17yo Male First Car Advice
17yo Male First Car Advice
Author
Discussion

CaptainBlue

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Hello PistonHeads! This is my first post here so please bear with me as a newbie.

My son is 17 very soon and is keen to get his first car - financed mainly by Bank of Dad - whereas I'm keen not to throw loadsa money at insurance companies unnecessarily.

Budget is around £5k for car plus insurance.

Preferences are for coolness, low insurance, reliability ... the usual.

Any suggestions?

I was thinking along the lines of a 3-5 year old Ibiza or Polo but was also thinking slightly more creatively at maybe an early MX-5 with some form of classic policy? Is this an option for a 17 year old? He lives in Norfolkcestershire so at least that should help with the insurance rates generally but also means a Smart of something off the wall is probably out of the question.

HustleRussell

26,708 posts

191 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
just hammer the insurance comparison sites and also ring some 'young driver' specialist insurers. Don't think the MX5 will be do-able now (Unless you're talking £1k car and £4k insurance!). The 'classic car' angle is getting much harder to exploit since most specialists now place a minimum driver age of 21/25 on them.

ETA: A lot of people will now post statements like "shop around I insured an MX5 as my first car for £550 blah blah blah", but they'll neglect to mention that it was eight years ago and they live in a cottage in a village in rural oxfordshire where there hasn't been a car theift since 1987 and the only reportable incident was mrs. davis scraping her Suzuki on a cattle grid in 1996.



Edited by HustleRussell on Wednesday 17th April 11:39

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
i believe that to have a car on a classic policy, it needs to be a second car.
Best thing to do is to spend and afternoon plugging in your sons details and the details of various cars into a price comparison site like moneysupermarket.com


anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
The main advice I have seen on here in the past is to think outside the box

Many young uns drive and crash hatchbacks and as such these can have higher premiums. Sometimes a more powerful Saloon can be cheaper than a hatch.

I think you will struggle with a classic at that age.


soad

34,761 posts

207 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Isn't there a minimum age (for policyholder) in order to take out a classic car policy?
Plus car has to be garaged overnight?

430T

942 posts

165 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Try an Aygo, insurable for under £1000 if you try hard enough.

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
i believe that to have a car on a classic policy, it needs to be a second car.
That certainly was not true 10 years ago.

soad said:
Plus car has to be garaged overnight?
And nor was that.

There is no specific blanket minimum age, but I wouldn't be surprised if none of the companies actually offer classic policies to really young drivers these days.

Juffled

189 posts

213 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
i believe that to have a car on a classic policy, it needs to be a second car.
nope not true, lotus elise and mx5 both insured as classic cars and only cars at some point in their time with me

iJam

7 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
a 1303 beetle was the cheapest car to insure when i was 17, im 21 now though, might have changed since then

crostonian

2,427 posts

203 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Sure I've just read somewhere that Footman James had started to insure classics to 17 year olds providing they could prove they were bona fide enthusiasts and not just buying a classic as a cheap way to insure a car, not sure how they prove this apart from ensuring you belong to an owner's club or similar.

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Old Ford Ka, plus insurance for a year - with the promise of a couple of grand to upgrade after 12 months if he's still points and accident free?

Insurance will be a significant bumming regardless of the car - although it's true that an old saloon can be cheaper than a smaller hatch' for some circumstances.

CaptainBlue

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks all. Good advice so far, but not keen on the Aygo in relation to "cool".

His elder sister is on her second 08 Ka (as she had here first one written off after a very low speed shunt), but then she's 21.

angusfaldo

2,831 posts

305 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
430T said:
Try an Aygo, insurable for under £1000 if you try hard enough.
Can you back this statement up? I'd be delighted to find insurance for my 17 year old on her 107 at that price.


Fartgalen

6,938 posts

238 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
Old Ford Ka, plus insurance for a year - with the promise of a couple of grand to upgrade after 12 months if he's still points and accident free?

Insurance will be a significant bumming regardless of the car - although it's true that an old saloon can be cheaper than a smaller hatch' for some circumstances.
Yes, this is the general response.
4 or 5k on first car is not necessary given that it's almost certain it'll get damaged.
1k Punto, Ka, etc, etc does the trick. That's what my daughter got.
She's only scraped a couple of plastic wheel trims, so she might be getting an upgrade this year. But she'll not be using Bank of Dad this time wink

Slow

6,973 posts

168 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Dont look at hatchbacks.

As a quick guess i would say a 520i insures for the same price as a 1.6 hatchback.

+ a bigger car gets mates and such in.

MysteryLemon

4,968 posts

222 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Reality is that with a 5k budget, you will likely be looking at £3500 for insurance and £1500 for a car.

As for going for a bigger car with a big engine because they will insure it for the same? So? Just because you can put a 17 year old in a 150hp BMW for the same price as a 100hp 1.6, doesn't mean you should.

How about a 1.0 or 1.4 Lupo?

Edited by MysteryLemon on Wednesday 17th April 12:00

StottyZr

6,860 posts

194 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
  • Make a list of cars that he is interested in (20 different cars would be ideal)
  • Go through the classifieds and find an example of each, note the number plates to the corresponding cars on the list.
  • Go onto confused.com and setup a quote for the first car on the list, add 2 additional drivers (both with clean licences and 40+) run a quote, then change small details such as where the car is parked, his occupation (between student/his part-time job) until the quote is the lowest possible.
  • Go through each number plate and run the quote, note down each amount.
From this information you'll be able to work out what gives the best value for money.

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
i believe that to have a car on a classic policy, it needs to be a second car.
Best thing to do is to get your son to plug his details and the details of various cars into a price comparison site like moneysupermarket.com
Fixed.

Buy a Kia Rio, if it is uncool he won't try to show off in it and if he doesn't like it kick him in his ungrateful face.

430T

942 posts

165 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
angusfaldo said:
Can you back this statement up? I'd be delighted to find insurance for my 17 year old on her 107 at that price.
yes

A mates taking out a policy soon at that price, with pass plus and both parents as additional drivers with a category B postcode and I believe its with Admiral, however I will ask him later smile

StottyZr

6,860 posts

194 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
To backup my method, I used it last week to help a friend. He's 20 and is looking for something more special than his Avensis laugh

We made the list etc and found that he can insure a Clio 197 for about £80 more than his Avensis! Compared to rivals the Clio 197 is very cheap to insure for him. We only found this gem through running identical quotes for each car in the list.