Decisions Decisions: Merc C Class Coupe or Bmw Coupe
Decisions Decisions: Merc C Class Coupe or Bmw Coupe
Author
Discussion

scoobyj

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Thursday 18th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi All,

Iam searching for a car to replace our 2002 BMW 325i Msport AUTO saloon (looking to sell soon). The reason is because the 325 is doing 18mpg as the wife only drives it round town, and its doing my head in having to keep putting petrol in it. My Crossfire which is a 3.2 does more than that round town.

Anyway, ive narrowed the search between 2 cars really. But I dont know which to go for, so would like your advice please. My budget is £5.5k and looking for no older than a 2005 with less than 60k miles.

1. 2005 BMW 318ci Auto Msport.
2. 2005 Merc C-Class Coupe Auto. Either 1.8 petrol or 2.2 diesel.

Having owned a couple of BMW's in the past, they have always been very reliable and feels very solid. But im concerned about the MPG as the weight of these are quite heavy, so should I expect alot lower than the quoted 25mpg urban figure?

The Merc. Never owned one but always liked the look of them. It would have to be the evo spec. However, again im thinking about fuel consumption and reliability. Is the petrol better round town than the diesel? Is the Diesel noisy?

Has anyone had experience of the 2? If so, please can you give me some pointers?

Also, would you be put of with a 2006 car that has had 5 owners and has only one key if it has FSH and receipts etc? The reason I ask is cos I purchased a car a few years back with 1 key and within a week it was stolen of my drive, the police said its likely it was the previous owner or an associate who had the other key.

Sorry for the essay but just want some advise before jumping in buying a new car.

Many Thanks

Edited by scoobyj on Thursday 18th April 23:34

matthias73

2,901 posts

181 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Buy her a yaris.

Or better yet make her put petrol in it.


XplusYplusZ

252 posts

172 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Not exactly the same cars but..

I had to choose between the 320d coupe and the Merc C-Coupe Diesel as a company car.

I test drove both and was absolutely shocked at how awful the diesel Merc sounded. It looked nice, but that's probably because it was a fresh design. Having seen one yesterday, a year down the line, it's already starting to look a little dated in my opinion. I also found the quality in the cabin was better in the bmw - that's probably also personal opinion, but i prefer the way the indicators and stalks work on the bimmer than the merc too.

Mostly though, it was the tansit van sound coming from the engine bay which put me off the merc..

The petrol mercs sound much better. But then there are still the weird niggles like the parking brake and 1990s entertainment centre in the merc, and of course, the seating position..

So my vote's for the bimmer.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Unless you're doing over 12k a year, forget diesel - the engine isn't best suited for stop-start around town motoring, especially if it has a DPF which can easily clog up if not driven for a decent distance on a semi-regular basis.

If it's purely for town driving, then the suggestion above is the best - get something small, economical and petrol.

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
If it's the same engine that is in my SLK (diseasel 2.2 twin turbo) then it's chuffing marvelous. The power is OK (204bhp) but the torque is the best bit (500nM). And the C class coupes look really nice too.

scoobyj

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Many thanks for all your replies.

To be honest, Ive never owned a diesel because of it sounding like a bus but i wouldnt be driving it so wouldnt matter to me. I just wanted something more economically friendly.

Never owned a merc either, i was abit surprised to hear about the cabin quality isnt that good compared to the BM. However, im assuming against any other car its probably pretty good.

Anyone out there had both these cars and can comment about the rear space and MPG??

Many Thanks


Tobias Funke

248 posts

227 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
At the time I had my e46 coupe my dad drove a C Class Coupe and, in my opionion, there was no comparison, the e46 was better in almost every way. I hated the driving position in the Merc and the parking brake was just a pain in the ass.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
scoobyj said:
Many thanks for all your replies.

To be honest, Ive never owned a diesel because of it sounding like a bus but i wouldnt be driving it so wouldnt matter to me. I just wanted something more economically friendly.

Never owned a merc either, i was abit surprised to hear about the cabin quality isnt that good compared to the BM. However, im assuming against any other car its probably pretty good.

Anyone out there had both these cars and can comment about the rear space and MPG??

Many Thanks
What annual mileage are we talking about?

scoobyj

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Annual milage approx 6k.

Mouse1903

839 posts

184 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Think the BMW will be the better bet out of those two

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
BMW here too - I won't touch a diesel if I was only doing 6k a year - not enough savings to outweight the potential issues.

KTF

10,735 posts

181 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
The C-Class coupe isnt really a coupe, more of a hatchback with no rear wiper, poor rear visibility and was designed when MB took their eye off the quality ball.

The Evo also has a rock hard ride that pitches you around the cabin. At least blurs the view of cheap plastics you have to look at then you sit in the thing.

scoobyj

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks people much appreciated.

So the BM is the way to go by what you guys say, but what is the rear leg room like in the coupe and rough expected MPG round town on the 318??

Many thanks

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
At that mileage petrol is a no brainer.

Get her to drive both.

Assuming she's not a petrolhead and is happy pottering around in D get the engine that delivers the best MPG in the car she most likes the look/driving experience of.

Happy wife, happy wallet.

Just make sure she picks the Beemer smile

Edited by B17NNS on Friday 19th April 23:43

Toltec

7,179 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
How much better on fuel is the 318 going to be? If she gets 18mpg the traffic must be fairly bad so no big petrol car is going to be that good. Oddly enough that mpg is what my wife gets in her 325 auto too and I know she also averages 16mph...

In light traffic it will do 23mpg around town which is slightly better than the 21mpg claimed by BMW. The 2005 318 has a claimed urban mpg of just under 25 so at a guess it will do maybe 21mpg in the conditions that your wife drives in.

It is going to take a while to get £5.5K back at 3mpg saving...

Nothing like man maths to convince you to keep the straight six smile

Realistically you will need to get a small petrol with a dsg or similar.

Edited by Toltec on Saturday 20th April 00:25

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all

matc

4,738 posts

238 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Out of those 2 cars - the BMW every time!

I work for Mercedes!

scoobyj

Original Poster:

5 posts

163 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Thank you for your replies.

I love the Alfa GT, but the wife doesnt like the off centre number plate cos its not symetrical lol. She has now started to like the Astra Twintop which doesnt help.

I need to move fast cos its now getting to a stage that im getting bored of looking.

S8QUATTRO

944 posts

181 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I had a c220 cdi coupe auto 06 model, great car for the motorway 40+ mpg. Around town 20-25 mpg, hard ride, low profile tyres, difficult for anyone over 4ft to get in and out of the back. I think the 220 cdi engine seemed reliable whilst we had it, quite quick, very loud. Nice interior feel. They have odd keys, but some nice touches like the headlight stay on for a while when you lock the car. If you get one make sure you have decent tyres and some models have wider rears.

S8QUATTRO

944 posts

181 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
The Mercs also have common problems with the handbrake, easy diy fix to adjust it though. Little hatch under rear seat.