Best mpg/running costs for mountaous roads 2k
Best mpg/running costs for mountaous roads 2k
Author
Discussion

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
2k budget to get something cheap to run for a 20 mile commute over fairly 'mountainous' roads (ie over 250 meters in 4 miles or so for one bit), should I end up moving to this location the other side of the pennines.

I know the 'mpg' thing gets asked a lot, but I'm wondering if this situation could change factors.

More space would always be useful, but only if it's not going to affect MPG.
Thinking things like a Clio/Megane 1.5DCI, Fiesta TDCI, C2/C3 HDI and the like.
Any toys like climate control would be nice, but again economy is the main factor.
If there was space to stick the dog in the boot that'd be nice - though only for when I may be filling up the rest of the car (I do have crew cab seats for my van, so it's not the end of the world if I need to do this.)

May also get used for trips around the place generally - as these days I'm finding I just can't justify doing half the things I want to because of the extra cost that fuel adds.

I'd just take a bike if I didn't have to have a 7 1/2 stone dog with me! (We did get him to sit pillion on a bike and stay there, but he was less than impressed and don't think would have stayed if the bike had started moving :P .)

While I always like fun; cheap is still more important, especially as I also have (just to earn some PH cred):
Fairly heavily tweaked E36 M3
R1 based kit car.
Various motorbikes.
And... Vito 111 + chip - 44mpg sitting behind trucks - for carrying bikes. But not so great off the motorways.
Iveco 75E15 motorhome

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
_g_ said:
2k budget to get something cheap to run for a 20 mile commute over fairly 'mountainous' roads (ie over 250 meters in 4 miles or so for one bit), should I end up moving to this location the other side of the pennines.

I know the 'mpg' thing gets asked a lot, but I'm wondering if this situation could change factors.

More space would always be useful, but only if it's not going to affect MPG.
Thinking things like a Clio/Megane 1.5DCI, Fiesta TDCI, C2/C3 HDI and the like.
Any toys like climate control would be nice, but again economy is the main factor.
If there was space to stick the dog in the boot that'd be nice - though only for when I may be filling up the rest of the car (I do have crew cab seats for my van, so it's not the end of the world if I need to do this.)

May also get used for trips around the place generally - as these days I'm finding I just can't justify doing half the things I want to because of the extra cost that fuel adds.

I'd just take a bike if I didn't have to have a 7 1/2 stone dog with me! (We did get him to sit pillion on a bike and stay there, but he was less than impressed and don't think would have stayed if the bike had started moving :P .)

While I always like fun; cheap is still more important, especially as I also have (just to earn some PH cred):
Fairly heavily tweaked E36 M3
R1 based kit car.
Various motorbikes.
And... Vito 111 + chip - 44mpg sitting behind trucks - for carrying bikes. But not so great off the motorways.
Iveco 75E15 motorhome
£2k on fuel for M3

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Heh; I wish I had that option!

Unfortunately, I need to make the trip more than 20 times! :P (Presuming I've got to fill up the NOS tank a good few times too.)
Then there's the servicing; while I do it myself, per mile it's going to be a lot worse - no cheap oil or 'maybe a bit of exhaust bandage will fix that'.

When asked by others, to be fair... my answer often is just ride/drive what you've got ... but even using my pretty economical van for daily stuff is really killing me on fuel costs as it is. I'm hoping something in this price range won't suffer a massive amount on depreciation when compared to alternatives - and cheap tax won't add a good chunk of extra fuel to be saved to justify the extra vehicle, as an older car would have.

JDRoest

1,126 posts

181 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
I use a Doblo (Cargo) in the Alps. Does about 30-35mpg up Stelvio, does about 150-200mpg down Stelvio.

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
The maxi size looks interesting should I come to replace the Vito - enough load area for 2 or 3 bikes while being under 2m tall (park in normal car parks), but a bit better fuel economy.

LuS1fer

43,566 posts

276 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Panda 4x4?

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Panda 4x4?
Always fancied one, actually... had a look and can't really match the economy of the models I listed in the first post.
There is a bit off pretty-muddy lane, but I've managed to stay there in an mx5 in the past, so a FWD shopping trolley shouldn't be a problem.
The non 4x4 panda gets a bit better economy, but still not up to the c3 and the like from what I can tell.

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Any more thoughts?

Think it's going to be a toss-up between the C3 and the Fiesta.

C3 is available in £10 a year cheaper tax and 3mpg better on paper. Whether that translates in to the real world is another matter.
I did quite like my Laguna's sloppy bump-absorbing suspension for comfort - and the dog won't appreciate me making use of the Fiesta's sharper handling.

But the C3 does seem to get slated for general Citroen stuff (and it looks like a snail).

nails1979

643 posts

172 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Vote for the clio here. My sister has a 06 and a bit of speed demon and still returns high 50s and low 60s consistently. She does a lot of miles and now has took it over the 100000 miles mark without any problems. Its had a set of discs and pads. 1 rear bearing and normal oil and filter changes plus the cam belt done. Not bad to drive either for what it is.

LuS1fer

43,566 posts

276 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
The C3 I'm not sure of but I had a C4 as a hire car and it was dire - as dull a car as has ever been invented.

I never want to drive one again. If you're set on those then drive both before deciding, it's the only way you'll know for sure and if you end up hating the Cit, you may have disliked the Fester just as much so you need to know.

KaraK

13,878 posts

240 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
C3 - don't do it! I've only driven the first gen one but it still has the dubious "honour" of being the worst car I've ever driven

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Cheers for the thoughts. It would be the first C3.

Any comparison of the C3 to an early Laguna? I had a basic first-gen 8v 1.8 Laguna which seemed to share a lot of the ride 'character' as described for the C3 - it was soggy but comfortable and had terrible body roll. However, I still enjoyed it - perhaps though could have done with that stiffer ride as I did end up with the almost motorbike-round tyre at the outside edges.

Reality should be that I'm most bothered by mpg and should ignore dynamics - especially if I'll have the dog in the car most of the time - and take the M3/kit car/bike if I want fun.
However, to be fair; it's rare that I won't 'make use of a vehicle' given the chance, however much I should stop that!

Edited by _g_ on Friday 12th April 00:39

HustleRussell

26,708 posts

191 months

Thursday 11th April 2013
quotequote all
Climbing? You want lightness and short gears. Some small shopping car should do it, I recommend a Yaris. Over a journey that short, Diesel engines won't get hot enough and it's bad for them.
The Yaris is a tough little thing, short gears, skinny tyres, cam chain not belt etc etc.

Edited by HustleRussell on Thursday 11th April 19:52

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
The Clio does look like a good option - generally under a ton with less 'dfsbad marks' than the c3.

The drive is likely to be at least 45 minutes - I thought that was ok to justify a diesel?
I've realised I can cut out one big climb and descent and swap it for a similar distance that goes through lots of towns/villages (not nearly as fun and a bit muddier exit). However that still leaves another two which are unavoidable.
The petrol engines also tend to start to bump up the tax rate too - though if it is going to be cheaper overall, I'd go for that. Also, I'd definitely be interested if I could find a decent LPG conversion of one of these - there's a station that does LPG near one end of the journey, which is convenient.

I had looked at the Yarris, but for a car I'd be spending a lot of time in, ideally I'd like a few more toys. Also, I reckon the centre instruments would annoy me.

Ideally I'd find places that would be happy for me to test drive all the models on the route and have a decent way of working out mpg - rather unlikely however, unfortunately (though I do have an obd II thingy somewhere.)

_g_

Original Poster:

741 posts

232 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Been reading that it's the DPF that tends to cause mpg issues on short runs (which would explain why my Vito sucks for this) - so removing that with a remap would be a consideration - but would have to be doing a whole load of miles before it was 'paid off'.