Which car? S4 vs 645 - help!
Which car? S4 vs 645 - help!
Author
Discussion

mattman

Original Poster:

3,192 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok - 40yrs old this year, decided I need a V8 cabriolet in my life.

Simple criteria - convertible!, 4 seats, auto, heated seats (wife's only stipulation), less than 70k, daily driver spin 10k pa, budget 10- 12k

Think I've looked at/considered most things. Would like a 911 but not that brave to risk engine issues, don't really fancy an m3 for no rational reason so the final choice is either;

Audi S4 - 04 vintage, circa 8k
Or
BMW 645 - 04/05 vintage, circa 11-12k

Both hit the criteria, but concerned the Audi may not be special enough, by this I mean it does look like a 2.0tdi s line, and the Beemer may be a little dull long term

So over to the PH collective - I plan to keep the car 4-5 yrs, I don't want an mx5 + another car - I know it'll do 20mpg if I'm lucky
So what would you go for?

Edited by mattman on Wednesday 17th April 20:38

Oilchange

9,743 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
MG ZT 260.
Something like this...
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/m...

Edited by Oilchange on Wednesday 17th April 20:34

cerb4.5lee

45,310 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
What about a CLK 55 convertible as another option, out of your choices I would go 645i.

mattman

Original Poster:

3,192 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Oilchange said:
MG ZT 260.
Something like this...
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/m...

Edited by Oilchange on Wednesday 17th April 20:34
Doh! Forgot it needs to be cabriolet!

The GMan

2,508 posts

286 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
4 seats?

645 is not a true 4 seater, short journeys are OKish but will still be cramped.

Oilchange

9,743 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all


?

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Oilchange said:
MG ZT 260.
the rare convertible one?

645 for me.

detchibe

471 posts

253 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I have a 645ci coupe and the rear seats are a token gesture. And it's a little dull, I wish I'd bought a cabrio frown

jdwoodbury

1,372 posts

237 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I would for for a CLK55 myself. I had an E60 545i, great for cruising but I never really gave me the V8 experience, if you want a soundtrack then it needs to be the AMG V8. What I would say however the Audi v8 with a Milltek on gives it a good run for the money (and is arguably the more current/modern car).

AdeTuono

7,626 posts

258 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I sold my 645ci after a couple of months as it was one of the dullest cars I've ever owned.

If you do decide to go for one, be aware of an issue that's becoming evident on cars of the age you're contemplating. There's a coolant pipe that runs front to back under the valley cover in the V. Seals on this pipe are starting to perish, causing a leak which looks as if it's coming from the water pump. BMW say that this can only be fixed by a complete engine removal and strip-down and quote 60-odd hours labour. There is a remedy....

http://www.bimmerzone.com/BMW_Performance_Cooling_...

My old car failed a few months after I sold it, and our local BMW specialist repaired it using one of those ^^^. BMW, of course, refuse to acknowledge there's a problem.

Still >£1,000 though.

Alucidnation

16,810 posts

201 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Oh go on then.....













MX5.

M159V8

2,540 posts

177 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
645 with straight through pipes! biggrin

Jimmyarm

1,962 posts

209 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
645 convertible cloud9

An Audi is just, well an Audi/VW/Skoda

ArtVandelay

6,692 posts

215 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Can you not go up to a 650, slightly better engine and improved interior too.

However I think they look ungainly as a soft top. My coupe was fantastic though (still is even though I can no longer drive it)

Heard the manual box isn't great on the 6 series, though no experience of it myself.

LiamM45

1,035 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
The dull looks of the S4 can be a blessing in disguise. I have a B5 S4 and a normal B5 A4, and no one bats an eyelid at the S4, you could park it anywhere, you never worry about it, you never get chavs trying to race you, etc. It's very anonymous and discreet.

The B6's with the V8 do make a lovely noise. Don't expect mega performance though, they are a heavy 4wd car with 340bhp, saying that it's probably similar to the 645.

cerb4.5lee

45,310 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Alucidnation said:
Oh go on then.....













MX5.
What use is one of them to anyone interested in cars? He wants a car with an engine under the bonnet not a hopeless 4 pot! hehe