Would an MOT tester or a service technician inspect bearings
Would an MOT tester or a service technician inspect bearings
Author
Discussion

chrisw666

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

230 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
We had a company vehicle in the garage on Wednesday this week for an MOT and scheduled service, as part of this they suggested that the front and rear brakes needed changing, which we agreed to as we usually get a sensible discount.

No other advisory notices were issued, on collecting it the van was driven 5 miles and parked overnight. The next morning when collected it had developed a strange grinding noise from the steering, which was diagnosed as a front wheel bearing.

So two decent sized bills in three days, the second bill being something that my (admittedly limited) knowledge of vehicle servicing would have been spotted by not one but supposedly two thorough checks.

smartphone hater

4,304 posts

174 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Yes they would have checked, but only a visual check by spinning the wheel & listening for noise & pulling the wheel to check for loose play. Bearings can be strange things & the noise you were getting is probably the first symptom of it being worn in anyway.

jones325i

755 posts

184 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
I've had one of my cars fail an MOT in the past due to excessive play in a wheel bearing.

Dogwatch

6,385 posts

253 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Presumably the other wheel bearing will be handing in its notice soon?
Unusual not to have some hint of trouble especially after work had been done on it. Could it have had a knock on the trip home which finally did for a bearing which was already on its last legs?

chrisw666

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

230 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Dogwatch said:
Unusual not to have some hint of trouble especially after work had been done on it.
That was my thoughts, not sure about it getting a knock but knowing the route it took its highly unlikely as its all major roads and into a large storage yard.

JM

3,170 posts

237 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
chrisw666 said:
We had a company vehicle in the garage on Wednesday this week for an MOT and scheduled service, as part of this they suggested that the front and rear brakes needed changing, which we agreed to as we usually get a sensible discount.
Just pads, or discs as well?

Disc hard to get off resulting in a few bashes with a big hammer, putting strain on the bearing which fails after next use. Or excess release fluid used at hub which washed some grease from the bearing.



tr7v8

7,628 posts

259 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
JM said:
chrisw666 said:
We had a company vehicle in the garage on Wednesday this week for an MOT and scheduled service, as part of this they suggested that the front and rear brakes needed changing, which we agreed to as we usually get a sensible discount.
Just pads, or discs as well?

Disc hard to get off resulting in a few bashes with a big hammer, putting strain on the bearing which fails after next use. Or excess release fluid used at hub which washed some grease from the bearing.
My thoughts, neanderthal with hammer brinneled the bearings.

chrisw666

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

230 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Discs too, so that theory makes sense.

chrisw666

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

230 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Just to update this, spoke to service manager yesterday morning.

He's agreed to replace both front bearings FOC, its been left at that but when this was offered with very little pushing it screams that someone has screwed up.

Momentofmadness

2,371 posts

272 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
chrisw666 said:
He's agreed to replace both front bearings FOC, its been left at that but when this was offered with very little pushing it screams that someone has screwed up.
Maybe, maybe not - but you're obviously a good customer and he wants to keep your business thumbup