RE: Aston races hydrogen Rapide S at N24
RE: Aston races hydrogen Rapide S at N24
Friday 12th April 2013

Aston races hydrogen Rapide S at N24

It's an Aston endurance racer, Jim, but not as we know it...



Any racing enthusiast worth his or her salt will know that Aston Martin has a long heritage of endurance competition. But not quite like this. Firstly, Aston Martin’s about to enter the Nurburgring 24-hour with a four-door saloon, the Rapide S. That’s not the biggest news, though, because this particular Rapide S will be powered by a combination of hydrogen and petrol.

Rapide S will retain internal combustion
Rapide S will retain internal combustion
It won’t be equipped with a fuel cell, though. This particular Rapide will instead use a conventional 6.0-litre V12 petrol engine that’s been modified to allow it to combust hydrogen too. Those modifications include a new hydrogen-specific fuel rail and injectors, an additional ECU to control the hydrogen-powered parts of the system, and a revised intake manifold. As a result, the engine will be able to run on pure gaseous hydrogen, pure petrol, or a combination of both, and the proprietary engine management software will cleverly allow the engine to blend fuels to obtain the optimum balance between efficiency and performance. Oh, and there's the small matter of two turbos to add further oomph, too. Further modifications to the rest of the car include the addition of several hefty hydrogen storage tanks that’ll fill the boot and take the place of the passenger seat.

Aston Martin says that the hydrogen Rapide S will be the first-ever hydrogen-powered car to compete in an international race, as well as the first car to complete a zero-CO2 race-pace lap at the event. It adds that the car will emit “virtually only water” from the exhaust – that ‘virtually’ being a necessary addition as the combustion of nitrogen in air also results in nitrates, which are nasty little blighters, and part of the reason we haven’t seen a greater number of hydrogen combustion engines yet. However, a spokesperson from Aston Martin told us that the vast majority of these will be “catalysed out”, leaving only “trace amounts” to find their way through the Rapide S’s sizeable exhaust pipes. Sounds a bit like where we are at the moment with CO2, then... so does that make it a relevant alternative fuel for a combustion engine? The fullness of time will decide, but for now, we’ll be watching Aston’s N24 entry with interest. If nothing else, Aston deserves a pat on the back for daring to be different.

Author
Discussion

scubadude

Original Poster:

2,619 posts

228 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Now I'm all for Hydrogen fuel cell tech in road cars but surely pressurized, tanked hydrogen in a race car is a receipe for explosion?

More power to them for doing it and getting it through scrutineering though.

ali4390

2,388 posts

196 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
scubadude said:
Now I'm all for Hydrogen fuel cell tech in road cars but surely pressurized, tanked hydrogen in a race car is a receipe for explosion?

More power to them for doing it and getting it through scrutineering though.
Agreed. Wouldn't fancy be the driver of that if it ploughs into a wall at 160mph - clenched arse time indeed!

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
ali4390 said:
scubadude said:
Now I'm all for Hydrogen fuel cell tech in road cars but surely pressurized, tanked hydrogen in a race car is a receipe for explosion?

More power to them for doing it and getting it through scrutineering though.
Agreed. Wouldn't fancy be the driver of that if it ploughs into a wall at 160mph - clenched arse time indeed!
I think it would be clenched regardless...

ukaskew

10,642 posts

252 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
"As a result, the engine will be able to run on pure gaseous hydrogen, pure petrol, or a combination of both, and the proprietary engine management software will cleverly allow the engine to blend fuels to obtain the optimum balance between efficiency and performance."

erm...

"as well as the first zero-CO2 car to complete a race-pace lap at the event. It adds that the car will emit “virtually only water” from the exhaust"


I might need a science lesson here, but if it's burning petrol as well where is the CO2 going?

Scrof

197 posts

185 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
ukaskew said:
"As a result, the engine will be able to run on pure gaseous hydrogen, pure petrol, or a combination of both, and the proprietary engine management software will cleverly allow the engine to blend fuels to obtain the optimum balance between efficiency and performance."

erm...

"as well as the first zero-CO2 car to complete a race-pace lap at the event. It adds that the car will emit “virtually only water” from the exhaust"


I might need a science lesson here, but if it's burning petrol as well where is the CO2 going?
My bad - got the word order wrong. Now sorted! The implication is that they'll set it to run on hydrogen-only for a lap or somesuch.

Gorm

13 posts

168 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Well, I knew what he meant....I can read the word "or". There's a selector facility in the software, OBVIOUSLY!

Omaruk

734 posts

190 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
So is it essentially like an LPG conversion using liquified hydrogen instead ?

richb77

889 posts

192 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
These hydrogen tanks will be extremely sturdy.

Think of the tanks you see on the back of BOC trucks. They dont explode (the valves may shear off though).

Commercial aircraft carry a mixture of steel and composite aluminium cylinders all of which have to withstand direct high force impact (bullets for example) as many carry pure oxygen.

If a crash was serious enough to damage the tank i dont think the driver would be alive to be worried about it.

scubadude

Original Poster:

2,619 posts

228 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
richb77 said:
These hydrogen tanks will be extremely sturdy.

Think of the tanks you see on the back of BOC trucks. They dont explode (the valves may shear off though).

Commercial aircraft carry a mixture of steel and composite aluminium cylinders all of which have to withstand direct high force impact (bullets for example) as many carry pure oxygen.

If a crash was serious enough to damage the tank i dont think the driver would be alive to be worried about it.
As a diver, working in the industry and having seen a few "incidents" I can tell you the valve shearing off would be more than bad enough, it would expell a large cloud or vapour, mixing nicely with atmospheric oxygen and the slightest spark would toast a fair few black forest trees.

Also you don't want a tank to come loose inside the car (in an accident) if its that big and strong

richb77

889 posts

192 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
scubadude said:
richb77 said:
These hydrogen tanks will be extremely sturdy.

Think of the tanks you see on the back of BOC trucks. They dont explode (the valves may shear off though).

Commercial aircraft carry a mixture of steel and composite aluminium cylinders all of which have to withstand direct high force impact (bullets for example) as many carry pure oxygen.

If a crash was serious enough to damage the tank i dont think the driver would be alive to be worried about it.
As a diver, working in the industry and having seen a few "incidents" I can tell you the valve shearing off would be more than bad enough, it would expell a large cloud or vapour, mixing nicely with atmospheric oxygen and the slightest spark would toast a fair few black forest trees.

Also you don't want a tank to come loose inside the car (in an accident) if its that big and strong
Maybe some confusion.

I was trying to make the exact point that you have. The tanks are fine its more about movement of them and the rear danger is to the valve/tank join.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
"No CO2" ?? hmmm really? Where exactly are you getting the hydrogen from that releases "no" CO2 during it's manufacturer, storage and transport?

if you don't want to release any CO2, then i suggest that driving pointlessly in circles at high speed isn't the way to achieve it.........

binnerboy

488 posts

181 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
is hydrogen more or less explosive than petrol ?

why is having a compressed tank of hydrogen more of a risk than a tank carrying petrol ?

I don't have an figures handy but petrol isn't exactly benign is it ...

sheared valve vs split fuel line
tank of explosive gas vs tank of explosive liquid

"and part of the reason we haven’t seen a greater number of hydrogen combustion engines yet"

i thought handling the material was a bigger issue due to the tiny molecules passing more easily through substances cos solids are really solid when you go small enough.

gofasterrosssco

1,320 posts

267 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all

Hydrogen tends to 'burn' rather than combust in an explosive manner, so a different set of risks apply. Maybe a bad example, but if you watch the Hindenburg airship disaster, the aircraft progressively burns, rather than the whole thing exploding. Petrol vapour is more combustable, just that hydrogen is compressed, where as the vapour is not. To me I've never been able to understand the concern fully.

There are other methods of hydrogen stoage (achieving higher storage desities too) that are alot safer, but are mainly in the development stages still I believe. So developing the engine tech is useful for when other storage methods appear - if they ever do.

LewisR

678 posts

246 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
"No CO2" ?? hmmm really? Where exactly are you getting the hydrogen from that releases "no" CO2 during it's manufacturer, storage and transport?

if you don't want to release any CO2, then i suggest that driving pointlessly in circles at high speed isn't the way to achieve it.........
Agreed.

Hydrogen is a non-starter. It exist as such a simple molecule that it will leak through everything. Park a hydrogen car up for a weak or so and your tank will be empty. The filling stations will have the problem of storing and it will have to be transported safely, cheaply & efficiently.

LoftyD

303 posts

263 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Has everyone glossed over the possibility of a production twin turbo v12 from Aston in the near future?

ChrisPap

395 posts

185 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Odd that the technical illustration is of a Rapide (though not an S) but with a V8 turbo engine.

Hope there is a V12 but god knows where they'll find room for the turbos!

will261058

1,115 posts

223 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
BMW had a couple of 7 series that did pretty much the same thing burning Hydrogen as a fuel rather than a fuel cell about 6/7 yrs or so ago. They changed tack with "Efficient Dynamics" but I did hear they are still working on this.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 12th April 2013
quotequote all
Lets hope they can do better than the log style manifold shown........

radio man

202 posts

205 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
give it 10 to 15 yrs and the only people using electric cars will be the one who work from home so the can be sure the car doesn't run out of battery power between work and home. Nearly everybody else will be driving Hydrogen powered cars so that they can drive 300 miles until the can fill up at a gas station, and whilst the hydrogen car is taking a few hours to do their 300 miles the person with the electric car could spend the same amount of time charging their pink eveready 4 wheeled bunny.

bp1000

873 posts

210 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
radio man said:
give it 10 to 15 yrs and the only people using electric cars will be the one who work from home so the can be sure the car doesn't run out of battery power between work and home. Nearly everybody else will be driving Hydrogen powered cars so that they can drive 300 miles until the can fill up at a gas station, and whilst the hydrogen car is taking a few hours to do their 300 miles the person with the electric car could spend the same amount of time charging their pink eveready 4 wheeled bunny.
In 10-15 years we will have new battery tech but I firmly believe battery powered cars will be the automotive laser disc.