Grimsby Crash call for 50mph
Grimsby Crash call for 50mph

Poll: Grimsby Crash call for 50mph

Total Members Polled: 66

50 should make it safer: 1
50 should make it worse: 6
50 will make little difference: 31
a poll wont help: 10
I dont do polls!: 2
50 and speed cameras will solve it: 1
make it dual carriageway like the rest of A18: 17
bring sightlines and junctions up to standard: 13
Author
Discussion

saaby93

Original Poster:

32,038 posts

209 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
News report call for 60 to 50
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=et5hBZp2_zk

Obviously most people use the NSL road without having a problem
What's causing the accidents - will 50 make it better or worse
They're relatively few but still enough to make it Britains most dangerous road for car drivers.

Is anyone mistaking it for being a dual carriageway like the rest of the road?

stormy22

793 posts

168 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
The option I would choose isn't there.

"It will make little difference unless they install speed camera's also."

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
To me, it looked like the Primera overtook on a blind bend and heat the HGV head-on.

Won't lowering the limit make people more annoyed and want to speed up, thus taking more chances on dodgy overtakes.

mike9009

11,017 posts

274 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
As a result of that crash, the more sensible suggestion would be to make it one way.....

saaby93

Original Poster:

32,038 posts

209 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Added both suggestions -although a DC would only be on the cards if it was busy enough
You cant convert every road into a DC scratchchin


road here
http://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=Laceby+Manor+Golf+...

Does it look any different to a normal road?


Edited by saaby93 on Saturday 13th April 13:39

AnotherGareth

215 posts

205 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
I reckon that anyone keeping to the existing speed limit should have little trouble driving safely along that section of road, so lowering the limit will mainly penalise the vast majority of drivers who manage not to crash in that area.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
The thought of a head on collision between a car and even a 7.5 tonne vehicle at 30mph makes me shudder. Speed wasnt the factor here.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
To me, it looked like the Primera overtook on a blind bend and heat the HGV head-on.

Won't lowering the limit make people more annoyed and want to speed up, thus taking more chances on dodgy overtakes.
What are the chances that the dead peoples' car was doing more than 60mph I wonder?

The only thing that will make the road safer is engineering. I just looked along there on street view - it's a fast, flowing road, easy to drive at or indeed well over 60mph for most of it by the looks of it. All of the junctions, verges, sight lines and markings are set up for a much slower speed though, and that's what is making it so lethal.

sunbeam alpine

7,251 posts

219 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm in Belgium, and I live just off a road which had it's limit lowered from 90 kmh to 70 kmh about 4 years ago.

This has always been a bad road - 2 wide lanes where it was easy to overtake, and dead straight so good visibility. There were regularly accidents (some fatal) when the limit was 90kmh. I hate driving it now as there are quite a few places where the police can hide (and they do this regularly), and if you drive it at 70 kmh you often do it with a truck up your arse.

There has actually been an increase in accidents since the change has been brought in, but no fatalities, so maybe it is safer?

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Rural A and B roads are being dropped to 50 in Derbyshire and Cheshire.

I have used these roads for longer than I care to remember and I have identified hazards presented by the lower limit.

(1)..Incompetent drivers pass lorries where they have passed lorries for years and seem incapable of judging distance. I have witnessed four near head on collisions as they take longer to overtake and find themselves facing an oncoming vehicle. I saw no such incidents in the previous thirty years.

(2)..I can almost guarantee that the driver in front of me will lose concentration as a result of a low speed limit that feels unnatural. When I catch them up and follow, they will start to look at anything but the road ahead. When a sheep steps out into the road, guess what happens behind the first car in the queue?

(3)..An unnaturally low speed limit has a soporific effect. We really need more drivers falling asleep, don't we?

gog440

9,298 posts

221 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Strangely enough I drove that road only 2 weeks ago, if (as has been suggested) the car driver was overtaking on that bend he was a bloody idiot,there is a decent straight just after that corner that is perfectly safe to overtake on.
I had a very enjoyable blast down there overtaking where it is safe, but I have always followed the rule that if you arent 100% sure you can make the overtake dont do it.

GrumpyTwig

3,354 posts

188 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Presumably they would have all been fine if it'd happened at 50mph?

Speed changes are on the whole just an excuse to temporarily get out of redesigning poorly laid out roads.

I'd guess the car was attempting an overtake?

RacerMDR

5,582 posts

241 months

Saturday 13th April 2013
quotequote all
Where is the option for better driver training? Making the licence a privilege not a right

I don't see why the road should be adjusted to the lowest standard. Why should the rest of us have to be subjected to dumbing down because of one incompetent or a mistake?

Edited by RacerMDR on Saturday 13th April 14:25