Being done over by an independent mechanic...?
Being done over by an independent mechanic...?
Author
Discussion

Jazzy Jefferson

Original Poster:

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi all

Sorry if this is in the wrong section. I would appreciate any advice... :-)

My Girlfriends car has been off the road for a week. The MOT expired, and its an MOT fail due to the EML being on. So in her hast, she took her car to an independent "work from home" type garage. In short, she needed a new catalyst, and Toyota wanted £700. Of course, weld on a sports cat and its done for £200-300. Job sorted.

So the car was dropped off on Monday, and its now "ready for collection"

Here is the list of work she is being charged £120.00 for:

MOT
Filled tyres
put £10 of fuel in
Cleaned the lights (lights were fine before?)
Cleaning brake discs (Car had been sat outside for a few days, a quick run round the block should sort that)

Now, I am told, the CAT has not been replaced, yet somehow, it now has an MOT. So I assume its a dodgy MOT.

Would I be fair in asking the "mechanic" to politely do one. We did not ask for any of this to be done. We asked for a new CAT and an MOT.



h0b0

9,103 posts

227 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Drive the crap out of it and take it for another MOT at a place that only does MOTs. Then you will know.

Jazzy Jefferson

Original Poster:

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
h0b0 said:
Drive the crap out of it and take it for another MOT at a place that only does MOTs. Then you will know.
That's been done. We originally got the work quoted with another, reputable garage. I do not know why she did not go back to the same garage. There wouldn't have been an issue.
She does what she does....

Jazzy Jefferson

Original Poster:

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
The Crack Fox said:
So, it was going to cost you £700 to get an MOT cert, you've got one for £120, and you're unhappy ? If you suspect he has cut corners (disabling the EML light for example) then take it somewhere else for a second opinion, but £120 seems fair to me; £50 for an MOT, £10 for fuel, two hours faff at £30 an hour = £120.
We already know the faults. I guess this "independent" is in fact the 2nd opinion.
I see what you are saying. But we were quite happy to pay and fix the car.

£700 is the price of a replacement CAT direct from Toyota. £200-300 gets us a sports cat which should sort it out. Thats the part price. No labour on that.

The car was taken to this guy, and he was told: "Replace the CAT, and send it for an MOT" No faffing around with the lights or tyres, no need to put fuel in thanks, we can do that. No need to clean the disks, I have brake cleaner if needed. No additional work was discussed, hes just taken it on himself.

We are happy to pay for the MOT. we asked for that, fair and square. But the extra "work" that he decided to do himself.... not so sure.

Edited by Jazzy Jefferson on Thursday 18th April 16:30


Edited by Jazzy Jefferson on Thursday 18th April 16:30


Edited by Jazzy Jefferson on Thursday 18th April 16:32

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
The Crack Fox said:
So, it was going to cost you £700 to get an MOT cert, you've got one for £120, and you're unhappy ? If you suspect he has cut corners (disabling the EML light for example) then take it somewhere else for a second opinion, but £120 seems fair to me; £50 for an MOT, £10 for fuel, two hours faff at £30 an hour = £120.
Seriously, that's your logic?!

For a start, it was going to cost £300 to get an MOT with a replaced catalytic converter. And now the price is £120 for a suspect MOT and not having a new cat? And that's a good result? Forget it, that mechanic appears to have carried out a load of unauthorised/unnecessary/bullst work for an inflated price because he saw her coming a mile away.

The car still needs a new cat.. I wonder how that magically got better and the EML went out? Must be a very reputable guy, this scratchchin

Jazzy Jefferson

Original Poster:

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
McSam said:
eriously, that's your logic?!

For a start, it was going to cost £300 to get an MOT with a replaced catalytic converter. And now the price is £120 for a suspect MOT and not having a new cat? And that's a good result? Forget it, that mechanic appears to have carried out a load of unauthorised/unnecessary/bullst work for an inflated price because he saw her coming a mile away.

The car still needs a new cat.. I wonder how that magically got better and the EML went out? Must be a very reputable guy, this scratchchin
Nail on the head mate. She just told me that "this guy said it passed with no problems" So Im now pretty sure he's reset the light and go his mate to pass it, no matter what.
To be honest, I dont mind paying for an MOT. We asked... and we got. I would just rather get the work done and get it through properly.

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
EML on isn't a fail and they can often be easily turned off with a code reader.

Rick101

7,191 posts

181 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Can I get the guys number? Sounds great!

andymc

7,627 posts

238 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
mate, you're wanting you cake and to eat it, take it to toyota and get them to do it

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
It sounds like you should just have sorted it yourself.

ar 145

275 posts

227 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
How do you know it needed a new cat though?

Mr Mobile mechanic could have plugged it into a diagnostic machine and sorted it? no?

gog440

9,298 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
jagracer said:
EML on isn't a fail and they can often be easily turned off with a code reader.
^^^this

It may have been a random one off fault that he has cleared electronically, it has then passed the test.
It isnt worth an MOT testers licence to do a moody MOT, they are really cracking down on testers these days.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
jagracer said:
EML on isn't a fail and they can often be easily turned off with a code reader.
Actually, it is as of last month. If the fault isn't persistent then you could clear the code and the light wouldn't return, but then, that really isn't what the OP asked the mechanic for either.

Limpet

6,629 posts

192 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Or instead of ripping you off, it could be that he reset the fault codes (the first stage in any diagnostic process, by the way) and no codes reappeared so he took it for a test and it passed. Is there a print-out of the emissions reading? VOSA are pretty hot on bent MOTs these days.

I had a car fail on emissions at a test centre I'd used a few times. Took it to a well established garage near to work who used to look after our company fleet, with the instruction to investigate the problem and let me know. Got a call an hour later to say they'd just done an emissions test which it had passed quite comfortably, and did I want them to complete the rest of the MOT while it was on the ramp? Of course I said yes, and got myself a certificate.


jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
gog440 said:
^^^this


It isnt worth an MOT testers licence to do a moody MOT, they are really cracking down on testers these days.
It isn't moody even if it was on, EML light on is not a fail.

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
McSam said:
ctually, it is as of last month.
Can you show me where? http://www.motinfo.gov.uk/htdocs/index.htm
http://www.dft.gov.uk/vosa/repository/SN%2001%2020...

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Hmmm. I seem to recall from the recent list of new failure items, the EML now features, because it's associated with emission control problems. Although I could be wrong.

I'm not sure how relevant that is to the mechanic ignoring his instructions, though, which is the main point of the thread!


ETA - Apparently that bulb is one of only a couple that don't cause a fail now.

Jazzy Jefferson

Original Poster:

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
ar 145 said:
How do you know it needed a new cat though?

Mr Mobile mechanic could have plugged it into a diagnostic machine and sorted it? no?
The engine light came on a while ago. We had it plugged into diagnostics with the garage we know and should have used. They reset it, and of course it came on again, so they looked into it further. At the time, we had an MOT, so due to lack of funds, we left it to sort when the MOT expires. and here we are.

Jazzy Jefferson

Original Poster:

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Can I just clarify:

The problem is that it was sent to this guy, and he was told to replace the CAT and MOT it. He has done the MOT. Happy to pay for that.

In addition, we have now been presented with a bill for further work that was not authorised.
Probably should have just said that to begin with... biggrin


cossy400

3,470 posts

215 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
I see your point.

But wait a while and see if the EML comes back on.

Or just get on with your life, you ve just said funds were tight.

Dodgy Joe has got you a ticket which im sure is only valid really for about 2 hours after the test, because you could take the car home and swap bits (for example if you had a straight thru pipe instead of a cat).

I suppose its more annoying knowing you ve possibly had your pants down.

I probably like many PHers only use the one garage, so am pretty confident in knowing hes not going to pull any stunts