Which of these hatch's should I buy?
Which of these hatch's should I buy?
Author
Discussion

i am he

Original Poster:

27 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
I have 7000 quid to spend, and i am completely stuck between buying a ford fiesta zetec S 1.6 (09 reg) or a Astra H 1.8 sRi (07 reg), which car should i buy and why?
Btw I am 17 years old and i am looking for the funnest car to drive etc, take insurance out of the picture as i work and am going halfs with parents, but i am buying the car.

mattball

114 posts

178 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
You haven't provided many details on either. Are you open to suggestions on other cars? Personally I'd be inclined to go for something jap, I reckon you can get a better car and also save on costs due to their superior reliability.

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
If there were absolutely nothing on the table other than the two cars mentioned, then I'd prefer the Fiesta for a bit of fun.

Questions I'd ask would be:

Why only these two cars?
Why not consider something "more suitable" (how long is a piece of string) for a 17 year old to get experience and no-claims in?
Which do YOU prefer?

i am he

Original Poster:

27 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
what exactly are you thinking of? the reason I narrowed it down to these two are because of how popular and sworn by they are in the UK, especially by young males.

i am he

Original Poster:

27 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
mat205125 said:
If there were absolutely nothing on the table other than the two cars mentioned, then I'd prefer the Fiesta for a bit of fun.

Questions I'd ask would be:

Why only these two cars?
Why not consider something "more suitable" (how long is a piece of string) for a 17 year old to get experience and no-claims in?
Which do YOU prefer?
I honestly dont know what i prefer...the fiesta is a nicer car than the astra, hands down, but there is just something about the astra that is cool and striking it is a stunning car with black rims etc

i am he

Original Poster:

27 posts

163 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
mat205125 said:
If there were absolutely nothing on the table other than the two cars mentioned, then I'd prefer the Fiesta for a bit of fun.

Questions I'd ask would be:

Why only these two cars?
Why not consider something "more suitable" (how long is a piece of string) for a 17 year old to get experience and no-claims in?
Which do YOU prefer?
what do you mean by 'more suitable'? I will be doing 30 miles a day in this to college and back with 4 passengers, so i need quite a robust and powerful car for the dual carriageway and country roads to get there and back...

All my mates are driving round in farty little 1 litres like the corsa and cit C1, which i defo don't want, i want something i can have alot of fun on country roads etc

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
I think you're going to find the Astra SRI a little expensive on the insurance side of things.

My brother has just got one, and needless to say its a really nice car, however his insurance on it is well over the £1000 mark and he's 19 with a couple of years named driver experience. At 17, i can imagine the cost of the insurance is going to be 30-50% the value of the car.

My advice would be - Stick with a 1.2L for a couple of years, get some no claims, then go for something with a little more to offer smile

RobGT81

5,229 posts

217 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
The Mrs had an Aygo, same as the C1. It was a blast on little country roads.

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

197 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
If you're after the 'funnest' (?) car out of those two, then Fiesta all the way. Does £7K only buy you an 09 plate? Sure you can do better than that.

lewisf182

2,242 posts

219 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Fiesta all the way. New model + reportedly more fun to drive, which is easy to beleive with the fiesta weighing less. Zetec S is a much better looking car too. Cant stand the interior on both so thats a none point for me

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Have you had a drive of them both? If not, do that and see which one you enjoy more.

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
i am he said:
All my mates are driving round in farty little 1 litres like the corsa and cit C1, which i defo don't want, i want something i can have alot of fun on country roads etc
Sounds like an accident waiting to happen if I'm being completely stereotypical.... 17 y.o, 4 up, in a 1.8 blasting round the country....hmmm.....

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
mnkiboy said:
Does £7K only buy you an 09 plate? Sure you can do better than that.
For reference: My brothers 1.8 Astra SRI was 08 plate, approx 40K miles, that was only £5300 from a dealership with a few months warranty etc.

vrooom

3,763 posts

298 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
mx5

Big Fat Fatty

3,315 posts

187 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
i am he said:
I honestly dont know what i prefer...the fiesta is a nicer car than the astra, hands down, but there is just something about the astra that is cool and striking it is a stunning car with black rims etc
So it's form over function you want or do you want a car that's fun to drive?

If it's for a first car I would go with the Fiesta if that's the sort of thing you're after. Other options might include a Honda Civic, Mazda 2/3 or a Renault Clio etc.

PS, they're called 'wheels', the rim is the outer most part of a wheel not including the tyre.

Allaloneatron

3,123 posts

271 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
CallorFold said:
i am he said:
All my mates are driving round in farty little 1 litres like the corsa and cit C1, which i defo don't want, i want something i can have alot of fun on country roads etc
Sounds like an accident waiting to happen if I'm being completely stereotypical.... 17 y.o, 4 up, in a 1.8 blasting round the country....hmmm.....
Yep. I wouldn't want to be in that car. Too many flowers attached to trees around here for my linking. I had a 1.1 Saxo when I was 17 and drove like a complete tosser. In a 1.8 would have been dead a few times over.

G0ldfysh

3,318 posts

288 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
Most fun....

Put 6k in the bank to spend on holidays and experiences outside of the humdrum schlep back and forth from college.

Buy yourself a snotter, thrash the living st out of it to and from college with your mates, all knowing that a crash will write it off, but at the same time not put you in a pickle to get transport going again.
Learn to fix the car get oily and fit an oversized exhaust and stereo.

crap cars rule, can park anywhere, something with all your savings in while looking great has the headache and stress of other people attached to it.
So many other things to do with good bundle of cash at 17.


chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
i am he said:
All my mates are driving round in farty little 1 litres like the corsa and cit C1, which i defo don't want, i want something i can have alot of fun on country roads etc
At 17 years old the size of the engine is meaningless.

Spend a maximum of £5k on the car and the rest on maintaining some semblance of a social life so you can meet girls and then finger them in country lanes. This is much more fun than trying to extract any joy from driving an Astra.

In fact, take a girl car shopping. Not your mum or aunt, you can take your sister if she is a year or two older and popular (one of her hot mates would be better), if you don't know any girls don't buy a car you'll just become dull get a bus pass or train season ticket and talk to girls using them, don't get a restraining order and don't touch them unless invited.

Edited by chrisw666 on Wednesday 10th April 12:47

ambuletz

11,799 posts

212 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
If you want fun then go ford. get the fiesta, or a focus. Even a normal fiesta zetec will feel fine. Alternative 'fun' choice would be a suzuki swift sport.

pad58

12,549 posts

212 months

Wednesday 10th April 2013
quotequote all
I think we've been here before.
17 wants a 1.8/1.6 engine to have fun on country lanes with three other people in the car?
Not going to end well.