£4-5k commuter? - 20k plus per year
£4-5k commuter? - 20k plus per year
Author
Discussion

pstruck

Original Poster:

3,549 posts

280 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
I have searched and read a few similar theads, but here's my version of a what car with my own criteria....

I'm currently clocking up circa 500 miles per week commuting and am looking for a comfy, reliable and economical car, which can also provide some smiles when called upon in which to soak up the miles. The current ageing 1.6 Zetec Focus is getting rather long in the tooth and I fear its race is nearly run.

My journey is generally 12 miles twisty rural A-road, followed by 35 miles of fairly quiet motorway in the morning. The homeward trip is either the reverse, or when I fancy a change a short hop on the slab followed by 30 something miles of twisty rural B-roads (hence the need for some smiles).

So, with a maximum of £5k and for 50mpg with a bit of fun are we still talking Fabia vRS or similar, or would anyone like to throw in some left field options?

pstruck

Original Poster:

3,549 posts

280 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm overwhelmed by the response. hehe Should have known better really. It's hardy an inspiring high octane topic to stir the petrol in the veins.

getmecoat

iamrcb

607 posts

227 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Mk1 Fabia VRS, 50mpg easy.

dapearson

4,456 posts

255 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Standard answer would be octavia/a4/a6/passat 1.9 TDI.

How about spending a bit less and getting something more interesting?

e.g. a civic type r - only 30 mpg so about £100 per week in fuel rather than £60 (@ 50mpg), but £3k-4k should get a good one. Might not be the most relaxing commuter on motorway, but more interesting.

A £5k diesel commuter still has some depreciating to do, so factor that in too. You could get something more interesting that won't lose as much money, so offsetting the extra fuel.

I have the same distance commute, so have chosen to go by motorbike (circa 50mpg but mostly fun and v little depreciation), and i have a car as a backup - currently a shed in the form of an avensis 2.0 petrol, but being replaced by an impreza this weekend (30mpg but might actually increase in value).

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
5 miles of A road and 25 miles of motorway for me, and I went for:



If it had to be a car, I'd probably just choose something comfortable and rep style - diesel Passat etc. Commuting is normally just something you'd like to get over and done with in comfort, no?

pstruck

Original Poster:

3,549 posts

280 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
N Dentressangle said:
Commuting is normally just something you'd like to get over and done with in comfort, no?
Mostly agree with the statement above, but I actually quite enjoy the drive home when I go the 'non-motorway' route, as it involves some nice interesting roads and lets me indulge in a more 'enjoyable' driving style. Hence the need for something which is capable of raising a smile.

Bike isn't an option for me.

When I say £5k, that is what I'm willing to spend up to. More than happy with something half that price if it ticks all the boxes.

thismonkeyhere

11,853 posts

262 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Toyota Avensis 2.2 D4-D diesel.

...is my daily commute.

My journey is not dissimilar to yours - carefully driven you should be able to achieve 50-55 mpg easily.

Reliable, comfortable, cheap to insure. Ok, not massively exciting, but it handles well and the 2.2 does have a bit of 'poke'. It's chain cam also.

BE57 TOY

2,628 posts

178 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Seat Leon FR 2.0TDI

pstruck

Original Poster:

3,549 posts

280 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok, so a possible change of heart having given this some more thought and realised that I do put some value on driving pleasure. I think I am coming round to the idea that diesel may not be the way to go.

So, exploring the options what can I buy that is fairly quick and nimble, yet relatively comfortable (ie not too raw) for sitting on the motorway, or hooning around country A and B roads, yet will return 35+ mpg? I know some will be saying Clio 172/182, but I’m not sure I could live with the build quality and paranoia. I’m not really into screaming revs, so am not sure a Civic Type R is for me either. A Cooper S (well, on my budget the SC R53) by the sounds of it likes a drink, plus I find the MINI styling a bit ‘feminine’.

Have I ruled out the best options? I’m beginning to think I should have kept my Leon Cupra I sold 2 years ago!

clockworks

7,818 posts

176 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Suzuki Swift Sport?

KTF

10,735 posts

181 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Toledo TDi.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
pstruck said:
Ok, so a possible change of heart having given this some more thought and realised that I do put some value on driving pleasure. I think I am coming round to the idea that diesel may not be the way to go.

So, exploring the options what can I buy that is fairly quick and nimble, yet relatively comfortable (ie not too raw) for sitting on the motorway, or hooning around country A and B roads, yet will return 35+ mpg? I know some will be saying Clio 172/182, but I’m not sure I could live with the build quality and paranoia. I’m not really into screaming revs, so am not sure a Civic Type R is for me either. A Cooper S (well, on my budget the SC R53) by the sounds of it likes a drink, plus I find the MINI styling a bit ‘feminine’.

Have I ruled out the best options? I’m beginning to think I should have kept my Leon Cupra I sold 2 years ago!
In my experience all the Mini range are considerably thirstier than you would think - the aerodynamics really hurts it on the motorway.

It's not usually something I'd suggest, but what about a 1.8T A3/A4? Quite a good engine but a good compromise between noisy and comfy.

CampDavid

9,145 posts

229 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
iamrcb said:
Mk1 Fabia VRS, 50mpg easy.
According to the lying we of a trip computer. Realistically, the two we've had have over-read 10% on the economy

Still, awesome thing. Not the sharpest tool in the world but big shove on country lanes and fine on the motorway. My parents have had two now in nearly 10 years, they looked at sacking it off earlier this year but couldn't find anything sub £22k that appealed so it's staying until it's dead (circa 2025)

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm not convinced I'd want an old Fabia to do 20k plus miles a year in, and you don't really get much for your money either.

Think what you buy depends how much you value 'fun' over comfort. The best all rounder will probably be a 2.0 diesel Golf/ A3/ 1-series of some sort. Could possibly squeeze into a MK5 Golf GTI for that money but it would be high miles.

nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
I bought one new, and remapped it.
I travelled a 700 mile round trip every weekend for 2 1/2 years.
Fabia is a great car. Interior cheap, but very comfy.
Even better with Angel tuning having a tweek biggrin

pstruck

Original Poster:

3,549 posts

280 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I figure I need to go and drive some of the options and give some more serious thought to what is most important to me.

Whichever I go for I'll be sat in it for two hours per day, so comfort is a factor, but also I'd hate to end up with something which bores me to tears. As I said before, I actually enjoy the drive home and wish to continue to do so, even if it does cost me a bit extra in fuel.

It is a difficult balance. Diesel would give me cheaper fuel bills, but I would lose some of the fun (subjective I know) and for my budget I'd end up with an older, higher mileage car. A petrol car for my budget would probably be newer with less miles on the clock, but higher fuel bills and possibly greater depreciation. Having said that, the newer the better I guess, as newer petrol engines are certainly more efficient with significantly improved mpg over something older.

MrDecadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
BE57 TOY said:
Seat Leon FR 2.0TDI
Seconded wink

Suspension is a bit hard but fine for motorway work

Splendidmac

34 posts

192 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I had a similar dilemma (but with more motorway miles) and ended up with a W126-series Merc 300SE running on LPG. Similar running costs to a friend's Golf 2.0D auto. Cost me £1.5k for the car and £1k for the conversion, and have covered 55k motorway miles in it with no (serious) problems. Very comfortable place to spend time and certainly different!

excel monkey

4,826 posts

258 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Predictable PH choice, but how about a 3-series BMW? Either a nice late E46, or a leggy early E90 model.

The six cylinder cars won't manage 35mpg, but will get close if you take it steady on the motorway.

MagicalTrevor

6,481 posts

260 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I've got a similar problem and have exactly the same car (1.6 Focus Zetec). My budget is a little different though.

I was previously looking the the Volvo S60 D5 SE for it's comfort and >40mpg economy but I suspect it wouldn't be much fun on the twisties that you mention. If it's just a plod up and down the motorway then nothing much can touch it for comfort and the price. <£4k should get you a nice one.

Otherwise, it's the 1.9TDI VAG cars like what have been recommended already