Yet another what car thread
Yet another what car thread
Author
Discussion

J3PTF

Original Poster:

265 posts

189 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
As i write this I am waiting for my much loved Focus ST to be collected, which I've had to sell to release some much needed funds.

The search now begins for a replacement, and as I'm struggling for ideas, I'd welcome the thoughts of PH.

The main requirements:

- has to be cheap to buy - not quite shed money, but don't want to spend too much more
- has to have rear seats, for the occasional nursery run with my daughter
- can't be a money pit! I know for the money I'll spend things will no doubt go wriong, but I'd rather not the most expensive to fix when they do
- fun! I know it'll be boring compared to the ST, but something capable of some fun would be nice.
- it won't be used for hugh mileage, and mostly be used for station runs / local errands

Your ideas please!

Chilliman

12,443 posts

192 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
I bought a Mk3 Golf VR6 last October as a winter run-around, I think If you buy carefully they're reliable and alot of fun, if a bit heavy on fuel.. although I'm getting 32mpg on a steady motorway run....

TinyCappo

2,106 posts

184 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
E39 540 cheap realtively inexpensive to fix and awesome fun!

ben5732

763 posts

187 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Some form of Volvo T5

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
J3PTF said:
As i write this I am waiting for my much loved Focus ST to be collected, which I've had to sell to release some much needed funds.

The search now begins for a replacement, and as I'm struggling for ideas, I'd welcome the thoughts of PH.

The main requirements:

- has to be cheap to buy - not quite shed money, but don't want to spend too much more
- has to have rear seats, for the occasional nursery run with my daughter
- can't be a money pit! I know for the money I'll spend things will no doubt go wriong, but I'd rather not the most expensive to fix when they do
- fun! I know it'll be boring compared to the ST, but something capable of some fun would be nice.
- it won't be used for hugh mileage, and mostly be used for station runs / local errands

Your ideas please!
Ford Puma
Ford SportKA

Both fun, in fact probably both more fun than the ST, or at least it wouldn't surprise me if they were.

Impreza Turbo 2000 might be in budget with a bit of looking, similar power and performance to the ST.


Rover 200 BRM. Very capable and quickish FWD hatch. Close ratio gearbox, LSD and sweet revvy engine make it a peach to drive.

Saab 900 Turbo.

e36 BMW 323i.

e46 Compact BMW 325Ti.

Porsche 924.

Ash From Flux

1,138 posts

199 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Gen 6 Celica? Can be had for 'Shed Money', great fun, pretty reliable and, if they do go wrong, pretty cheap to put right. yes

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all

lindrup119

1,235 posts

174 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
Oddball choice: Classic Mini.

- has to be cheap to buy - not quite shed money, but don't want to spend too much more. Should be able to get a nice enough one around that mark that shouldn't need any major work.

- has to have rear seats, for the occasional nursery run with my daughter. I'm 6'1" and can sit comfortably (no joke!) in the back. Perhaps not the safest thing you want to transport your daughter around in though.

- can't be a money pit! I know for the money I'll spend things will no doubt go wrong, but I'd rather not the most expensive to fix when they do. Things will go wrong, but it will be like if you broke a Lego toy, easy to work on and not expensive (unless you want it to be with mods wink)

- fun! I know it'll be boring compared to the ST, but something capable of some fun would be nice. Won't be as 'fun' speed wise (unless you've got big bucks) but for smiles per mile I can't think of much better.

- it won't be used for high mileage, and mostly be used for station runs / local errands. Check. Although it will do motorway trips but you wouldn't want to cross-continents in one!

If that doesn't float your boat then a large number of warmed up hatches and wafty saloons that have already been mentioned should fit the bill or at least give you a better idea of what to look at. smile

scarble

5,277 posts

188 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd suggest a RS Clio but as we're in the same neck of the woods you might buy one out from under me tongue out
I'm looking for a nice clean 172 Cup.
2.5k-ish I think they go for.
So you can have any 172 non-cup or 182 with or without "Cup packs" or even the why-bother 182 actual Cup can in my experience all be had for less than a Fiesta ST and they're a bit quicker too.
Look out for cam belt (you don't want to chance it as they do go) and the "dephaser" (VVT) pulley is known to wear out, should normally be done at same time as cam belt.

Give us an idea of your price range because I might be wrong on Fiesta ST prices (£4-5k?)

Ash From Flux

1,138 posts

199 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
For a bit more dollar (circa £2.5 - 3k), you could pick up a Civic Type-R... It won't go wrong, it is VERY fun and plenty of room in the back for little'un.

scarble

5,277 posts

188 months

Monday 8th April 2013
quotequote all
I was going to suggest that too.
Bit heavier and slower than the Clio but probably a tad more reliable.
Sadly afaik we never got LSDs on our CTRs cry

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
My favourite bit of what car threads is finding out what car they bought as a result.

Although I also quite enjoy it when the OP never posts again as they confirm my opinion that these threads are a massive waste of everyone's time.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
It's just I'd managed to replace a Focus ST with a Focus ST for just over shed money, and thought "this time, Muppet, this time you've finally suggested a car that might just fking work".

Even 300's suggestions were on-message and relevant.



And then no feedback.




And so my hatred of these threads grows again.

scarble

5,277 posts

188 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
As you hate these threads so much, why repeatedly bump one for no reason other than to voice your silly little opinion?
Anyway, I posted in mine to say when I got a car tongue out
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Edited by scarble on Wednesday 24th April 09:52

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
You should look up my what car thread tongue out
Just did. You bought the car you first thought of.

What car thread: Clio 172 or Clio 172??

Awesome.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
As you hate these threads so much, why repeatedly bump one for no reason other than to voice your silly little opinion?
Anyway, I posted in mine to say when I got a car tongue out
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Edited by scarble on Wednesday 24th April 09:52
Sorry, missed your edit.

If anyone has a reason for posting anything at all on this forum other than voicing their opinion I'd like to know what it is.

Other than trying to be helpful, obviously, which was why I posted in this thread to start with.

TameRacingDriver

20,662 posts

303 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
scarble said:
I was going to suggest that too.
Bit heavier and slower than the Clio but probably a tad more reliable.
Sadly afaik we never got LSDs on our CTRs cry
An EP3 is certainly not slower than a Clio RS.

I've owned two clios, driven a CTR and had a little play with a CTR when in my Clio, and I don't really know how anyone could come to the conclusion the Clio is faster?! Even magazine road tests bear this out, with the 18ish seconds of the Clio playing 16ish seconds of the CTR in the 0-100 dash.

Anyway, the CTR is a decent suggestion TBH. The Clio will likely be a moneypit [/experience].

stormy22

793 posts

168 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm just shocked someone hasn't suggested a bloody BMW yet...thats usually how these things go, then Audi comes up....thats not here either....then someone suggests forgetting the family and buying a Caterham wannabe....
or a bloody MX5