Cam Belt Failure - Seasonal?
Cam Belt Failure - Seasonal?
Author
Discussion

toad_oftoadhall

Original Poster:

936 posts

282 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
It occurs to me that cam belt failure might be more common on startup on icy winter mornings. (Materials brittle, possibly cams more reluctant to turn with oil ice cold.)

Anyone confirm or debunk this totally unfounded musing?

Meths

2,111 posts

167 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
If it fails on a cold morning, it's probably well past its "use before" date.


Rubber tends to be more durable in the cold; Although cyclic heating and cooling in winter may have an effect.

cptsideways

13,900 posts

283 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
The load on the belt is massive from cold

Evoluzione

10,345 posts

274 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
No, I don't think there is any particular time of day, season or part of engine cycle when a belt goes, it's just down to old age or faulty fitting.

legless

2,064 posts

171 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
I can't think of the last time I actually saw a failed timing belt as a result of the belt itself letting go.

Most of the ones I've seen involve disintegrated pulleys, seized tensioners/water pumps or a failed accessory drive belt flailing around and ripping the timing belt in the process.

Evoluzione

10,345 posts

274 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
legless said:
I can't think of the last time I actually saw a failed timing belt as a result of the belt itself letting go.

Most of the ones I've seen involve disintegrated pulleys, seized tensioners/water pumps or a failed accessory drive belt flailing around and ripping the timing belt in the process.
A little reminder for you:


mat777

10,714 posts

191 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
For a cambelt to just snap by itself (assuming its not defective), youll have to be running it for long after its due milage/age to be services

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
mat777 said:
For a cambelt to just snap by itself (assuming its not defective), youll have to be running it for long after its due milage/age to be services
Honestly Matt, why?

Why?

cptsideways

13,900 posts

283 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
mat777 said:
For a cambelt to just snap by itself (assuming its not defective), youll have to be running it for long after its due milage/age to be services
You've not owned an Alfa have you hehe

legless

2,064 posts

171 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Evoluzione said:
A little reminder for you:

Exactly. This happens, but all the recent ones I've seen have not been caused by the belt itself breaking - instead it has been a failure of another component that has either caused the belt to break or lose tension.

Bear Phils

891 posts

167 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
This thread is just what I needed to reassure myself about a suspected noisy pulley...

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
You've not owned an Alfa have you hehe
Try half the stated service interval hehe

ismellburning

136 posts

169 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
Evoluzione said:
A little reminder for you:

Pardon my ignorance, what exactly are we looking at here?

BrewsterBear

1,548 posts

223 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
ismellburning said:
Evoluzione said:
A little reminder for you:

Pardon my ignorance, what exactly are we looking at here?
Are you kidding? It's a broken belt, many bent valves and one valve which has broken and rattled around inside the cylinder, but the looks of it. This is what happens when a cambelt breaks on an interference engine.

rsox87

151 posts

185 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
ismellburning said:
Pardon my ignorance, what exactly are we looking at here?
Those are the valves that let fuel/air charge in, and burnt exhaust gases out of the cylinder. They should all be dead straight and in one piece. In this case, the cam belt has snapped, so the cams have stopped rotating and some of the valves have been left extended whilst the pistons continue to go up and down. Most modern engines have an "interferance" design, which means that if the valves are down then the piston will hit them before it reaches top dead centre and starts to go down again. This is A Bad Thing. As well as the valve damage, the tops of the pistons and the valve seats (the guides that the valves slide in inside the top of the engine) are probably damaged too. It's likely that this engine is only good for scrap. Get your cambelts done on time folks!

(alternatively, get a car with a camchain)

(alternatively to the alternative, get an RX7 or an RX8. No cams = no problems, right?)

Triumph Man

9,652 posts

199 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
mat777 said:
For a cambelt to just snap by itself (assuming its not defective), youll have to be running it for long after its due milage/age to be services
You've not owned an Alfa have you hehe
I remember my dad buying a 156 a few years ago, he booked it immediately in for a cam belt change, but until it went in winced everytime he turned it over, in case it went!

cptsideways

13,900 posts

283 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
The joys of many a pre 2005 Toyota engine, just wait till the belt breaks & pop a new one on & away you go.

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
mat777 said:
For a cambelt to just snap by itself (assuming its not defective), youll have to be running it for long after its due milage/age to be services
Dross!

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
BrewsterBear said:
ismellburning said:
Evoluzione said:
A little reminder for you:

Pardon my ignorance, what exactly are we looking at here?
Are you kidding? It's a broken belt, many bent valves and one valve which has broken and rattled around inside the cylinder, but the looks of it. This is what happens when a cambelt breaks on an interference engine.
Ignorance is bliss! cry

cptsideways

13,900 posts

283 months

Tuesday 16th April 2013
quotequote all
mat777 said:
For a cambelt to just snap by itself (assuming its not defective), youll have to be running it for long after its due milage/age to be services
Unless the application was badly designed in the first place wink