What Un-PH car for an frugal 25k a year?
What Un-PH car for an frugal 25k a year?
Author
Discussion

Jakg

Original Poster:

4,070 posts

199 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Friend of mines just got his first proper job with lots of money... only it's 60 miles away, so he's looking at a 120 mile commute which works out to be 25k a year.

He can get the train, but a season ticket works out to be £4k a year - driving works out much faster, but also slightly cheaper... if the car can do 55+MPG.

He's currently doing it in an old T-Reg Petrol Astra, but he's thinking of getting another car so his wife can use the Astra and he can use the new car to commute.

Originally they were thinking some new "65 MPG" Vauxhall on finance but I don't think that's such a good idea. I would say realistically they only have a few K to spend on the car right now, but will have lots spare each month which is why they were thinking finance (but we all know PH's opinion on that!)

My suggestion was either something like a BMW ed / VW BlueMotion but both of those are still going to be a fair wedge even second hand. The other option was an Audi A2 TDI. Can PH think of anything else?

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
A prius

Exceedingly reliable and frugal


And before anyone tells you the battery pack will fail could they please show me a company that overhauls the battery pack

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Citroen AX Diesel. Costs peanuts to buy, capable of 100mpg.

YMMV

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

197 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:
A prius

Exceedingly reliable and frugal


And before anyone tells you the battery pack will fail could they please show me a company that overhauls the battery pack
A Pruis (and any other hybrid) is good in town, but on the motorway is constantly running on engine power alone, therefore they're not much more economical than a standard small engined petrol car.

Something diesel powered and long geared would be my choice. Mondeo TDCi - plenty of choice out there and is comfortable enough for driving long distances.

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
At 60 miles each way the best kind of engine will be a small efficient diesel, not a hybrid IMO. Something like the VAG 1.6 tdi. Getting a new car on a cheap PCP or lease is probably a good shout really - at big miles it will be good to have a warranty. Check out a cheap Hyundai for their 5 year unlimited mileage warranty.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Jakg said:
I would say realistically they only have a few K to spend on the car right now, but will have lots spare each month which is why they were thinking finance (but we all know PH's opinion on that!)
If he is brave he could go for the worlds cheapest car

The infamous K11 micra 1000cc

Its slow, its noisy, its not very comfortable but it will do 45Mpg and they cannot be killed

Run it for 6 months and put the savings into an account and then they can afford a nice german diesel.



Just don't sell the Micra as they will need it when the nice german diesel goes pop

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
As an example, Freedom Contracts have a V40 D2 for £280 inc VAT on a 3+35 lease for 20k miles. That does 78.5 combined (allegedly).

MagicalTrevor

6,481 posts

260 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Amateurish said:
As an example, Freedom Contracts have a V40 D2 for £280 inc VAT on a 3+35 lease for 20k miles. That does 78.5 combined (allegedly).
Just about to post this. I'm considering one for a 18.5k annual commute. there is a 94g/km version that does a claimed 84mpg!!!

talksthetalk

10,821 posts

166 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
If it's motorway miles the I'd suggest a second hand Leon ecomotive.
Under 10k now, golf bluemotion engine, but 2 k cheaper, or 50K miles less!
If it's urban then a Prius.
BUT are you sure economy is priority number 1?
Usually a balance between money and 'nice stuff'-whether that is leather and sat nav or a bit of poker or image are factors. Just re-read 't reg astra, so scrub the image bit
biggrin

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
octavia with the old vag tdi engine, there is a reason plenty are used as taxis

MrC986

3,755 posts

222 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I had a similar dilemma....I looked long and hard and given the commuting distances bought a large comfortable car...a well spec'd 2003 Saab 9-5 2.2 tid estate in my case - 100k miles, FSH and all for under £2.5k. Given I do mostly country roads/motorway, it is currently showing 45 mpg. Oh, and it has a chain driven engine rather than a cambelt. Sadly diesel VW's and similar seemed expensive. The other option for the OP could be a French derived diesel car if they are brave! Good luck and be patient wink

PS it maybe relatively 'uncool' but it still has a 'smiley' on the back! thumbup

Jakg

Original Poster:

4,070 posts

199 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
talksthetalk said:
If it's motorway miles...
Sorry should of said - pretty much all dual carraigeway.
McWigglebum4th said:
A prius
In the real world, what sort of MPG will a Prius get doing 70 on a dual carriageway vs a modern diesel?
Amateurish said:
As an example, Freedom Contracts have a V40 D2 for £280 inc VAT on a 3+35 lease for 20k miles. That does 78.5 combined (allegedly).
I looked at Freedom Contracts (just because I saw they had an Up! for something rediculous like £60 a month!) but I have to be honest I don't that know much about Leasing.

Trying to find a Lease deal for 20+kpa seems to be quite difficult, but I'm also seeing a lot of business vs personal leases. I don't think he can get any sort of company car / company car allowance etc so I take it he wouldn't be eligible for a business lease?
Crusoe said:
octavia with the old vag tdi engine, there is a reason plenty are used as taxis
olly22n said:
A4 1.9tdi.
What sort of age?
talksthetalk said:
BUT are you sure economy is priority number 1?
At the moment - yes. An S-Class would be a lovely way to get there, but getting a train costs half as much they'd just do that. The biggest advantage of the car is time-saving, but it has to work out cheaper than the train to be worth it.

The problem is his wife is convinced that the car *has* do 65+ MPG to be "worth" it which is why she's looking at brand new cars (which I don't think is a good idea - they were also looking at "traditional" finance but I think leasing is the only way to make the numbers stack up) but honestly I don't think they'll get that sort of economy out of anything (and I also don't think they are properly accounting for other running costs). If it was me I'd get something like a diesel Rover 75 etc, and put up with 45MPG but loads of cash left over but she seems to have a mental block on the MPG (and how much it costs to tax - don't even get me started!)

Was hoping to get a few suggestions so I could sit down with them and work out how much a "cheap" less economical car (such as an "old" VAG TDI or similar) costs versus a "new" economical car (but that has bucketloads of depreciation etc to come).



Thanks PH smile

andy-ski

86 posts

221 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm about to get an Alfa 147 JTDm 57 plate 60k miles for much the same annual mileage.
Lovely comfortable leather interior, climate, cruise, parking sensors, sensible 16" alloys for cheap tyres that will last 25-30k anyway.
It will be good for a few years at the rental cost of 1 years leasing.

john_r

8,354 posts

302 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Another vote for a shed Saab - My job means I'm now doing a few more miles so I got a 2004 9-5 2.3t Vector with 48k miles and 9 months MOT for £1,380 from eBay... I'll run it for 3-4 years and scrap it if anything will cost more than £250 to fix. Climate, leather, cruise, electric everything, great stereo, 30mpg+; and so far, apart from a shock (£50 second hand) and a precautionary oil change and sump clean, it's cost nothing but petrol to run it. <touch wood!>

For 25k miles per year, either get a company car or a reliable throwaway shed... imho.

PaulG40

2,381 posts

256 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I do 22k a year and run a peugeot 306 HDi. 50-60mpg. Comfy, pretty fast for what it is, overtaking wise. Cost me £1500 for a 50k mile one!

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I do between 120 & 180 miles round trip for my commute depending what office I'm working in and havea 59 reg S40 1.6d DRIVe stop/start.
It was a bargain from my brother in law hence it wouldn't have been my first choice but on my 180 mile commute on A roads (A17 & A47) it will do 55 mpg (verified). On the 120 mile commute which has dual carriageway it will break 60 mpg.
It has climate, great seats and has just enough punch mid range to overtake lumbering trucks between 40 & 60+ mph.
Steering isn't great and ride can be crashy but overall its about ideal for the job.
I've done 15k miles in so far and its been 100% reliable.
£20 tax as well :-)
I do like the look of the new S40 and in another couple of years that will be my next commuter.
I think they are £0 tax.

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Jakg said:
I looked at Freedom Contracts (just because I saw they had an Up! for something rediculous like £60 a month!) but I have to be honest I don't that know much about Leasing.

Trying to find a Lease deal for 20+kpa seems to be quite difficult, but I'm also seeing a lot of business vs personal leases. I don't think he can get any sort of company car / company car allowance etc so I take it he wouldn't be eligible for a business lease?
No, he wouldn't be elibile for a business lease. If you take the Freedom Contracts site as an example, only some are available as personal deals - those are the ones to look at. Most have the option of 20k miles over 2 or 3 years.

Just think of leasing like an extended car hire. You commit to 2 or 3 years, and make an up front payment of 3 or 6 months. At the end of the term you give the car back. So for the Volvo lease I quoted, the total amount payable is £10,670 over the 3 years. Plus you will need to service it and fit tyres. It might be a good option for someone with little savings but decent monthly disposable.

Bill

58,939 posts

286 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Amateurish said:
No, he wouldn't be elibile for a business lease. If you take the Freedom Contracts site as an example, only some are available as personal deals - those are the ones to look at. Most have the option of 20k miles over 2 or 3 years.

Just think of leasing like an extended car hire. You commit to 2 or 3 years, and make an up front payment of 3 or 6 months. At the end of the term you give the car back. So for the Volvo lease I quoted, the total amount payable is £10,670 over the 3 years. Plus you will need to service it and fit tyres. It might be a good option for someone with little savings but decent monthly disposable.
Not for 25k a year though, they'll end up paying through the nose for the extra mileage.

RizzoTheRat

29,169 posts

223 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I vary between 20k and 30k miles per year, last 3 cars have been

Citroen ZX 1.9TD - Probably a bit too old now but fantastic car, 50+ mpg on a 50/50 mix of diesel and sunflower oil, and lasted until 196000 miles

306HDI - Loads around and fairly cheap to buy, aircon generally won't work so get a sunroof instead, 50+ mpg, heater matrix went at 140k on mine though

Octavia VRS 2.0TDI - averaged 47mpg over the last 30k miles mixed driving, 55mpg average is easily doable if spending more time on motorways. The 1.9TDI should be well within his price range, and as said above there's a reason so many taxi drivers use them.


Re. the Prius, the engine uses a different cycle to a standard petrol engine so they're still more efficient on the motorway than a standard petrol. Bear in midn that diesel's about 4% more expensive than petrol so you only need 48mpg in a petrol to cost the same as 50mpg on diesel (ignoring the difference in purchase cost and servicing)

Buying a new car with the associated depreciation in order to get a slightly better fuel economy is madness.

R26Andy

404 posts

192 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Hold on, I take it he owns the current car.

Surely in almost all cases the cost of a new car is going to far outweight the fuel savings from his current car? Pay £xxx/month on car finance to save £yy/month on fuel?

Sounds like theyve justified driving instead of trains on one set of criteria and then decided to take out finance on another car on another set of criteria.



Edited by R26Andy on Wednesday 17th April 15:05