MK5 R32 to S2000?
Author
Discussion

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

206 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Morning all.
Maybe it's because I've hit 35 today or it could just be the blue sky that's decided to show up but I'm hankering, for the 4th time, to get a low mileage late S2000. Over the last 8 years I've been close to putting one on the list but have always ended up with a more practical car - CTR, MK2 Golf GTI, GTFour, STI, R32 and Forester.

I've had focused cars before and a few of those being rear wheel drive so I'm aware of the change in driving style and obvious comfort but it does still intrigue me a bit. I've also got the Forester XT for family lugging and more balls-out driving so there isn't really a need for another 4 door on the driveway. Previously I've done over 20k a year with work but now I'm pretty much on the train aside from a few long drives now and then.

I drove one many years ago and it did seem pretty good, if a little snug (I'm 6'0 and 83kg), and of course the engine is something very special. I don't know a great deal about the potential issues that come with them or any recalls so I'm hoping some of the current owners will chime in with some thoughts just to give more of an owners perspective.

I've pondered a Chim and a Boxster too but the upkeep of the Chim discounted that along with the potential bills of an older Boxster.

Thoughts, comments and warnings welcome.


David

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Do it. You're a long time dead.

I've just done the same (albeit with a Chim).

I figured if I didn't do it soon (I‘m 42), I'll probably never do it. Good luck.

PTE993

126 posts

246 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Did the same last month. biglaugh I changed a practical, earnest and economical diesel Alfa 159 estate for an S2000 GT. I had the Alfa for a year. Lovely car to look at but dull to drive. And for 90% of the time it is just me in the car.

The S2000 is perfect for the 60-80 mile round trip when I do have to go into the office (over A,B roads and MW's). It isn't the quietest motorway cruiser (sits at around 4K RPM). But if that's what you're after then get a different car. Driving in commute traffic it is perfectly civilised but then when you get a chance letting go and getting it up to 9000 is totally addictive.

Insurance isn't horrific either. £300 p.a. (in 40's, 9yrs NCD).

Considered the same list of options, Boxster etc.. and settled on the Honda specifically because I wanted to try the engine, they are cheap to buy and it has relatively inexpensive running costs. There's lots of info on them on the S2Ki forum.

My 11 year old daughter loves it! And it is her car of choice at the weekends.





krunchkin

2,209 posts

172 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I've had one for a year now and scoured all the internet forums before buying one. The amount of gripes and worries is tiny considering its a car designed to be hammered to fk to get the best out of it.

CONS

Rumours of SOME late year models engines being dodgy
Bushes seize if not checked
OEM stereo is st
High tax after 06 (mine costs 480 a year )
Needs to be set up right by someone who knows what they're doing to get a really good feel
Tendency to end up in a hedge if you dont know what you're doing (esp early models without VSA) so insurance reflects it
Paint quality is st and likes chips more than a fat scouser

PROS
Revs to 9000rpm and you're supposed to use it
Incredibly reliable, despite internet scare stories
Dashboard looks like you're playing Gran Turismo
Goes like stink
Roof comes down
Makes you laugh every time you drive it, especially when you drop into 3rd and give it the full 9k to the limiter
Feels incredibly tight and sharp when you have it set right on good tyres
Most people who still have one tend to have looked after it, despite it being pretty bulletproof anyway

Edited to add - some other notes after a year with it

- it doesn't like the cold - the roof hasn't got a malfunction when it doesn't retract fully - its just cold - leave it to warm for 5 mins before you drop it, and likewise the whole car - don't even think about pushing the engine or tyres or gearbox until you have had it out for 20 mins and given it time to warm its bones - it becomes a different car. Gears very notchy from cold but soon transform into lovely slick shift

-get the Geo done every 6 months - makes a massive difference, and oil change every 6 months to quality fully synth

- putting Stoptech discs and pads on mine made a really noticeable difference. Hugely imporved braking confidence

- if you're buying one and the tyres are a bit mismatched or out of synch on wear fit a fresh new set - huge difference in feel



Edited by krunchkin on Saturday 20th April 13:13


Edited by krunchkin on Saturday 20th April 14:00

LukeR94

2,218 posts

172 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Terrific post Krunchkin.

That should be a how to treat your pride and joy right to-do-list, and should be a must for anyone that wants to buy and look after a performance car.

obviously minus the S2K specific things, like the roof laugh


krunchkin

2,209 posts

172 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
It's the first 'performance' car I've owned and I think the most striking thing is that sense of it needing to be warmed up and ready to be used. I jump in my work car everyday, turn the key, and go - and off it trundles in its mundane, motorway munching blandness. With the S2K you really feel it from the car that it wants to get itself nice and warm and heated up before its going to deliver amazing grip and performance. First time I've sensed 'character' in a vehicle.

TameRacingDriver

20,662 posts

303 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
LukeR94 said:
Terrific post Krunchkin.

That should be a how to treat your pride and joy right to-do-list, and should be a must for anyone that wants to buy and look after a performance car.

obviously minus the S2K specific things, like the roof laugh
My 350Z roof is the same when its cold, doesn't retract fully. I thought it was a 350Z Convertible thing. Obviously not...

bracken78

996 posts

237 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
You only live once and even if you hate it, at least you tried!

I have had two and wish I still had one now but it was not practical with the addition to the family seeing as we only need one car and saving to move house. It was cheap with the only main cost being the insurance which can be steep.

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

206 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Great reponses, thanks all. Much room for thought over a beer today. Part of me wants another Impreza but we've pretty much got that with the Forester so perhaps it's time to get something a little different.

The owners of the S2000 OC lives around the local area (he hit me up the backside a few years ago in my old 4motion!) so I may have to drop him a note for some advice.

Cheers all,



David

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm tempted to get rid of the 335d for one and get a Focus or similar for practical times.

krunchkin

2,209 posts

172 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Ved - if you're after a cheap, sub 10k bit of hassle free, balls out, top down, mad revving, 2 seater fun you can't really go wrong. If you bear in mind the few small issues they may or may not have, use a bit of common sense, and buy one from someone who's obviously given it some love you're going to struggle to buy one that's even close to a shed. Just do it.

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

206 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all

JFReturns

3,834 posts

202 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Ved said:
Your R32 is gorgeous! Nice advert.

The S2000 will be a step down in terms of interior appeal, ride quality etc but will be more fun. And just as fast once you wind it up! Unless the roads are wet, in which case take it easy...

roadman

492 posts

169 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
ill say it...Happy Birthday wink

and yes as said above get the S2000

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

206 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
JFReturns said:
Ved said:
Your R32 is gorgeous! Nice advert.

The S2000 will be a step down in terms of interior appeal, ride quality etc but will be more fun. And just as fast once you wind it up! Unless the roads are wet, in which case take it easy...
...in which case, take the Forester wink

JFReturns

3,834 posts

202 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Ved said:
JFReturns said:
Ved said:
Your R32 is gorgeous! Nice advert.

The S2000 will be a step down in terms of interior appeal, ride quality etc but will be more fun. And just as fast once you wind it up! Unless the roads are wet, in which case take it easy...
...in which case, take the Forester wink
I always thought my MX5 and Impreza would be the perfect (realistic) two car combo. S2000 and Forester is right up there too!

Dominicc01

530 posts

198 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Definitely get one! They're utterly unique, and tremendous fun.

The interiors are snug for everyone - from little Japanese fellows to big westerners. But I've had very few passengers who either can't get in or are uncomfortable. I'm 6"2 and around 100kg, and it's fine for me.

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
Get the Boxster or Chim, you only live once..though an S2000 will also be pretty good fun too..

GBSGR5

33 posts

219 months

Saturday 20th April 2013
quotequote all
I've got a Forester and S2 Lotus Elise. The Elise is maybe a more hardcore option than the S2000, but might be worth considering. It also has less potential for big bills than a Boxster or a Chimera (IMO).

The OP's R32 looks very nice. If I was to move to one car then a 5 door R32 would be high up on the list.