Are older Diesels a bit of a money pit reliability wise?
Discussion
When I say older, I'm thinking Mondeo/Vectra/Saab etc etc from around the year 2000 - 2005 since these are generally around the £1500-2000 mark...
Anyway - DMF,Injector,Fuel pump,Turbo,particulate filter etc...all these things seem to pop up regularly as failure items costing scary amounts (£500+) to fix.
I know people will come along saying their Diesel is perfectly reliable - but you can't ignore the fact that certain items seem to go pop quite regularly for Diesel cars?
Is a petrol still a better bangernomics bet, i.e. slightly more expensive on fuel (maybe), but cheaper in the long run should things go wrong?
Anyway - DMF,Injector,Fuel pump,Turbo,particulate filter etc...all these things seem to pop up regularly as failure items costing scary amounts (£500+) to fix.
I know people will come along saying their Diesel is perfectly reliable - but you can't ignore the fact that certain items seem to go pop quite regularly for Diesel cars?
Is a petrol still a better bangernomics bet, i.e. slightly more expensive on fuel (maybe), but cheaper in the long run should things go wrong?
I think it depends very much on the individual engine - some around that period are pretty hardy, whereas others are a ticking timebomb financially.
PSA 2.0 HDi 90's and VAG 1.9 TDi's (other than 150) are generally a pretty safe bet for example.
My own 306 HDi is on 227k miles now, and still on the original engine, turbo, injectors etc. No DMF to fail, no DPF to give agro, and all simple enough to DIY.
PSA 2.0 HDi 90's and VAG 1.9 TDi's (other than 150) are generally a pretty safe bet for example.
My own 306 HDi is on 227k miles now, and still on the original engine, turbo, injectors etc. No DMF to fail, no DPF to give agro, and all simple enough to DIY.
On the whole, yes. At this end of the market, just a clutch and flywheel will add up to 50% or more of the value of the car and wipe out any fuel savings against the equivalent petrol for a period of years.
In 2010 I bought a 2003 Mondeo TDCI with 100k on the clock for £1,900. I was very luck with it really but even Ford's tech expert for the South East said to my Dad "You haven't bought one of those with over 100k on it have you?"... Gives you an idea...
In 2010 I bought a 2003 Mondeo TDCI with 100k on the clock for £1,900. I was very luck with it really but even Ford's tech expert for the South East said to my Dad "You haven't bought one of those with over 100k on it have you?"... Gives you an idea...
Yes i would say petrol from the 2000 to 2005 era will be a much better bangernomics bet.
Even leaving aside the modern diesel issues - which are expensive - i think its worth noting that petrols are fequently either cheaper - or you can get a better car in better condition for the same money.
A lot of diesels of this age - especially when you get as far back as 2000 will have a lot of miles on the clock - a lot of people that ran diesels in the 2000 to 2005 period did so because they were doing high mileage.
I like diesels - but when the "snotter" comes up for replacement - its going to be petrol all the way - quite why youd want to be bothering with common rail, turbos, DMFs and all the other diesel bothers - when you can get a lower mileage well proven normally aspirated 1.8 or 2.0 normally aspirated petrol possibly with a nicer spec is beyond me.
Gen 6 Accord could be a good bet - and as far as i know - the 2 litre petrol Mondeos are fairly good - although the Mk 2s have rust issues. So the Mk 3s but ive never heard anything more serious on the Mk 3 Mondeo corrosion wise apart from the issue with doors rusting at the bottom on earlier runs because Ford didn't rust protect the doors perfectly due to an issue with the production process at the time.
Going petrol also opens up options that in diesel form you would avoid at all costs - such as the Mazda 6.
So yes - the answer from Sir Fergie - go petrol.
Sir Fergie
Even leaving aside the modern diesel issues - which are expensive - i think its worth noting that petrols are fequently either cheaper - or you can get a better car in better condition for the same money.
A lot of diesels of this age - especially when you get as far back as 2000 will have a lot of miles on the clock - a lot of people that ran diesels in the 2000 to 2005 period did so because they were doing high mileage.
I like diesels - but when the "snotter" comes up for replacement - its going to be petrol all the way - quite why youd want to be bothering with common rail, turbos, DMFs and all the other diesel bothers - when you can get a lower mileage well proven normally aspirated 1.8 or 2.0 normally aspirated petrol possibly with a nicer spec is beyond me.
Gen 6 Accord could be a good bet - and as far as i know - the 2 litre petrol Mondeos are fairly good - although the Mk 2s have rust issues. So the Mk 3s but ive never heard anything more serious on the Mk 3 Mondeo corrosion wise apart from the issue with doors rusting at the bottom on earlier runs because Ford didn't rust protect the doors perfectly due to an issue with the production process at the time.
Going petrol also opens up options that in diesel form you would avoid at all costs - such as the Mazda 6.
So yes - the answer from Sir Fergie - go petrol.
Sir Fergie
I’ve just got rid of my 05 Focus TDCI. I bought it off my uncle in law who owned it for 4 or 5 years, and was maintained extremely well. Serviced every 6months with fresh oil and filter changes etc.
Despite this, in my short 6month ownership I had to change 2 injectors, at almost £450. And there was a whole host of error codes thrown up when plugged into a reader. Then the final push was that oil was pooling in the pipe leading to the turbo where the MAF sensor was located. Somewhere oil shouldn’t be getting!
A quick search online and as advised by the garage, threw up the evidence that the 1.6 PSA diesel engine was massively unreliable, with a massive number blowing their turbo’s and taking the engine with it.
My indy garage could replace the turbo before it went, and make the changes to the oil feed pipe and the engine flush/work needed to help prevent it going. To the tune of around £800. Or I could go back to Ford where their fix is a new engine and turbo for £1500+. But even then it isn’t guaranteed to last! The indy knew of a guy who went the Ford route and had it happen again 6months later!
So in my experience older diesels are not such a good investment, yes on most you get away without the DPF and stuff that are costing fortunes in the newer derv engines.
That’s not to say a one owner car with exceptional SH is going to cost you a fortune to own and maintain. It’s just a case of getting lucky, the same with any car I suppose.
In terms of economy costs. I was probably getting a day or so extra mileage over what I’d get in my 1.6 petrol Focus. So in the grand scheme of things it wasn’t that much more economical to run.
I’m going back to petrol now, as I just didn’t get on with the diesel, and hated being in the longer queues at the pump
.
Depending on what you want/need the car for I’d vote petrol. Unless its motorway slogging covering loads of miles. Then I’d go for a decent derv, and try to avoid one with forced induction!
Despite this, in my short 6month ownership I had to change 2 injectors, at almost £450. And there was a whole host of error codes thrown up when plugged into a reader. Then the final push was that oil was pooling in the pipe leading to the turbo where the MAF sensor was located. Somewhere oil shouldn’t be getting!
A quick search online and as advised by the garage, threw up the evidence that the 1.6 PSA diesel engine was massively unreliable, with a massive number blowing their turbo’s and taking the engine with it.
My indy garage could replace the turbo before it went, and make the changes to the oil feed pipe and the engine flush/work needed to help prevent it going. To the tune of around £800. Or I could go back to Ford where their fix is a new engine and turbo for £1500+. But even then it isn’t guaranteed to last! The indy knew of a guy who went the Ford route and had it happen again 6months later!
So in my experience older diesels are not such a good investment, yes on most you get away without the DPF and stuff that are costing fortunes in the newer derv engines.
That’s not to say a one owner car with exceptional SH is going to cost you a fortune to own and maintain. It’s just a case of getting lucky, the same with any car I suppose.
In terms of economy costs. I was probably getting a day or so extra mileage over what I’d get in my 1.6 petrol Focus. So in the grand scheme of things it wasn’t that much more economical to run.
I’m going back to petrol now, as I just didn’t get on with the diesel, and hated being in the longer queues at the pump
. Depending on what you want/need the car for I’d vote petrol. Unless its motorway slogging covering loads of miles. Then I’d go for a decent derv, and try to avoid one with forced induction!
Very interesting.
So to summarise - I think it's fair to say that modern Diesels are over stressed (as I have always suspected) and are really only good for <10 years and/or <100'000 miles use.
That's rubbish really. They're now made be economical and 'clean'. But they don't last anywhere near as long as previous generation cars.
In my mind, a 53 plate 100'000 Diesel car should be perfectly serviceable for at least 5 years (assuming it's been serviced and cared for) - clearly, I'm very wrong.
Sod that. Petrol it is then.
So to summarise - I think it's fair to say that modern Diesels are over stressed (as I have always suspected) and are really only good for <10 years and/or <100'000 miles use.
That's rubbish really. They're now made be economical and 'clean'. But they don't last anywhere near as long as previous generation cars.
In my mind, a 53 plate 100'000 Diesel car should be perfectly serviceable for at least 5 years (assuming it's been serviced and cared for) - clearly, I'm very wrong.
Sod that. Petrol it is then.
Dr Doofenshmirtz said:
Very interesting.
So to summarise - I think it's fair to say that modern Diesels are over stressed (as I have always suspected) and are really only good for <10 years and/or <100'000 miles use.
That's rubbish really. They're now made be economical and 'clean'. But they don't last anywhere near as long as previous generation cars.
In my mind, a 53 plate 100'000 Diesel car should be perfectly serviceable for at least 5 years (assuming it's been serviced and cared for) - clearly, I'm very wrong.
Sod that. Petrol it is then.
It's as much down to how the car's driven as it is the engine. How many diesels do you hear being labourer around town, gearbox bouncing off the floor, for all of a 5 mile trip to the shops? Plenty. Funnily enough these same cars then need a DPF, DMF, and another other mechanical TLA you can think of.So to summarise - I think it's fair to say that modern Diesels are over stressed (as I have always suspected) and are really only good for <10 years and/or <100'000 miles use.
That's rubbish really. They're now made be economical and 'clean'. But they don't last anywhere near as long as previous generation cars.
In my mind, a 53 plate 100'000 Diesel car should be perfectly serviceable for at least 5 years (assuming it's been serviced and cared for) - clearly, I'm very wrong.
Sod that. Petrol it is then.
I bought a 2003, 95k mile merc C220 18 months ago
I was concerned about diesel reliability but since then done 30,000 miles with just servicing and tyres so they certainly can be reliable, I guess like my car there's a bit of luck and judgement in picking a decent well maintained example.
I was concerned about diesel reliability but since then done 30,000 miles with just servicing and tyres so they certainly can be reliable, I guess like my car there's a bit of luck and judgement in picking a decent well maintained example.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


