Learner car vs curb appeal?
Learner car vs curb appeal?
Author
Discussion

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm after a car for a driving school and I initially had in mind something ordinary like a Focus, Auris or 1 series.

However, I think back to when I was learning to drive and was wondering whether I was influenced by the type of car the driving school ran and I guess I was a little. I wouldn't have wanted to learn in anything tiny for example.

There are some interesting smaller cars out there now and I'm wondering what you all think could be an appealing car to drive as a learner?

MINI; too dated now or a good choice?

Fiat 500; too girly for the boys?

Citroen DS3; too boy racer?

All with question marks as these are not necessarily my opinion but are they right and are there any other cars that would be suitable?

Must have 3 or 5 doors, a rear seat and not a convertible (DSA rules).
My own criteria are that it must be good on fuel, reliable and not too powerful (how very un-PH) smile

Budget is probably upto £15k.
New, probably but could be used and not too old.

Over to you smile


okie592

2,711 posts

198 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I chose my driving school because the instructors were good.

I know a few people who picked there's for the cars ( Audi a1) ds3 etc

Most of those are still learning.

I like the ds3 and in white or black it would attract both m and f but personally I don't think students should be picking on the car

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Thinking back to when I passed my test, it was more down to reputation than car - if half a dozen classmates had all passed first time with so-and-so, then they tended to get more custom as a result.

There are a couple of local driving driving schools that use Panda 100HPs - they look reasonably cool, they're small enough not to be off-putting to nervous types and I imagine they're relatively cheap to run.

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd have thought the DS3 appeals to the girls as well doesn't it, nice looking car apart from the silly vertical DRL's

All those options are slightly trendier than standard Fiesta/Polo so could be a draw for potential pupils, but to be honest when I was learning the price was more important than the car (1.6 diesel Escort).

Slow

6,973 posts

168 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Why not go for something bigger?

I wish i didnt learn in such a small car, when i got my own focus it felt huge compared to my instructers car.

Palms

254 posts

182 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Would choose a ds3 myself as they look apealing to both sex's, then start to build your reputation on getting good pass rates and the car will become less important

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
M5.

I'll pay you now for lessons and i've had a licence for 10 years.

HustleRussell

26,709 posts

191 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
DS3? Nice big alloys which will in all probability be ruined within a week.

I learned to drive in a Corsa 'C', so clearly I chose my instructor based on his reputation rather than what car he used. When I see 'A'-class, 1-series, A1, mini etc learner cars I assume it's a gimmick to get more potential students interested though, It probably works for some.

George7

1,130 posts

181 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
When I was learning in a dowdy 1.3 CDTI Corsa, I remember being a bit jealous of the driving schools which used hot, or even mildly warm hatches such as the Fiesta Zetec S. For this reason, the Panda 100HPs are a good suggestion. The DS3 has a pretty good image too, but as mentioned, big 17 (maybe even 18" alloys, not sure) will get ruined extremely quickly, the tyre costs will probably be quite steep too. The Corsa was pretty depressing though, don't get one of those tongue out

Obviously I chose my instructor based on recommendations and reputation, but a more interesting car would've been a bonus.

Edited by George7 on Monday 15th April 15:13

MGZRod

8,176 posts

207 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Something Bright with good visability.

good visibility = easier manouvers which = better driving by pupils which = higher pass rate which = good reputation.

From what i've heard/done (I passed in 2010) mmany folk go on word of mouth now, as opposed to school/car.

I've passed on details of my instructor to about 6-7 folk over the past couple years.

Carl-H

947 posts

237 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I learnt to drive in a K12 Nissan Micra. Obviously the instructors car had no bearing on who I chose for me.

I do see plenty of girls learning in minis and stuff though and I think for the majority of you get people now, they'd rather drive a better car. I chose my instructor as I knew he was fair. I only had 6 lessons before my test and passed first time so he didn't drag it out to make money.

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
What influenced me was not the car at all, it was purely the price. Many 17 year olds now ask...how much a lesson? etc
Learning to drive is expensive and unless daddy's paying, then price is the big issue.
Get a car that has all the main essentials, if YOU can't jump in it and feel pretty comfortable straight away then a learners experience will be a lot worse. Get the car that feels the best, easiest to adjust, and isn't too large and intimidating to a learner. A ds3 is almost 4metres long, a mini is a foot less. Something worth considering.

Perd Hapley

1,750 posts

204 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Well, today I learned that you can't take a driving test in a Toyota iQ.

gov.uk said:
Vehicles you can’t use
Some models of vehicle can’t be used for the test. This is because they don’t give the examiner all-round vision. They are generally convertible cars and panel vans.

You can’t use these cars for a driving test:

BMW Mini convertible
Ford KA convertible
Toyota iQ
VW Beetle convertible
What's the all round vision problem with the convertibles listed? Is there an obstructive rollbar or something?

VTECBOY

352 posts

175 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I learned to drive in a 1litre fiesta last year and I thought it was a great car! I have seen some odd instructor cars up here such as BMW's, Audi's. girlfriend was learning to drive in a mini clubman 1.6 for some odd reason? I would say get a fiesta smile

VTECBOY

352 posts

175 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I learned to drive in a 1litre fiesta last year and I thought it was a great car! I have seen some odd instructor cars up here such as BMW's, Audi's. girlfriend was learning to drive in a mini clubman 1.6 for some odd reason? I would say get a fiesta smile

VTECBOY

352 posts

175 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I learned to drive in a 1litre fiesta last year and I thought it was a great car! I have seen some odd instructor cars up here such as BMW's, Audi's. girlfriend was learning to drive in a mini clubman 1.6 for some odd reason? I would say get a fiesta smile

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
My first instructor had a focus and was a retard. My second had a Fiesta and actually knew how to drive.

A small number of people might pick an instructor for the car, but most of them won't care and will go on reputation or price.

VTECBOY

352 posts

175 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
^ stupid smartphone frown

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I learnt in a little Toyota Yaris, a 1.4 Diesel I believe.

It was a great little car to learn in and the clutch was very easy to get used to as a new driver. Don't think I stalled it once!

My choice of Instructor came from family friend recommendation - not the car. I actually had no clue what car the instructor had until he turned up for my first lesson smile

B19GRR

1,980 posts

287 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
In the time that I've known MsGRRs BIL, he's had a Mini, a Punto and is now on a DS4 (yes 4) which he really likes, I find the E-brake a bit suspect. I can't help thinking that learner cars are way to flash these days as I'm another 'learnt in a crappy Micra' success story. Sign of the times though I guess, Dave's a good teacher though with a high success rate getting business by word of mouth so I guess it's not hugely important what he's teaching in.

Cheers,
Rob