Servicing book dealer stamps
Discussion
A pal of mine who bought a new Jaguar last year has told me that when he puts it in for servicing the main dealer will not stamp the service book unless ALL other work identified as being necessary apart from the service is done.
Does anyone know if this is the case with other makes of car ?
Does anyone know if this is the case with other makes of car ?
Sounds very wrong to me, I'd be taking my business elsewhere.
When we had an X-Type I rang one Jag dealer to enquire as to the cost of a service. Right snooty type on the other end of the phone, she starts the conversation with 'is this your first jaguaaaaaaar sir? how lovely' which put my back up straight away. Then when she said the service would be £500odd I asked what would be done for that and she replied 'well we service it sir'.
Funnily I didn't take the car there.
When we had an X-Type I rang one Jag dealer to enquire as to the cost of a service. Right snooty type on the other end of the phone, she starts the conversation with 'is this your first jaguaaaaaaar sir? how lovely' which put my back up straight away. Then when she said the service would be £500odd I asked what would be done for that and she replied 'well we service it sir'.
Funnily I didn't take the car there.
D1bram said:
Sounds very wrong to me, I'd be taking my business elsewhere.
When we had an X-Type I rang one Jag dealer to enquire as to the cost of a service. Right snooty type on the other end of the phone, she starts the conversation with 'is this your first jaguaaaaaaar sir? how lovely' which put my back up straight away. Then when she said the service would be £500odd I asked what would be done for that and she replied 'well we service it sir'.
Funnily I didn't take the car there.
Your reply confirms what I thought. I'm seeing my pal next week and will tell him do. Thanks for that !When we had an X-Type I rang one Jag dealer to enquire as to the cost of a service. Right snooty type on the other end of the phone, she starts the conversation with 'is this your first jaguaaaaaaar sir? how lovely' which put my back up straight away. Then when she said the service would be £500odd I asked what would be done for that and she replied 'well we service it sir'.
Funnily I didn't take the car there.
Last year when I was looking to replace my DB9 with a Bentley Continental GTC, I was continually pestered by a dealer who had a car suitable in every respect apart from two critical factors. A. It was more expensive than others I had found.
B. It was an awful colour combination ( black with white leather ). I told him both of these reasons and thought that was the end of it. No such luck ! Two weeks later he rang to say that he had done a credit check on me and knew I was good for the money. " what was the real problem ? ", he asked. Can you believe these guys !?
Salt flat rat said:
A pal of mine who bought a new Jaguar last year has told me that when he puts it in for servicing the main dealer will not stamp the service book unless ALL other work identified as being necessary apart from the service is done.
Does anyone know if this is the case with other makes of car ?
Tell them to poke it.Does anyone know if this is the case with other makes of car ?
I used to get the menu service for the menu price on the 911, book stamped, and did anything else myself.
I had my Jag serviced a couple of years ago at the dealer. They came up with a comedy list of £4K's worth of work they reckoned the car needed, silly stuff mainly. I thanked them for the service, got the book stamped and never went back to them again. I've used a specialist for everything since.
Oh... and all the stuff on their comedy list was just rubbish. However, I suppose most customers with a 4 year old Jag might just say to go for it. Good business for the dealer, but no problems getting the service book stamped to indicate the service had been done.
Your man is speaking out of his arse and I'd be going somewhere else.
Oh... and all the stuff on their comedy list was just rubbish. However, I suppose most customers with a 4 year old Jag might just say to go for it. Good business for the dealer, but no problems getting the service book stamped to indicate the service had been done.
Your man is speaking out of his arse and I'd be going somewhere else.
Piersman2 said:
I had my Jag serviced a couple of years ago at the dealer. They came up with a comedy list of £4K's worth of work they reckoned the car needed, silly stuff mainly. I thanked them for the service, got the book stamped and never went back to them again. I've used a specialist for everything since.
Oh... and all the stuff on their comedy list was just rubbish. However, I suppose most customers with a 4 year old Jag might just say to go for it. Good business for the dealer, but no problems getting the service book stamped to indicate the service had been done.
Your man is speaking out of his arse and I'd be going somewhere else.
Seconded.Oh... and all the stuff on their comedy list was just rubbish. However, I suppose most customers with a 4 year old Jag might just say to go for it. Good business for the dealer, but no problems getting the service book stamped to indicate the service had been done.
Your man is speaking out of his arse and I'd be going somewhere else.
At 40k miles I was told I needed discs and pads all round on the 911. Oddly at the next three services they didn't get a mention, and the discs were still on the car when it passed its MOT two days before I sold it, with 90k+ miles on it.
Self healing brake discs. Who would have though it?
RSoovy4 said:
Seconded.
At 40k miles I was told I needed discs and pads all round on the 911. Oddly at the next three services they didn't get a mention, and the discs were still on the car when it passed its MOT two days before I sold it, with 90k+ miles on it.
Self healing brake discs. Who would have though it?
Yep. On my list I had some 'worn' suspension arm bushes. Strange that they've since managed to get through 3 MOTs and never been picked up by 2 separate specialists. How those arms are still attached I'll never know! At 40k miles I was told I needed discs and pads all round on the 911. Oddly at the next three services they didn't get a mention, and the discs were still on the car when it passed its MOT two days before I sold it, with 90k+ miles on it.
Self healing brake discs. Who would have though it?

Oh, and the "non-retracting" seatbelts they picked up. Bizarre. Still self retracting 3 years later.
Salt flat rat said:
Does anyone know if this is the case with other makes of car ?
It's the same with Mercedes - but it only applies to scheduled service items, not things like pads + disks.I think it's fair emough, to be honest. Some people think they can just have the basic service done at the dealer and get the stamp. They can then claim the car has full MB service history. OK, literally that true - it is full, but it's not complete as the other service work required wasn't done.
D1bram said:
When we had an X-Type I rang one Jag dealer to enquire as to the cost of a service. Right snooty type on the other end of the phone, she starts the conversation with 'is this your first jaguaaaaaaar sir? how lovely' which put my back up straight away. Then when she said the service would be £500odd I asked what would be done for that and she replied 'well we service it sir'.
Many of the big dealer groups use call centres for service booking and the people you talk to know absolutely nothing.Edited by Deva Link on Friday 12th April 23:47
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


