New PH game - car poker!
Discussion
I was re-reading an ancient James May book the other day and found the excerpt below. I think it would be a brilliant idea for a game to play on PH. Someone posts on this thread what they are looking to buy, and hopefully finds someone else about to buy the same thing. They can then start their own thread for that individual competition. Once both players are ready, copious photos of each car can be uploaded for the PH collective to judge. Loser send the winner a small prize of some sort in the post. Read May's explanation of it, and let the games begin!








I remember reading that ages ago.. But it's only now occured to me that fellow PHer BorkFactor and I have done exactly this 

Two E46 328is, mine inspired by his, bought for within £50 of the same money two months later. And then two months after that, here they both are hundreds of miles from home, halfway through a stunning full-bore drive around the Cairngorms to the Lecht ski centre
You be the judge..
BorkFactor:


McSam:


I can tell you one thing, they turn out to be pretty evenly matched on a good B-road! Not much difference in spec between them and both have been very well looked after. They've also performed very similarly in terms of running costs over the last year (very little maintenence needed, despite 120k and 142k miles on them).
Though clearly my tan interior, sunroof and slightly later clear lenses make mine far superior


Two E46 328is, mine inspired by his, bought for within £50 of the same money two months later. And then two months after that, here they both are hundreds of miles from home, halfway through a stunning full-bore drive around the Cairngorms to the Lecht ski centre

You be the judge..

BorkFactor:


McSam:

I can tell you one thing, they turn out to be pretty evenly matched on a good B-road! Not much difference in spec between them and both have been very well looked after. They've also performed very similarly in terms of running costs over the last year (very little maintenence needed, despite 120k and 142k miles on them).
Though clearly my tan interior, sunroof and slightly later clear lenses make mine far superior

McSam said:
I remember reading that ages ago.. But it's only now occured to me that fellow PHer BorkFactor and I have done exactly this 

Two E46 328is, mine inspired by his, bought for within £50 of the same money two months later. And then two months after that, here they both are hundreds of miles from home, halfway through a stunning full-bore drive around the Cairngorms to the Lecht ski centre
You be the judge..
I can tell you one thing, they turn out to be pretty evenly matched on a good B-road! Not much difference in spec between them and both have been very well looked after. They've also performed very similarly in terms of running costs over the last year (very little maintenence needed, despite 120k and 142k miles on them).
Though clearly my tan interior, sunroof and slightly later clear lenses make mine far superior
Bork Factor edges slightly for me, just because of the ambers.

Two E46 328is, mine inspired by his, bought for within £50 of the same money two months later. And then two months after that, here they both are hundreds of miles from home, halfway through a stunning full-bore drive around the Cairngorms to the Lecht ski centre

You be the judge..

I can tell you one thing, they turn out to be pretty evenly matched on a good B-road! Not much difference in spec between them and both have been very well looked after. They've also performed very similarly in terms of running costs over the last year (very little maintenence needed, despite 120k and 142k miles on them).
Though clearly my tan interior, sunroof and slightly later clear lenses make mine far superior

Both seems ace mind.
31mph said:
mat777 said:
May on Motors. its a collection of his columns, like the Clarkson books. However, I find his writing more mature and with more deadpan humour
Yes, I like this extract - I'll check if this is on KindleThanks

BorkFactor said:
Ah yes, our thread has indeed arrived 
You can tell the only photo I took was the interior pic of my car
And of course, we all know that traditional amber lenses and black leather are the way to go
I'm normally an amber fan but some colours suit clear better. FWIW I'm about to put clears on my E36. But black leather wins! Nice cars chaps! You can tell the only photo I took was the interior pic of my car

And of course, we all know that traditional amber lenses and black leather are the way to go

Codswallop said:
Tough one - I prefer the tan leather of McSam's car, but I like the standard ride height and ginger-cators on BorkFactor's car 
Interesting - they're the same ride height 
both completely standard 328i SEs on the same wheels and 205/55R16 tyres! It does look lower at the front in the head-to-head photo, but I think I'm on a bit of an incline.Bork was a real advocate of orange indicators - he will absolutely love ginger-cators because he is in fact ginger himself
- but he actually preferred my clear lenses when we got the cars side by side! I do too, but I know it divides opinion a bit.I'll stick with my clears!

Any bonus points for a cleaner engine bay?

As for a judging poll, maybe we should put something in Reader's Cars when we get time! It's really interesting to see that, even just here, votes for tan vs black and clear vs ginger are pretty evenly split!
vladcjelli said:
31mph said:
mat777 said:
May on Motors. its a collection of his columns, like the Clarkson books. However, I find his writing more mature and with more deadpan humour
Yes, I like this extract - I'll check if this is on KindleThanks

McSam said:
Interesting - they're the same ride height
both completely standard 328i SEs on the same wheels and 205/55R16 tyres! It does look lower at the front in the head-to-head photo, but I think I'm on a bit of an incline.
Bork was a real advocate of orange indicators - he will absolutely love ginger-cators because he is in fact ginger himself
- but he actually preferred my clear lenses when we got the cars side by side! I do too, but I know it divides opinion a bit.
I'll stick with my clears!
That is right - both cars ride at the same height. Although didn't we find out that yours had Sport suspension?
both completely standard 328i SEs on the same wheels and 205/55R16 tyres! It does look lower at the front in the head-to-head photo, but I think I'm on a bit of an incline.Bork was a real advocate of orange indicators - he will absolutely love ginger-cators because he is in fact ginger himself
- but he actually preferred my clear lenses when we got the cars side by side! I do too, but I know it divides opinion a bit.I'll stick with my clears!
I am still undecided about the indicators, the clear ones make the car look much more modern, but I think the ginger ones work well with the colour. They look terrible on a silver 316i with steel wheels though. Plus they match my hair

One of us will pop a thread up in Readers Rides with a poll later today I'm sure, sounds a good way to spend a coffee break!
Glad you all like the cars though, they are awesome machines.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




