veg oil anyone?
Author
Discussion

JakesterUK

Original Poster:

869 posts

230 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
A friend of mine runs his 300tdi Discovery on new veg oil and swears by it as a 'cheap as chips' way of running a big 4x4.

Does anyone have any experiences of running on veg oil as I'm toying with the idea myself and wandered what others experiences had been?.


heners54

286 posts

170 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
My uncle ran a 50:50 mix of veg oil and swore by it, did over 90k running the stuff in a Kia Sedona with no issues. He said he wouldn't use any more than that ratio though, don't know what the consequences are of running pure veg oil though.

Fubar1977

919 posts

171 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
After reading too many reports of knackered seals and poor running along with various other issues I would have to say fk No!

On an old (really old) diesel maybe, anything made in the last 10 years? No.
Too much of a gamble for me.
Was considering it for mu old 55 plate Polo TDi and was advised it would be ruinous.

HustleRussell

26,708 posts

191 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Direct injection engines won't put up with it for long generally speaking, so as he says ^ you'd need to be running an older diesel car with lower bork potential.

pherlopolus

2,192 posts

189 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Our old mk1 sharan with 90bhp engine loved it, ran 80% in summer, got caught out with higher ratio on a surprise frost and it nearly didn't start.

At one point asda was doing corn oil @ 3 for 2 on 3l, worked out about 55p a litre, was a few years ago though.

Cemesis

771 posts

193 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
It does work on older cars but you must research for a compatible vehicle and not make any assumptions.

The problem is that new veg is about 40% cheaper than Diesel but a modern Diesel will get 40% better ecconomy than an older one which negates the difference.

If you can get used veg for nothing and filter it then you can actually drive for free but WVO (Wates veg oil) is getting harder to find.

405dogvan

5,329 posts

296 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Old diesels will be fine - newer diesels (HDi, common rail etc.) you have to be more wary-of, simply because they have higher demands/higher tolerances and the parts, if they fail, are bloody expensive.

That and the fact that new, it costs as much as 'real' diesel (if you consider the reduced performance/MPG) is off-putting to most people - but there's a lot of competition for oil of all kinds these days.

My 405 TD would (and has in the past) run fine on veg but it's not really much of a moneysaver unless you have access to 'free chip oil' and the kit to clean-it-up!?

I did once put some in just to impress her-indoors - she was convinced it would blow-up and it didn't @)

fourpointsixgt

513 posts

195 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Ran my w124 e class merc 300td on the stuff all the time, only in the depths of winter did I mix it with regular diesel.
The only thing I did on top of normal servicing was replace the fuel filter more regularly. It was a non turbo engine designed to run on fuel in 3rd world countries. I reckoned it was saving me 40% in fuel costs.

Evoluzione

10,345 posts

274 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
I can't add any more than others have, but isn't central heating oil the one to go for now?

Slow

6,973 posts

168 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Mum filters old chip oil and just throws it in, no point wasting some free fuel.

Fubar1977

919 posts

171 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
fourpointsixgt said:
Ran my w124 e class merc 300td on the stuff all the time, only in the depths of winter did I mix it with regular diesel.
The only thing I did on top of normal servicing was replace the fuel filter more regularly. It was a non turbo engine designed to run on fuel in 3rd world countries. I reckoned it was saving me 40% in fuel costs.
This is exactly the sort of motor it`s suitable for.
A modern TDi with common rail injection on the other hand will probably be a world of pain for the relatively small saving.

DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
If you run veg oil, just change the fuel filter every few months to start with, as the veg oil clears out the crap in the tank and fuel lines.

Common rail diesels won't tolerate veg oil and will end in a bill of many pounds.....

Condi

20,556 posts

202 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
306 Hdi runs fairly well at a 20/30% mix with derv. Doesnt save huge amounts, but no difference in fuel economy or performance. Only worth doing during warm weather, 10 degrees or so, as it becomes very thick when cold. Even better still if you're on long runs as the heat from the pump thins it out and makes it easier, not great for short journies.

JakesterUK

Original Poster:

869 posts

230 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the input everyone, I wouldn't be looking to run in a newer diesel car but most likely a 300tdi discovery or defender, my budget wouldn't buy a late model land Rover or similar so new diesel economy doesn't really come into it for me.

DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
look over on Landyzone.co.uk for more info on the 300tdi on veg oil.