are they?
6. Has the car ever been smoked in, as far as you can tell?
If its good news, I'd like to come down to see the car next week.
I received this response:I'm interested in the <car> you have in at the moment. Would you be able to answer a few questions about it for me?
1. Does it have a full service history? If so, is it at <brand> dealers or specialists?
2. Are there any faults with the equipment or any warning lights showing on the dash?
3. Does it have road tax?
4. Are there any cosmetic defects?
5. What condition are the tyres and what brand are they?
6. Has the car ever been smoked in, as far as you can tell?
If its good news, I'd like to come down to see the car next week.
Dealer said:
Mr King
The vehicle is 11 years old and covered 112000 miles there is certain wear and tear on the vehicle which is commensurate with the age and mileage
Looking at your questions I feel this may not be the vehicle for you
Sent from my iPhone
Verily I am smacked of the gob. The ad clearly states the age and mileage, so he's either assumed that I haven't read it, or am of such low intellect and wisdom that I would assume that a car of this vintage and price would be pristine. Half of me wants to tell me where to stick his car and his attitude, but I like to give people the benefit of the doubt; maybe his wife just ran off with his best mate, or somebody just stiffed him for a short weasel on a late minty frogger - or something. I decide to communicate my confusion thusly:The vehicle is 11 years old and covered 112000 miles there is certain wear and tear on the vehicle which is commensurate with the age and mileage
Looking at your questions I feel this may not be the vehicle for you
Sent from my iPhone
Me again said:
I fear you may have misinterpreted my questions. I am well aware of the age and mileage of the car, but the purpose of my questions is to make sure that a cheap vehicle such as this doesn't quickly become very expensive due to underlying faults, lack of maintenance or other hidden expenses.
I'm not expecting a showroom fresh vehicle, but neither do I want it to land me with a massive bill, as that would rather defeat the point of a cheap car!
I am, in fact, a cash buyer with money waiting for this precise model, age and variant. This is the closest example to me currently available, which is why I'm hoping you'll take this second chance to answer a few straightforward questions.
I look forward to a more positive response.
Clearly this will do the trick - he'll be convinced I'm a serious buyer, and furnish me with the few germs of wisdom I need. Oh look, here comes a reply...I'm not expecting a showroom fresh vehicle, but neither do I want it to land me with a massive bill, as that would rather defeat the point of a cheap car!
I am, in fact, a cash buyer with money waiting for this precise model, age and variant. This is the closest example to me currently available, which is why I'm hoping you'll take this second chance to answer a few straightforward questions.
I look forward to a more positive response.
Dealerboy said:
Me king
The vehicle is on our forecourt and your more than welcome to view the vehicle
There is limited service history , no warning lights , bodywork is in good condition and interior is in reasonably good order , I do not know if the previous owner smoked and I really haven't got the time or inclination to look a tyre makes on a vehicle of this age or price
But as I said please inspect the vehicle and make your own mind up . But as I'm sure you will appreciate it is difficult to describe a vehicle via email as it depends on ones expectations
Sent from my iPhone
Now, I fully appreciate that this isn't a career-making sale for the dealer, but is it really too much to ask that he pop outside for a quick shuftie at the tax disc and to verify that it's not a pair of Nankang ditchfinder supremes that the previous owner has decided are suitable for transmitting 250 turbocharged horses to the tarmac under the front of the car? The vehicle is on our forecourt and your more than welcome to view the vehicle
There is limited service history , no warning lights , bodywork is in good condition and interior is in reasonably good order , I do not know if the previous owner smoked and I really haven't got the time or inclination to look a tyre makes on a vehicle of this age or price
But as I said please inspect the vehicle and make your own mind up . But as I'm sure you will appreciate it is difficult to describe a vehicle via email as it depends on ones expectations
Sent from my iPhone
Maybe I'm being unreasonable, but I don't think I am. It just frustrates me when, during a recession, a potential customer waving a wad of cash under your nose is seen as a nuisance. Obviously, this dealer will not be getting my business, the only shame is that the dealer will probably see this as proof that his initial assumption that I was a timewaster was right.
tl:dr - Reply below saying "Quite right! What a feckless eejit that dealer was - top rant: 10 out of 10"
Sorry but I have to say that I thought the dealers response was courteous and succinct. Were I he and I received your second email I would probably have told you to do one and subsequently ignored anything else you sent.
You aren't a customer. You are wrong. If that is the sum total of poor customer service I rather think you haven't been a customer in many situations.
You aren't a customer. You are wrong. If that is the sum total of poor customer service I rather think you haven't been a customer in many situations.
Magic919 said:
I feel some sympathy for the dealer at this point.
To be fair, they're not exactly difficult questions. Well, the smoking one I thought was a bit OTT but the rest seem completely reasonable. It would seemingly take a lot less effort for the dealer to check the details of those basic questions (and not be an arse about it) than it would be for a seller to drive there and check it themselves. To the OP: I'd just take from this the positive that you got to find out the dealer is a bit of a knob before you bought the car.
Edit: I see which way this thread is going, I'm out.

AlexKing said:
Had an exchange of emails today with a dealer that (to me at least) just beggars belief. I've copied it in below so you can tell me what you think, but first some background.
I'm shipping my Jaguar to New Zealand in a couple of weeks, where I'm going to spend a year, so I need a temporary replacement to use here in the UK while it's on the boat. By happy coincidence, an old friend, who now lives in Texas, wants a car to use while he's spending a few months back in the UK this summer. He's very particular about the exact model he wants, but it would work very well for me too, and he's sending me the money (£2500) for it up front, so I'll have free use of it until I leave the UK. So I have this cash to spend on this good, quality barge, and one good looking example pops up about 40 miles away. Not so far away, but not a trivial trip, so I dropped him a quick email to see if it was worth a trip....
Maybe I'm being unreasonable, but I don't think I am. It just frustrates me when, during a recession, a potential customer waving a wad of cash under your nose is seen as a nuisance. Obviously, this dealer will not be getting my business, the only shame is that the dealer will probably see this as proof that his initial assumption that I was a timewaster was right.
tl:dr - Reply below saying "Quite right! What a feckless eejit that dealer was - top rant: 10 out of 10"
Well done Mr Dealer for remaining civil. He's seen the car, he's seen that you're a picky buyer so he's honestly advised you to look elsewhere or view it yourself. Seems perfectly reasonable to me.I'm shipping my Jaguar to New Zealand in a couple of weeks, where I'm going to spend a year, so I need a temporary replacement to use here in the UK while it's on the boat. By happy coincidence, an old friend, who now lives in Texas, wants a car to use while he's spending a few months back in the UK this summer. He's very particular about the exact model he wants, but it would work very well for me too, and he's sending me the money (£2500) for it up front, so I'll have free use of it until I leave the UK. So I have this cash to spend on this good, quality barge, and one good looking example pops up about 40 miles away. Not so far away, but not a trivial trip, so I dropped him a quick email to see if it was worth a trip....
My Email said:
Hi,
I'm interested in the <car> you have in at the moment. Would you be able to answer a few questions about it for me?
1. Does it have a full service history? If so, is it at <brand> dealers or specialists?
2. Are there any faults with the equipment or any warning lights showing on the dash?
3. Does it have road tax?
4. Are there any cosmetic defects?
5. What condition are the tyres and what brand are they?
6. Has the car ever been smoked in, as far as you can tell?
If its good news, I'd like to come down to see the car next week.
I received this response:I'm interested in the <car> you have in at the moment. Would you be able to answer a few questions about it for me?
1. Does it have a full service history? If so, is it at <brand> dealers or specialists?
2. Are there any faults with the equipment or any warning lights showing on the dash?
3. Does it have road tax?
4. Are there any cosmetic defects?
5. What condition are the tyres and what brand are they?
6. Has the car ever been smoked in, as far as you can tell?
If its good news, I'd like to come down to see the car next week.
Dealer said:
Mr King
The vehicle is 11 years old and covered 112000 miles there is certain wear and tear on the vehicle which is commensurate with the age and mileage
Looking at your questions I feel this may not be the vehicle for you
Sent from my iPhone
Verily I am smacked of the gob. The ad clearly states the age and mileage, so he's either assumed that I haven't read it, or am of such low intellect and wisdom that I would assume that a car of this vintage and price would be pristine. Half of me wants to tell me where to stick his car and his attitude, but I like to give people the benefit of the doubt; maybe his wife just ran off with his best mate, or somebody just stiffed him for a short weasel on a late minty frogger - or something. I decide to communicate my confusion thusly:The vehicle is 11 years old and covered 112000 miles there is certain wear and tear on the vehicle which is commensurate with the age and mileage
Looking at your questions I feel this may not be the vehicle for you
Sent from my iPhone
Me again said:
I fear you may have misinterpreted my questions. I am well aware of the age and mileage of the car, but the purpose of my questions is to make sure that a cheap vehicle such as this doesn't quickly become very expensive due to underlying faults, lack of maintenance or other hidden expenses.
I'm not expecting a showroom fresh vehicle, but neither do I want it to land me with a massive bill, as that would rather defeat the point of a cheap car!
I am, in fact, a cash buyer with money waiting for this precise model, age and variant. This is the closest example to me currently available, which is why I'm hoping you'll take this second chance to answer a few straightforward questions.
I look forward to a more positive response.
Clearly this will do the trick - he'll be convinced I'm a serious buyer, and furnish me with the few germs of wisdom I need. Oh look, here comes a reply...I'm not expecting a showroom fresh vehicle, but neither do I want it to land me with a massive bill, as that would rather defeat the point of a cheap car!
I am, in fact, a cash buyer with money waiting for this precise model, age and variant. This is the closest example to me currently available, which is why I'm hoping you'll take this second chance to answer a few straightforward questions.
I look forward to a more positive response.
Dealerboy said:
Me king
The vehicle is on our forecourt and your more than welcome to view the vehicle
There is limited service history , no warning lights , bodywork is in good condition and interior is in reasonably good order , I do not know if the previous owner smoked and I really haven't got the time or inclination to look a tyre makes on a vehicle of this age or price
But as I said please inspect the vehicle and make your own mind up . But as I'm sure you will appreciate it is difficult to describe a vehicle via email as it depends on ones expectations
Sent from my iPhone
Now, I fully appreciate that this isn't a career-making sale for the dealer, but is it really too much to ask that he pop outside for a quick shuftie at the tax disc and to verify that it's not a pair of Nankang ditchfinder supremes that the previous owner has decided are suitable for transmitting 250 turbocharged horses to the tarmac under the front of the car? The vehicle is on our forecourt and your more than welcome to view the vehicle
There is limited service history , no warning lights , bodywork is in good condition and interior is in reasonably good order , I do not know if the previous owner smoked and I really haven't got the time or inclination to look a tyre makes on a vehicle of this age or price
But as I said please inspect the vehicle and make your own mind up . But as I'm sure you will appreciate it is difficult to describe a vehicle via email as it depends on ones expectations
Sent from my iPhone
Maybe I'm being unreasonable, but I don't think I am. It just frustrates me when, during a recession, a potential customer waving a wad of cash under your nose is seen as a nuisance. Obviously, this dealer will not be getting my business, the only shame is that the dealer will probably see this as proof that his initial assumption that I was a timewaster was right.
tl:dr - Reply below saying "Quite right! What a feckless eejit that dealer was - top rant: 10 out of 10"
I'm fully with the dealer on this one. Most of your questions sounds reasonable but the smoking and tyre requests would be ringing the big 'pain in the arse customer' alarm in my mind. 
I'm selling my two cars at the moment, I think I may have to try and suspend my natural cynicism and rudeness during the process.

I'm selling my two cars at the moment, I think I may have to try and suspend my natural cynicism and rudeness during the process.

This is why I don't like buying from car dealers. Reasonable questions, and £2.5k isn't pocket change. Why go on an 80 mile round trip and waste 2 people's time if the car can be dismissed straight away? Dealer's attitude is crap IMHO and I wouldn't want to deal with them. He might have to get off his arse and check the tyres
woe is me.
I do find the attitudes in this thread odd. If you're buying a cheap car, having to spend 500 quid plus on a new set of tyres is a non starter.
woe is me.I do find the attitudes in this thread odd. If you're buying a cheap car, having to spend 500 quid plus on a new set of tyres is a non starter.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



t and buy the car at list price, you annoying timewasting piece of s