Howdy...my first 'what car?' post
Discussion
Hi everyone,
This is my first post so please be gentle(!)
I'm looking to buy a family runaround, and have a tight budget of <£2,500. The car will not be used everyday as it isn't needed for commuting, but will be used perhaps a dozen times a month on a mixture of runs, ranging from just a couple of miles right up to 600+ mile cross-country jaunts.
Other requirements are as follows:
- Car needs to be 2001 (Y-plate) or newer to allow use of personal plate
- Needs to average a real-world 35mpg or better across all driving styles
- A boot big enough to swallow a child's buggy
- A toddler seat will sometimes be used, so needs either five door or ability to safely accommodate toddler seat in front
- Reliability. I realise this is a tough to guarantee, but I don't want to buy something that is known for being incredibly unreliable.
That's about it really. I'm easy on styles and brands, and condition and quality is more important to me than mileage, but it would be good to get something nice and comfortable. Options so far include BMW 318 SE saloon (circa 2002) with 80-90k miles, Audi A4 2.0 SE (circa 2001) with similar miles, VW Golf 1.9 TDi 130bhp (circa 2002) with 100k miles, Vauxhall Vectra 1.8 (2004-2005) with 80k miles, and Mercedes A170 CDI (2003) with 80k miles.
Are any of these especially good/bad choices, and what other worthwhile options are there? Finally, if it were possible to increase the budget, would this be a worthwhile move?
Cheers.
This is my first post so please be gentle(!)
I'm looking to buy a family runaround, and have a tight budget of <£2,500. The car will not be used everyday as it isn't needed for commuting, but will be used perhaps a dozen times a month on a mixture of runs, ranging from just a couple of miles right up to 600+ mile cross-country jaunts.
Other requirements are as follows:
- Car needs to be 2001 (Y-plate) or newer to allow use of personal plate
- Needs to average a real-world 35mpg or better across all driving styles
- A boot big enough to swallow a child's buggy
- A toddler seat will sometimes be used, so needs either five door or ability to safely accommodate toddler seat in front
- Reliability. I realise this is a tough to guarantee, but I don't want to buy something that is known for being incredibly unreliable.
That's about it really. I'm easy on styles and brands, and condition and quality is more important to me than mileage, but it would be good to get something nice and comfortable. Options so far include BMW 318 SE saloon (circa 2002) with 80-90k miles, Audi A4 2.0 SE (circa 2001) with similar miles, VW Golf 1.9 TDi 130bhp (circa 2002) with 100k miles, Vauxhall Vectra 1.8 (2004-2005) with 80k miles, and Mercedes A170 CDI (2003) with 80k miles.
Are any of these especially good/bad choices, and what other worthwhile options are there? Finally, if it were possible to increase the budget, would this be a worthwhile move?
Cheers.
Another vote for the Octavia - I've run a 1.9TDi Estate (Mahoosive boot) for the last two years mostly for daily commuting (130 miles per day). It also gets lent to the kids for 700 mile+ round trip weekend visits with their kids, buggies, dog etc and is also happy to do the short weekend tip runs etc.
Anything with that engine will do the job you need but if it's boot space then the Octavia is the one to go for. Your budget will comfortable get you a 2003/4 car.
Anything with that engine will do the job you need but if it's boot space then the Octavia is the one to go for. Your budget will comfortable get you a 2003/4 car.
Thanks for all the suggestions so far.
I quite like the Octavia, having been a passenger in numerous taxi examples they always seemed to me to be comfortable cars. I think the vRS models would prove to be a bit too thirsty as I imagine the bulk of my driving will be local, and motorway driving will be limited.
The Civic is another car that I hadn't considered. I have to say I find they look quite dated to my eye, although I'm sure they would satisfy every requirement on my list. I am a fan of Honda cars too.
The Avensis in that advert seems like a bargain, and actually they seem ideal in general. I am a fan of the shape too (not quite sure why?).
I like the Saab a lot and always have. I think the interior is as nice as anything I can find within my approximate budget, and the car hasn't really dated that much to my eyes either. I worry a little about reliability as I have relatives who have owned Saabs and they cost a fair amount to keep going.
Is there no love for a 2001-2002 BMW 316i SE or Audi A4 2.0 then?
Once again, thanks for the suggestions so far...please keep them coming.
I quite like the Octavia, having been a passenger in numerous taxi examples they always seemed to me to be comfortable cars. I think the vRS models would prove to be a bit too thirsty as I imagine the bulk of my driving will be local, and motorway driving will be limited.
The Civic is another car that I hadn't considered. I have to say I find they look quite dated to my eye, although I'm sure they would satisfy every requirement on my list. I am a fan of Honda cars too.
The Avensis in that advert seems like a bargain, and actually they seem ideal in general. I am a fan of the shape too (not quite sure why?).
I like the Saab a lot and always have. I think the interior is as nice as anything I can find within my approximate budget, and the car hasn't really dated that much to my eyes either. I worry a little about reliability as I have relatives who have owned Saabs and they cost a fair amount to keep going.
Is there no love for a 2001-2002 BMW 316i SE or Audi A4 2.0 then?
Once again, thanks for the suggestions so far...please keep them coming.
I'd suggest scanning through the Real world MPG WIKI the 20vt motors can crack over 30mpg.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=718...
no love for the 316i as it has the most poor 8v 100hp engine which can barely be described as efficient in a E30 3 series BMW let alone a E46 weighing 300kg more
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=718...
no love for the 316i as it has the most poor 8v 100hp engine which can barely be described as efficient in a E30 3 series BMW let alone a E46 weighing 300kg more
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


