What car is the modern DS equivalent?
What car is the modern DS equivalent?
Author
Discussion

HertsBiker

Original Poster:

6,443 posts

302 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I love those old Citroën's, they have class and personality. What is there now that equals that, and will still look like science-fiction in ten, twenty, thirty years time?

M159V8

2,540 posts

177 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
First car that came to my head when I read the title was the Citroen C6, funnily enough, albeit it's not in production anymore smile

SpeckledJim

34,596 posts

284 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Nothing. We have converged on the mean. Just pick a colour and 24, 36, or 48 months.

Sir Fergie

795 posts

166 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I think weve hit on the reason why the french car manufacturers are hitting problems now.

Im not going to pretend that the old DS was perfect - but there is very little in the way of genuinely cool modern cars that break new ground.

As ive said previously - its all about 2.0 diesels, 18 inch alloys, sports suspension and a big marketing drive based on brand awareness and image.

So sadly the answer is none - apart from perhaps the C6 which is really a one off event never to be repeated.

Sir Fergie

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
The DS was an outstanding car perhaps the best since the Traction Avante Andre Citroen designed himself which was a truly outstanding trend setting innovative design. I regret to say Citroen/Peugeot have lost the art of making such cars. I suspect in ten years C/P cars will be history. Pity because few if any car companies can equal the innovation Citroen introduced.

BMC/Leyland/Austin/Rover managed to squander the lead and innovation that Issigonis gave them with the Mini. It would seem Citroen/Peugeot are following the same downward spiral.

AnotherClarkey

3,698 posts

220 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
I will get shot down in flames for this but I think the Prius is in with a shout. It follows its own path, is unique in powertrain terms with a wonderfully smooth transmission and wafts about in near silence if driven sympathetically. It is resolutely unsporty and has an unusual yet highly practical and roomy interior. Like the DS it has many engineering features that are unique to it but work perfectly well (and reliably too).

If the Prius had hydropneumatic suspension then it would be just about perfect as a means of wafty transport. I think is about time that 'luxury' was reclaimed to mean space, light, smoothness and comfort rather than crass 'opulence'.

ez64

248 posts

193 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Malaise era II?

G0ldfysh

3,318 posts

288 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
AnotherClarkey said:
I will get shot down in flames for this but I think the Prius is in with a shout. It follows its own path, is unique in powertrain terms with a wonderfully smooth transmission and wafts about in near silence if driven sympathetically. It is resolutely unsporty and has an unusual yet highly practical and roomy interior. Like the DS it has many engineering features that are unique to it but work perfectly well (and reliably too).

If the Prius had hydropneumatic suspension then it would be just about perfect as a means of wafty transport. I think is about time that 'luxury' was reclaimed to mean space, light, smoothness and comfort rather than crass 'opulence'.
If some of the styling had been for the sake of styling, not over styled or just following fashion you would have more drive with this argument.
Principle is a good one, but Toyota styling is rarely delivered with panache.

AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Steffan said:
I regret to say Citroen/Peugeot have lost the art of making such cars.
I'm not so sure. I think that actually customers have lost the art of buying them.

What people admire, and what they actually buy, are two very different things. Everyone raves about the C6, but Citroen sold barely a handful, and many of those were dealer demos. Very few people were brave enough to order a brand new one. The same applies to the Avantime and to a lesser extent the Vel Satis. These days, people buy cars as white goods, not as artworks.

Citroen could produce another DS if they wanted to. Look at the Metropolis concept (aka DS9). They could make that. But they know that they wouldn't sell enough to make it worthwhile. If nobody bought the C6, nobody will buy the Metropolis either.

At the same time, the cost of developing a new car has gone through the roof. BMW claim to have spent 1 billion euros on the new 7 series. This means that manufacturers have to play it safe. Whatever they produce, it simply has to sell. They can't piss that kind of money away on something that gets people talking but doesn't get them reaching into their pockets. That's what one-off concepts are for.

I think that if the cost of developing a new car can be brought down by an order of magnitude, we will start to see more exciting niche models including spiritual successors to the DS. Platform sharing has helped, but there is clearly more to do.

AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
AnotherClarkey said:
I will get shot down in flames for this but I think the Prius is in with a shout. It follows its own path, is unique in powertrain terms with a wonderfully smooth transmission and wafts about in near silence if driven sympathetically. It is resolutely unsporty and has an unusual yet highly practical and roomy interior. Like the DS it has many engineering features that are unique to it but work perfectly well (and reliably too).
I was going to suggest the Prius, but figured it might be too controversial. For me, the essence of the DS was that it took design risks, had highly innovative engineering and features, and wasn't afraid to follow its own path regardless of what others thought. It polarised opinion; it was the very opposite of "playing it safe". The closest equivalent today is the hybrids, and in particular the Prius.

Bohemianesque

254 posts

195 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
i think the Prius is a good call.

Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
AnotherClarkey said:
I will get shot down in flames for this but I think the Prius is in with a shout. It follows its own path, is unique in powertrain terms with a wonderfully smooth transmission and wafts about in near silence if driven sympathetically. It is resolutely unsporty and has an unusual yet highly practical and roomy interior. Like the DS it has many engineering features that are unique to it but work perfectly well (and reliably too).

If the Prius had hydropneumatic suspension then it would be just about perfect as a means of wafty transport. I think is about time that 'luxury' was reclaimed to mean space, light, smoothness and comfort rather than crass 'opulence'.
You have just hit on exactly what my Prius is lacking without me realising it.

I'd love a DS but, as you say, a few modifications to the Prius and it's the a very good modern comparison.

W00DY

16,796 posts

257 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Why worry about a modern equivalent, you can still buy a DS.



Otherwise Fisker Karma. Perhaps.

Grenoble

60,030 posts

186 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Will be pricey, but VW XL1?

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Wednesday 17th April 2013
quotequote all
Nothing. There used to be loads of interesting cars - Citroens, Saabs, etc. bit now everything is a carbon copy of the same template frown

Kolbenkopp

2,345 posts

182 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Don't think there is anything around that even comes close sadly.

Perhaps the upcoming BMW i3 or that big new Tesla could qualify? But both aren't really standard production cars as the DS was. That XL VW marketing exercise even less so... And all of these are really only focused on powertrain and perhaps (interior) styling, the rest isn't groundbreaking by any means...

I think development costs as others have mentioned are a key problem. And anything straying from the norm a bit (Audi A2, Honda Insight mk1, Avantime, C6, ...) did not sell at all. Combine risk averse manufacturers and risk averse buyers and what you get is VAG/Toyota-style blandness on the market.

Finally I think cars have reached a level of optimisation that anything currently available basically is acceptable to 95% of the buying crowd. Realistically, current Fiestas, Clios or Golfs do most things the DS set out to do much, much better.

What is left driving the market is Image/Status/Fashion. No wonder really that the SUV is the last real "innovation" the market embraced. The cars are st or at least worse than they could be if they where built for purpose. But that is outweighed by the fashion appeal.

clockworks

7,814 posts

176 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Porsche Panamera?

LuS1fer

43,567 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
It would have to be a car that offered a fetherbed ride on advanced suspension, it would have to look stunning and be affordable. Nothing qualifies. the C6 was halfway there but still looks like a Citresque Peugeot.

excel monkey

4,825 posts

258 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
It would have to be a car that offered a fetherbed ride on advanced suspension, it would have to look stunning and be affordable.
Based on those criteria, what about a Jag XF or XJ? (apart from the affordable bit - although the DS was never cheap).


Edited by excel monkey on Thursday 18th April 09:04

LuS1fer

43,567 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
excel monkey said:
LuS1fer said:
It would have to be a car that offered a fetherbed ride on advanced suspension, it would have to look stunning and be affordable.
Based on those criteria, what about a Jag XF or XJ? (apart from the affordable bit - although the DS was never cheap).


Edited by excel monkey on Thursday 18th April 09:04
I was behind an XJ on the way to work this morning. I used to think it worked but it really doesn't, at least not in silver.
The XF is also a bit mundane in the styling stakes but it's still a premium marque where the Citroen wasn't (I exclude the SM as that came from the purchase of Maserati).
If the Skoda Superb was a stunner, it might qualify given it seems geared for comfort rather than handling? (Never been in one).

I'm half-tempted to suggest an Evoque if that has self-levelling on it?