RE: Porsche: PDK or the highway
RE: Porsche: PDK or the highway
Friday 12th April 2013

Porsche: PDK or the highway

'You'll have it, and you'll like it', says latest release from Stuttgart



Nope, discussion about Porsche's decision to PDK-only the new GT3 isn't over yet - this really is the gift that keeps giving and the car hasn't even been driven yet. We've had our say, you've had yours. Now it's Porsche's turn.

PDK is motorsport-inspired too, says Porsche
PDK is motorsport-inspired too, says Porsche
It could of course be a complete coincidence but Porsche has issued a press release celebrating the success of its PDK gearbox and the decision to make it compulsory fit for the GT3 in the context of its motorsport heritage. “In den 1980s,” runs the hastily-translated copy, “Porsche developed a world first in automotive technology for use in races and thus won the race: the dual-clutch transmission. In 2013, this progressive transmission returns to the circuit course [in the] new 911 GT3.”

It goes on to remind us that the dual-clutch transmission was first developed for the 962 racer, which took 54 race wins and various championships in its time, and it adds that the PDK system is a key reason the GT3 can lap the Nordschleife in under 7min30sec and hit 62mph in 3.5 seconds. What’s more, it re-iterates that the GT3’s PDK system will feature only two shift patterns: Sports and Race, in which gears are held for longer and upshifts are carried out only with “higher torques” [sic]. If we didn’t know better, we’d say Porsche’s feelings had been hurt by the criticism.

All well and good, but if it's such an important part of the GT3's track-bred influence, it does beg the question why racing 911s like the new 991 based Cup and RSR use the 'old engine' and conventional race sequentials, albeit now paddle shifter controlled.

Author
Discussion

IMI A

Original Poster:

9,997 posts

232 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I'll stick with a manual thanks!

Krikkit

27,941 posts

212 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Here we go again..!

Manual for me. Every single time.

Silverbullet767

11,376 posts

237 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I currently drive a lazy Automatic, but if I were in the market for a Porsche, I'd be after a manual.

No thanks.

Raph C

117 posts

268 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Having just driven an Audi with the 7 speed DSG, I am starting to like it very much.

Really, the only drawback now is the weight. A dual clutch gearbox is 30 to 40kg more than a standard one.

J4CKO

47,093 posts

231 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I am not going to buy one now, guess I will just have to stick with the 944, as obviously the gearbox is why I am not getting one.

Come on chaps, it will be fantastic and most of us would swap a testicle, possibly two for it, it is called progress, Porsche seem to know what they're doing, it isn't some old sport o matic thing.

aww999

2,078 posts

292 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Are there really so few purchasers of new sportscars that still want a stick and pedals setup? You would think there'd be enough of them left for Porsche to continue offering the option, and "clean up" from people who would normally buy other marques, but switch to a manufacturer who offers the gearbox they want.

To me, it reinforces the opinion that 90% of new car purchasers just want a new shiny toy that looks nice driving through London, while car enthusiasts buy the most exciting thing they can afford for a set budget. Inevitably, this is a secondhand sportscar, but then they are stuck with the gearbox choice of the previous (poser) owner. How else do you explain why (before PDK/paddle shift) so many great cars of the past have been ruined due to being specified with a spasticated slushbox by the first owner? Honda NSX, I am looking at you!

Cheib

25,479 posts

206 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I am sure this has been debated at length in the Porsche forum but you have to think that over time the 997 GT3 is going to be more sought after than the 991. Last of it's kind etc.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
I am not going to buy one now, guess I will just have to stick with the 944, as obviously the gearbox is why I am not getting one.

Come on chaps, it will be fantastic and most of us would swap a testicle, possibly two for it, it is called progress, Porsche seem to know what they're doing, it isn't some old sport o matic thing.
If that's your taste, fine: however for me it is *exactly* why I will stick with my old 944, and possibly add a 993 at some point. That and the bloated width and electric steering and blingy styling and all the other features of new Porsches.

dave stew

1,502 posts

198 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I would have argued "U.S. market" but in reality they like their performance stuff with three pedals (I'd love RHD E60 M5 with a wobbly stick between the seats).

I think the answer is that performance car manufacturer's are losing sight of the fact that road cars are just that - road cars and the ability in real world terms of 'Ring times and brutal 0-60 times really don't matter.

Or am I just getting old?


MarJay

2,181 posts

206 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Porsche has lost sight of the fact that people don't buy their cars to beat the lap record at the nurburgring, but to have a bit of fun on the road. I know the ring laptimes sell cars, but to enforce the PDK on people when they would have more enjoyment from a manual is insane IMO, and just goes to show that they now have no clue about what makes people want to drive a sportscar or a supercar.

Ecosseven

2,384 posts

248 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Porsche are no doubt reacting to customer feedback and demand. It will be a real shame when the manual dies out completely. It will be interesting to see if the next MX-5 is offered with an option of manual and dual clutch ‘boxes. The manual in my MX-5 is fantastic and I certainly won’t want a two pedal sportscar no matter how quick the gear changes.

PhantomPH

4,043 posts

256 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Bottom line? It comes with the PDK whether you like it or not.

The plus point is that the GT3 is by FAR the best looking Porsche (of any current model and designation) you can buy. Man, that's a handsome beast!

Tuvra

7,927 posts

256 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Lowtimer said:
J4CKO said:
I am not going to buy one now, guess I will just have to stick with the 944, as obviously the gearbox is why I am not getting one.

Come on chaps, it will be fantastic and most of us would swap a testicle, possibly two for it, it is called progress, Porsche seem to know what they're doing, it isn't some old sport o matic thing.
If that's your taste, fine: however for me it is *exactly* why I will stick with my old 944, and possibly add a 993 at some point. That and the bloated width and electric steering and blingy styling and all the other features of new Porsches.
Worst "I'm getting old" post ever hehewink

RenesisEvo

3,828 posts

250 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Porsche evidently believe that speed and success in motorsport is what defines a good gearbox. I vehemently disagree.

Lap times, acceleration times, speed, the notion that somehow motorsport-inspired and derived technology is relevant to road cars. All of which has nothing to do with the actual quality and enjoyment of changing gear in a car, whether that be achieved via paddle or lever. Did anyone see the word 'fun', 'enjoyable' or some equivalent? I didn't. I grow weary of the focus of press releases and marketing men on irrelevant numbers and statistics, and not the emotions and abilities they should focus on.

Mitch2.0

198 posts

218 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I adore a manual, especially on the road, however these new breed of double clutch boxes are fantastic. I certainly wouldn't pay a boat load extra for one, as used to be the case with 'flappy paddle' options. However let's imagine Porsche offered the GT3 with a manual or PDK and there was no cost difference; I'd probably go with the PDK. So I'm not really that miffed about this decision, it had to come sooner or later, in 20 years time the Porsche 911 GT3 was certainly not going to have a manual option, so it had to go some time between now and then!

randy

544 posts

307 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
LOL, the 962 ran an H-pattern synchro gearbox which was archaic for its time!

The Pits

4,290 posts

271 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
No Porsche I won't like it.

Get a manual while you can! The end really is nigh.

Plenty of time to tool around in autos when you're older. Their greatest advantage is found in city traffic - great for posers but it's the last place on earth you'll find any driving pleasure.

I followed a 458 around Hyde Park Corner this week. Naturally he had it in 'D', the day-to-day reality of how these paddleshifts are being used. It sounded awful and just plain wrong on so many levels. What a shame they'll never even offer a manual. That's my main objection, for the money they charge for supercars these days I really think owners should be allowed the choice.

MadMark911

1,755 posts

180 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Doesn't it boil down to one thing - widening the market appeal to the largest possible audience / user base? Most buyers are now not the traditional enthusiasts they once were, the majority buying the cars buy them with PDK, so Porsche seem to view manuals in the same way that Magellan would the flat earth society. Presumably Porsche only cares about their ability to make huge profits?

365daytonafan

283 posts

216 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Forget emotion and opinion the only think that ultimately matters to Porsche or any other manufacturer is sales and profitability.

Ferrari have dropped the manual shifts because the demand for them relative to the paddles was not worth the development cost.

For Porsche if the GT3 being PDK only hurts sales then I suspect they will have a rethink, but my bet it it won't hurt overall sales one bit.

oilit

2,818 posts

209 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
MarJay said:
Porsche has lost sight of the fact that people don't buy their cars to beat the lap record at the nurburgring, but to have a bit of fun on the road. I know the ring laptimes sell cars, but to enforce the PDK on people when they would have more enjoyment from a manual is insane IMO, and just goes to show that they now have no clue about what makes people want to drive a sportscar or a supercar.
Its no different than what JLR did to us with petrol engines in land rover products (unless you want to pay the top price) - hence no landrover /range rover product has ever crossed the driveway threshold of my house since.

Its nothing to do with what we want - we only pay the b*****d salaries (those of us who buy their products at least!), arrogance in the utmost and total contempt for their customers...


rant over getmecoat