Strange MOT, Advisories copied from previous year.
Strange MOT, Advisories copied from previous year.
Author
Discussion

Grahamr123

Original Poster:

209 posts

178 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Got my car MOT'd today. It passed, no problem.
However, I had three advisories, nothing too alarming on the face of it.

The problem is that the advisories are Identical to the ones I had previous year, which have all since been fixed.

One was handbrake travel, the cable was tightened sometime last year.
The other two was the inside of the front tyres which had uneven wear, I replaced the tyres and tracking re-aligned.

It seemed strange that all the same problems had come up again. So I checked the tyres, no uneven wear, they look fine.
The handbrake was fine as well.


I don't understand why they would simply copy them over. Is this something they do on MOT's now that I'm unaware of?
What going on here?

Disco_Biscuit

837 posts

225 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Well the obvious thing would be to go back to the test station and ask them to show you why it was advised surely.
If they have got it wrong they can call VOSA who can amend your MOT certificate.

You can't automatically carry over advisorys in fact unless they had last years certificate they wouldn't know what advisorys where given .

Edited by Disco_Biscuit on Saturday 13th April 07:08

muckymotor

2,500 posts

252 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Disco_Biscuit said:
You can't automatically carry over advisorys in fact unless they had last years certificate they wouldn't know what advisorys where given .

Edited by Disco_Biscuit on Saturday 13th April 07:08
Is this true? I thought the new computer based MOTs would have some record of advisories?

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
muckymotor said:
Is this true? I thought the new computer based MOTs would have some record of advisories?
Only if you print off a duplicate of last year's certificate.

Mike_Mac

664 posts

231 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
With a suspicious head and tinfoil hat firmly in place, is there a chance that these some or all of these 'advisories' are being put on all that garage's MOT test certificates in the hope of drumming up a bit of extra 'work'?

Especially as most drivers don't know how far the handbrake should normally travel and won't jack the car up to check inner-tyre wear?

kwk

562 posts

209 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Mine was slightly different. The 3 advisories I had last year, including slight play in the steering rack, all disappeared this year. I've done nothing to the car and it was the same garage and tester.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Mike_Mac said:
With a suspicious head and tinfoil hat firmly in place, is there a chance that these some or all of these 'advisories' are being put on all that garage's MOT test certificates in the hope of drumming up a bit of extra 'work'?

Especially as most drivers don't know how far the handbrake should normally travel and won't jack the car up to check inner-tyre wear?
I just had my MOT last month, and the advisory was "Front windscreen has damage to an area less than a 40mm circle outside zone A". Now I've been over the windscreen thoroughy and can't find any damage at all (unless you count the tiny chips from stones than are all over the windscreen). It also said on the invioce "Inner rim buckled, requires replacing" - again, been over all the wheels and no problems, and neither was this mentioned to me when I collected the car (which is kind of odd given that they could have tried to fleece me out of a new wheel).

I wonder if they put these thing on so it appears to VOSA that they're not just passing every car with a clean bill of health.

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
I had two advisories.
One for engine cover obscuring parts and the other one for undertrays obscuring parts.
Plain daft if you ask me,never had it before.Must be part of the new MOT.

Mike_Mac

664 posts

231 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
I wonder if they put these thing on so it appears to VOSA that they're not just passing every car with a clean bill of health.
Maybe - although I'd have thought that enough cars would have something that justifies an advisory, or indeed fail on something genuine, without a garage needing to make stuff up.

I had a look at the MIL's 206 prior to its last MOT test as she had an advisory that the CV boot was starting to perish. I couldn't find anything wrong with it and it sailed through the test with no problems (at a different garage). That was what sparked my first post, as the original garage seemed to be pressing to get the work done then and there after the test.

loko

313 posts

195 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
I had one for lowering springs, "shortend but still safe" was how it was described

Bonefish Blues

36,972 posts

254 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
MOT garage fails car on an item, plus advisories. Get quoted "no more than £600" to fix.

Go no my normal (non MOT) garage, pay a whole lot less...plus get told I shouldn't have used that MOT centre "they're a bit short of work"

Fail items fixed, plus I pointed out that advisory item X was in fact nonsense, since the "excessive play" was clearly connected to the road spring failure, not the recently polybushed suspension.

Also fixed a.n.o. advisory whilst we're at it.

Go back for re-test. Passed. All advisories faithfully carried over from Test 1.

Obvious conclusion is obvious.

bungle

1,874 posts

271 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Got a new advisory this year, words to the effect "couldn't test rear seat belts due to child seats", even though:

1. I had no advisories for the last 5 yrs they were fitted in the same car, and;
2. they are secured by isofix, and the belts do stretch round so could be tested.

But surely, if belts are a safety item, and they really couldn't test them, shouldn't they have failed the MoT or asked me to remove the child seats? (I know they are not allowed to remove them themselves).

mcford

819 posts

205 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
kwk said:
Mine was slightly different. The 3 advisories I had last year, including slight play in the steering rack, all disappeared this year. I've done nothing to the car and it was the same garage and tester.
He obviously thought that you didn't need telling twice about them smile

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
bungle said:
Got a new advisory this year, words to the effect "couldn't test rear seat belts due to child seats", even though:

1. I had no advisories for the last 5 yrs they were fitted in the same car, and;
2. they are secured by isofix, and the belts do stretch round so could be tested.

But surely, if belts are a safety item, and they really couldn't test them, shouldn't they have failed the MoT or asked me to remove the child seats? (I know they are not allowed to remove them themselves).
We do the tests the way VOSA tell us, if we vary from what they want we can lose our licence. They don't allow us to remove a child seat and if one is fitted we are not allowed to interfere with it in any way and stretching a seatbelt over it could dislodge something.

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
I've got an advisory on my previous MOT for a windscreen chip.

It's got bigger over the past year, but this time - no advisory.