Tedious What Car - 7 seat shed + low costs = pipe dream?
Discussion
Firstly, apologies for the deeply boring nature of this what car. I promise at some point in the future I'll do one about choosing between an LS3-powered 2CV and a quad-turbo Hayabusa Imp or some such to make up for it.
Due to a pretty sh-one-tty change in personal circumstances I'm left with very little money, a small and disintegrating station hack (53 plate Daihatsu Charade) for transport, and a need to occasionally carry 3-4 adults + 2 children in car seats + a folded wheelchair behind seats. Most of the time the prospective new car will be 1 or 2 up, mostly pottering but with some 150+ mile motorway runs every couple of weeks. The following are what have occurred so far for a budget of circa £2,000:
03-09 Renault Grand Scenic
For: Comfy, nice place to be when everything working
V good economy in diesel form
Excellent safety
Decent local Renault-specialising independent garage
Against: Truly horrific reputation for fragility, diesel hara-kiri, electrical Armageddon, chunky repair costs
Pre-facelift Fiat Multipla
For: Like the 6-seat arrangement, airy cabin/sunroofs for the nippers in ELX spec
Strange hair-shirt fascination with driving the fugliest thing on the road
Reasonably bomb-proof mechanicals
Apparently rather chuckable, in petrol form at least
Against: Italian electrics, trim fragility
Prone to breaking coil springs at inconvenient moments
Citroen C8/Peugeot 806/Fiat Ulysse
For: Lot of car for the money
Enormo-space + sliding doors
Reasonable economy in HDi/JTD form
Against: Probably too much car for the job in hand
Electrical borkage potential
High repair costs
Something Japanese and older
Toyota Picnic, Mazda MPV, Honda Shuttle (don't like seating arrangements in the Stream), Mazda Premacy if can find a 7-seater...
Any helpful thoughts/experiences from the PH massive? Ta in advance.
Due to a pretty sh-one-tty change in personal circumstances I'm left with very little money, a small and disintegrating station hack (53 plate Daihatsu Charade) for transport, and a need to occasionally carry 3-4 adults + 2 children in car seats + a folded wheelchair behind seats. Most of the time the prospective new car will be 1 or 2 up, mostly pottering but with some 150+ mile motorway runs every couple of weeks. The following are what have occurred so far for a budget of circa £2,000:
03-09 Renault Grand Scenic
For: Comfy, nice place to be when everything working
V good economy in diesel form
Excellent safety
Decent local Renault-specialising independent garage
Against: Truly horrific reputation for fragility, diesel hara-kiri, electrical Armageddon, chunky repair costs
Pre-facelift Fiat Multipla
For: Like the 6-seat arrangement, airy cabin/sunroofs for the nippers in ELX spec
Strange hair-shirt fascination with driving the fugliest thing on the road
Reasonably bomb-proof mechanicals
Apparently rather chuckable, in petrol form at least
Against: Italian electrics, trim fragility
Prone to breaking coil springs at inconvenient moments
Citroen C8/Peugeot 806/Fiat Ulysse
For: Lot of car for the money
Enormo-space + sliding doors
Reasonable economy in HDi/JTD form
Against: Probably too much car for the job in hand
Electrical borkage potential
High repair costs
Something Japanese and older
Toyota Picnic, Mazda MPV, Honda Shuttle (don't like seating arrangements in the Stream), Mazda Premacy if can find a 7-seater...
Any helpful thoughts/experiences from the PH massive? Ta in advance.
I ran a pre facelift multipla for 5 years and 57k miles then sold it to my mates dad, he ran it for another 5 years plus. In that time it had the front coil springs replaced under a recall,a crank sensor,a handbrake cable and a new connector on the wire from the battery to the starter after it broke (AA did a temp fix by crimping a connector on that was still there when the car was cubed) and a clutch slave cylinder replaced apart from routine servicing.
Loads of room in it, still got a decent boot even when full of passengers, Mine was a jtd elx.And the trim didnt break, it got grubby but was pretty solid, only thing that broke was the cable to allow the middle front seat to fold down to be used as a table.
And the ride/handling are excellent for this sort of car.
One thing to be careful of is what killed mine in the end, the rear beam has an aluminium bush pressed into the steel. When the bush gave up it was impossible to remove from the beam and a new beam was more than the car was worth!
Loads of room in it, still got a decent boot even when full of passengers, Mine was a jtd elx.And the trim didnt break, it got grubby but was pretty solid, only thing that broke was the cable to allow the middle front seat to fold down to be used as a table.
And the ride/handling are excellent for this sort of car.
One thing to be careful of is what killed mine in the end, the rear beam has an aluminium bush pressed into the steel. When the bush gave up it was impossible to remove from the beam and a new beam was more than the car was worth!
Edited by gog440 on Monday 22 April 12:54
Risotto said:
No idea of price or reputation but what about one of those old Chrysler Grand Voyagers - surely you could fit all that you need in one of those.
Not usually a high priority on PH, but have you seen the safety ratings of the Voyager? Horrendous deathtraps.I would probably go for something Japanese, although I do like the Multipla.
Edited by Krikkit on Monday 22 April 13:02
My MIL is trying to get rid of her mk1 Previa (she doesn't live here much anymore as she's in Switzerland most of the time and has an Auris for when she is here) but for the time she has had it (almost a decade) it has never gone wrong. Very reliable and highly recommended. May be a little bit juicy on petrol, mind.
Risotto said:
No idea of price or reputation but what about one of those old Chrysler Grand Voyagers - surely you could fit all that you need in one of those.
My Dad owned one of those for a few years and it was an excellent car, no problems at all.However it was the 3.3 Petrol which was expensive to run
Sadly a Honda FR-V sits out of your budget, the Fiat Multipla is the most interesting option IMO.
I know someone who owned a Fiat Ulysee and spoke highly of it, but the cambelt's just gone on it - if you get one be cautious with the cambelt, the recommended intervals are over optimistic.
The sensible money's on a 1.9TDI Alhambra/Sharan/Galaxy with a good service history.
I know someone who owned a Fiat Ulysee and spoke highly of it, but the cambelt's just gone on it - if you get one be cautious with the cambelt, the recommended intervals are over optimistic.
The sensible money's on a 1.9TDI Alhambra/Sharan/Galaxy with a good service history.
How about a Zafira.
I know, I know but they are dirt cheap, there are loads about and I have friends who have run them to high mileage with minimal problems.
Personally with your low-ish mileage I would go for the 1.8 petrol. Its no ball of fire but its a good compromise between power and economy. We used to have these as hire cars and they are miles better than the 1.6.
I know, I know but they are dirt cheap, there are loads about and I have friends who have run them to high mileage with minimal problems.
Personally with your low-ish mileage I would go for the 1.8 petrol. Its no ball of fire but its a good compromise between power and economy. We used to have these as hire cars and they are miles better than the 1.6.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


