Genuine "what car" quandary
Genuine "what car" quandary
Author
Discussion

P1H

Original Poster:

433 posts

179 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm in a dilemma, can you help?

I'm going to be doing 20,000 miles this year. I have a Civic Type R which I have owned for a year. Whilst not the end of the world over the course of 20,000 miles the mpg and the comfort are probably unacceptable. The reason I know this is I some how managed to rack up circa 20k in the last year between trips to uni, holiday and work etc.

I'm at a loss what to do next. The options appear to be:

1. Keep the type R, spend a lot on fuel and watch my back disintegrate.

2. Stop crying about fuel but get a more compromised hot hatch which will offer more comfort on the motorway, I.e. GTI.

3. Spend a considerable amount of money on a car I don't really want such as a 320d and watch it depreciate as the miles pile on.

4. Spend circa 5 - 6k on a comfortable diesel which will last a number of years and allow me to save toward an expensive car that I actually want in the future. (A E90 or 997) I had in mind a circa 2004 e class for example?

5. Get a diesel car that I'd actually want (330d), but the only way to achieve this and prioritise other things would be some sort of finance which I'm not particularly interested in.

Any input appreciated.

jamieclueless

3,701 posts

193 months

Friday 19th April 2013
quotequote all
swap your type r for a type s 2.2 diesel. Just as fast for everyday driving but softer suspension for more comfort and really good economy

P1H

Original Poster:

433 posts

179 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
jamieclueless said:
swap your type r for a type s 2.2 diesel. Just as fast for everyday driving but softer suspension for more comfort and really good economy
A good point and something to certainly consider, I'm not sure the FN shape is for me though.

NadiR

1,071 posts

178 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Get yourself a Fabia vRS 130. This way, you'll be able to keep relatively good performance, while getting good MPG and low running costs, compared to the Civic.

LostInScotland

16 posts

163 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Interesting thread - i'm in a similar predicament to the OP - considering a type-R but not sure I can live with the harsh ride and poor milage despite the reliability and performance.

Having recently driven a few cars to compare perhaps I can lend a few suggestions...

Audi S3? Just as fast and the type R but with 2 beautiful heater leather lazyboy recliners fitted... so very comfortable! Not sure milage is much better bit the ride sure will be. Jury is out on reliability though.

ST170? Comfy, fairly reliable from what I can gather, not slow - but not quick either.

330i Petrol - seems to be a very decent package for the money if you can find one in good nick.

Let us know what you decide on - oh and how much are you asking for your EP? I might be interested...

Rickyy

6,618 posts

250 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Are you in the position to run two cars? If so, get the best cheap Skoda Octavia SDI you can for the money and keep the Type-R as a plaything.

Lefty

21,607 posts

233 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
If you're going to have two cars: one diesel commuter and a plaything I'd suggest that your plaything should be faster/wilder/sillier than a civic? No offence intended but a toy should be just that wink

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Just keep it. 20000 miles isn't that far

tyranical

927 posts

221 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
jamieclueless said:
swap your type r for a type s 2.2 diesel. Just as fast for everyday driving but softer suspension for more comfort and really good economy
Brilliant idea if you like replacing clutches, they chew through them regardless of how they're driven (well documented on various Honda forums)

P1H

Original Poster:

433 posts

179 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Rickyy said:
Are you in the position to run two cars? If so, get the best cheap Skoda Octavia SDI you can for the money and keep the Type-R as a plaything.
I would love to do this in theory but as this is a cost cutting exercise i think it would be hard to justify insurance, tax and maintenance on two cars.

However, this is something I'll be doing in the future.


P1H

Original Poster:

433 posts

179 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
matt21 said:
Just keep it. 20000 miles isn't that far
You are right, it isn't. But there is something which doesn't sit right with me thinking not only could this be costing me a lot less BUT I could also be much more comfortable. Justifying both is hard.

I do a lot of sport and my back is healthy but I can feel those Type R seats starting to do something I don't like.

P1H

Original Poster:

433 posts

179 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Q
LostInScotland said:
Interesting thread - i'm in a similar predicament to the OP - considering a type-R but not sure I can live with the harsh ride and poor milage despite the reliability and performance.

Having recently driven a few cars to compare perhaps I can lend a few suggestions...

Audi S3? Just as fast and the type R but with 2 beautiful heater leather lazyboy recliners fitted... so very comfortable! Not sure milage is much better bit the ride sure will be. Jury is out on reliability though.

ST170? Comfy, fairly reliable from what I can gather, not slow - but not quick either.

330i Petrol - seems to be a very decent package for the money if you can find one in good nick.

Let us know what you decide on - oh and how much are you asking for your EP? I might be interested...
Thanks for the input, but I'm not sure those would fit he bill:

S3: circa 12k to buy, not good on petrol and would probably fall under point 3 of my initial post - a car I don't want to own and would probably be better saving up for something I really want. I take the comfort point though!

St 170: not the car for me, similar approach to the type r just slower with slightly better fuel economy.

330i: would cost more on petrol over 20k than the type R and I'd be going for a e46 which I'm not a huge fan of (aside from the m3 of course) I'm sure they are good to drive, but I'm confident any extra enjoyment wouldn't swing the balance.

I can't see an easy answer.

Edited by P1H on Saturday 20th April 11:14

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
NadiR said:
Get yourself a Fabia vRS 130. This way, you'll be able to keep relatively good performance, while getting good MPG and low running costs, compared to the Civic.
Gets my vote.

LostInScotland

16 posts

163 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
[redacted]

talksthetalk

10,821 posts

166 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
For 20k a year youre saying you need a car that you don't want.

I did 20k in my impreza in the first two years. And 28k a year in a corrola tsport.
See how you get on with what you have for say six months. The cost to change and depreciation on a newer car will be more than any extra fuel you're using for that period, and you'll see where a good compromise lies.?
Oh, did someone mention BMW123d?
Just a cheeky mention.



Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
If you are doing 20k a year, surely most of your driving will be on proper, open roads rather than crawling in city traffic? In which case the Type R can return very reasonable mileage if you don't thrash it. I do about 15k pa commuting to work, and average about 33mpg from my EP3 and that is driving it with almost no economy in mind, i.e. 85mph on dual carriageways and regularly overtaking stuff on B roads though I only have a few miles of town traffic and traffic lights to deal with. If I drive it for economy I can get over 36mpg without having to crawl along.