Can a diesel ever match a petrol at very high speeds?
Can a diesel ever match a petrol at very high speeds?
Author
Discussion

rpm2013

Original Poster:

3 posts

163 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I drive quite a bit on motorways, and often at high speeds when the motorways are clear.

I'm looking to replace my old 6-series BMW 630i, which performed pretty well at high speed. The crucial acceleration range for me is from 70-120 mph, e.g. when you are driving at say 110mph, have to slow down because of small queue or a slow driver in the outside lane, and want to speed back up again once you have passed them.

Now, one car I am looking at is the Mercedes E350 CDI. It has a power output listed of 265 bhp. This is very similar to my old BMW. Is this the key figure to be looking at, or will the diesel always struggle with acceleration at higher speeds regardless of power output in bhp?

Almost everyone who has a 350 goes for the diesel. Am I going to notice the difference in performance at 100-130 mph between my 630i and this Mercedes E350 cdi? Will the engine have to work harder to go beyond 110mph?

The main reason for opting for the diesel is fuel economy for when I'm driving around town in traffic or when I'm on the motorway at busy times only doing 50-70 mph. Should I be reassured by the power output, or will I be disappointed by the lower revs of the diesel - will this seriously affect performance at high speed?

trickywoo

14,283 posts

261 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all

schmalex

13,616 posts

237 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Torque is your friend, fella.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
If you really care about acceleration above 100 mph, you need something with a lot more power than your 630i.


And you need to move to Germany.

Bohally

943 posts

178 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
How often do you realistically need to go 110-130 in the UK?

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Yes diesel can match petrol at high speed. Because of gearboxes.

HarryFlatters

4,203 posts

243 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
hairykrishna said:
Yes diesel can match petrol at high speed. Because of gearboxes.
hehe

rpm2013

Original Poster:

3 posts

163 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Well I was happy enough with the performance of my 630i at high-speeds. You could drop it into 4th at 80 mph and be up to 100mph+ in no time. I could now get a car with similar petrol engine but I am conscious of running costs.

But the question I was really trying to get at - will the 350 cdi match the 630i in terms of acceleration at 100mph plus because of the listed power output being similar?

In terms of torque, the e350 cdi has huge torque figures, but these are at lower revs. This seems typical of diesel cars, very strong acceleration in the 30-70 mph range. But what about at higher speeds?

To clarify, I often drive after 21:00 when the motorways are generally pretty clear, so there are quite a few opportunities to drive safely at higher-than-normal speeds.

ar 145

275 posts

227 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Please tell me where these roads are that you can drive at 120 mph on.

Geekman

2,908 posts

177 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
ar 145 said:
Please tell me where these roads are that you can drive at 120 mph on.
You can drive at 120MPH+ on most motorways at non peak times. Whether or not it's safe to do so is another matter, but plenty of people choose to.

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
rpm2013 said:
Well I was happy enough with the performance of my 630i at high-speeds. You could drop it into 4th at 80 mph and be up to 100mph+ in no time. I could now get a car with similar petrol engine but I am conscious of running costs.

But the question I was really trying to get at - will the 350 cdi match the 630i in terms of acceleration at 100mph plus because of the listed power output being similar?

In terms of torque, the e350 cdi has huge torque figures, but these are at lower revs. This seems typical of diesel cars, very strong acceleration in the 30-70 mph range. But what about at higher speeds?

To clarify, I often drive after 21:00 when the motorways are generally pretty clear, so there are quite a few opportunities to drive safely at higher-than-normal speeds.
Assuming pound-feet and horsepower, Power = Torque x RPM/5252

Relative acceleration at high speed is going to be dependent on the gearing not on where in the rev range it makes peak torque.

J4CKO

47,107 posts

231 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
No, at over a 100, our 1.0 petrol Citroen C1 will edge away from a 335D, mapped or not

mjb1

2,585 posts

190 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Generally a diesel engine with a similar power output to a petrol one will have higher peak torque, but a narrower power band. So, in gear performance will feel faster, but there's likely to be more gear changes involved to keep it there. Whilst cruising the diesel will often be nicer due to turning lower revs.

LukeR94

2,218 posts

172 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
No, at over a 100, our 1.0 petrol Citroen C1 will edge away from a 335D, mapped or not
Pfft...

Mapped. Youve GOT to be joking.

Those things are M3 Beaters wink

Bezza1969

777 posts

179 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
rpm2013 said:
Well I was happy enough with the performance of my 630i at high-speeds. You could drop it into 4th at 80 mph and be up to 100mph+ in no time. I could now get a car with similar petrol engine but I am conscious of running costs.

But the question I was really trying to get at - will the 350 cdi match the 630i in terms of acceleration at 100mph plus because of the listed power output being similar?

In terms of torque, the e350 cdi has huge torque figures, but these are at lower revs. This seems typical of diesel cars, very strong acceleration in the 30-70 mph range. But what about at higher speeds?

To clarify, I often drive after 21:00 when the motorways are generally pretty clear, so there are quite a few opportunities to drive safely at higher-than-normal speeds.
To answer your question, the 2010 E350 CDI took 17 seconds to go from 100-130 MPH when tested by Autocar, but this was the pre 265 BHP version (and a saloon). The version with 265 BHP would be around 10% quicker I reckon. Dont have figures for a 630i, but the old 330i E46 coupe, which probably has a similar power to weight ratio to your more powerful but heavier 3 litre petrol, took 15.6 seconds to do 100-130 MPH in a road test by EVO magazine. In other words I dont think you will find any difference in roll on acceleration, the massive torque in the diesel making up for any deficit in outright power to weight ratio. These modern diesel execs really do shift, even at higher speeds!!

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Geekman said:
ar 145 said:
Please tell me where these roads are that you can drive at 120 mph on.
You can drive at 120MPH+ on most motorways at non peak times. Whether or not it's safe to do so is another matter, but plenty of people choose to.
Yes while they still have their driving licence.

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

173 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
No, at over a 100, our 1.0 petrol Citroen C1 will edge away from a 335D, mapped or not
is that like a 2CV flat out at 115 km/h could beat a Porsche doing 112 km/h wink

rpm2013

Original Poster:

3 posts

163 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Bezza1969 said:
To answer your question, the 2010 E350 CDI took 17 seconds to go from 100-130 MPH when tested by Autocar, but this was the pre 265 BHP version (and a saloon). The version with 265 BHP would be around 10% quicker I reckon. Dont have figures for a 630i, but the old 330i E46 coupe, which probably has a similar power to weight ratio to your more powerful but heavier 3 litre petrol, took 15.6 seconds to do 100-130 MPH in a road test by EVO magazine. In other words I dont think you will find any difference in roll on acceleration, the massive torque in the diesel making up for any deficit in outright power to weight ratio. These modern diesel execs really do shift, even at higher speeds!!
Thanks Bezza. Do you know any car review site which publishes acceleration figures for higher speeds? All of the main review websites seem only to quote 0-60, it would be useful to have figures for other speed ranges.

Geekman

2,908 posts

177 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
Yes while they still have their driving licence.
If you're reasonably observant and drive at night as the OP said he does, I'd imagine it's fairly difficult to get caught. I do quite a bit of motorway driving at night and I've never seen a single camera van or speed trap: you get the occasional unmarked police car but if you don't spot them following you then you deserve to lose your licence.

edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I have never been over 70mph in my 640d.

If I had, I am told they go quite well all the way upto (and past) the 155 limiter.