Keep car or get rid of it.
Keep car or get rid of it.
Author
Discussion

ashmashcash

Original Poster:

58 posts

163 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Hi guys, I am 19 and currently own a 56 plate renault clio campus 1.1 with just under 97,000 on the clock.

I want to get rid of it and upgrade to a more expensive car, but I also want a house and currently have 10k savings for it.

My brother got me the car, it came with mot but not service history. Mot had adviosorys such as anti roll/linkage ball has slight play.

No major issues with the car, other than sometimes moves to left? and mucky yellow crap inside underneath the oil cap and engine management light is on.

CAR ALSO OCCASIONALLY MAKES A GRINDING NOISE (COMING FROM UNDER THE CAR?, WHEN YOU BRAKE, AS IF SOME LONG POLE HAS MOVE FORWARD UNDER CARD AND RUBBING AGAINST IT???

with it being nearly 97,000 no service history, the following is probably needed.

Cambelt change
Timing belt replaced
Water pump replaced


Brake dics/pads
New tyres
Tracking rod fixed on the car.
Sort out engine management light

How much is likely to cost to do all of the above and is it worth doing? Car worth in current state?



Edited by ashmashcash on Tuesday 23 April 14:27


Edited by ashmashcash on Tuesday 23 April 14:33

DrDeAtH

3,706 posts

263 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Run it until it dies. Buy someting for 2k. Stick some money in a pot for maintaining it. Keep the rest for buying a house.



Or... Shave head, grow goatee, become powerfully built company director and drive a Remapped 335d. with an mx5 in the garage for the weekend...

TotalControl

8,307 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
You could probably do a majority of the work yourself with a bit if time and patience. So I'd say cost of parts.

Darren156

566 posts

223 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Have a mate wioth a Clio where the engine management lights pops up once or twice a month and goes into limp mode. They had it fixed. About 5 times. Still fecked. My advice? Get shot. Sounds like your head gasket is shot too with your dirty mayonaise filler cap, lol

Darren156

566 posts

223 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Is this a wind up? It sounds like the biggest pile of s**t going!!! You don't need to sell it, you need to incinerate it or fix it!!!

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Darren156 said:
Is this a wind up? It sounds like the biggest pile of s**t going!!! You don't need to sell it, you need to incinerate it or fix it!!!
Honestly, this is a six year old base model Clio that cost about as much as a pub lunch when it was new. These cars never get maintained...

Apart from a minor suspension issue, everything else is deferred maintenance and probably not much worse than the majority of comparable cars out there.

I wouldn't enjoy spending money and there is a good few hundred quid to spend but this is really as a result of saving all the maintenance up for one go, rather than because the car is fundamentally bad.

I doubt that you'd get back the money you spent if you did all that work as prep for sale, but if I intended keeping the car, I'd not complain about the amount of work needed. (I'd just make sure I knew a cheap and friendly mechanic).

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I certainly wouldn't throw any money at a 97k mile clio - it's worth pennies so just drive it till it dies or the MOT expires, sell for spares and buy something non french.

Well done on saving £10k at 19. I felt rich when I had a tenner in my pocket at that age!

ashmashcash

Original Poster:

58 posts

163 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
DrDeAtH said:
Run it until it dies. Buy someting for 2k. Stick some money in a pot for maintaining it. Keep the rest for buying a house.

Or... Shave head, grow goatee, become powerfully built company director and drive a Remapped 335d. with an mx5 in the garage for the weekend...
Hmm, I think it's pointless running it until it dies when I can probably sell it for upwards £1k?

With that 1k, i could then put another 1k, and buy something half decent?

I'd only get the 355d sport, standard version is balls. Mx5, i'd rather be a bus ********!

TotalControl said:
You could probably do a majority of the work yourself with a bit if time and patience. So I'd say cost of parts.
I actually love cars but I don't have the tools to do the above jobs, tools will cost 500 quid upwards? I might even be crap at it, even with instructions and end up destroying the car!

quote=Darren156]Have a mate wioth a Clio where the engine management lights pops up once or twice a month and goes into limp mode. They had it fixed. About 5 times. Still fecked. My advice? Get shot. Sounds like your head gasket is shot too with your dirty mayonaise filler cap, lol
Car occasionally goes into limp mode too, reckon it could be the spark plugs needs changing, again, don't know when that was replaced, probs one or more of the cylinders mis-firing too.

I would like to keep the car for another year, but with it's high millage and an expensive bill to do above things it won't be worth it. Insurance renewal in 4 months time, hopefully it will last by then.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
ashmashcash said:
Mx5, i'd rather be a bus ********!
This might not be the forum for you. hehe


deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Id invest in the clio. Getting quite rare now and will be worth a lot of money in a few years.
Buy a new engine. Wheel bearings. Bushes. Track rod ends and suspension. Then leather the interior and install a decent sound system.
10k should cover that and leave you a few quid for bork fund.

ikarl

4,082 posts

230 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
deltashad said:
Id invest in the clio. Getting quite rare now and will be worth a lot of money in a few years.
Buy a new engine. Wheel bearings. Bushes. Track rod ends and suspension. Then leather the interior and install a decent sound system.
10k should cover that and leave you a few quid for bork fund.
hehehehehehe

BRMMA

1,908 posts

203 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
ashmashcash said:
Hmm, I think it's pointless running it until it dies when I can probably sell it for upwards £1k?
Surely nobody would pay north of a grand for one of those in decent condition let alone yours which is fked

i'd either get the car fixed and plod on with it until you have your house and then when you can afford to upgrade or get rid of it now, buy something for about 3-4k which will be cheap to run and hold money well, probably some sort of VAG diesel

renrut

1,478 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Is this serious? You're talking about buying a house with the 10K saved but then in the same breath considering chopping in a heap of a car for a 335d which at the price you're talking about could have one expensive failure worth more than you got for the clio. FFS a set of tyres a service and insurance for a 335d will be more than the clio is worth and you're balking at spending a few hundred on it.

So I say sell the clio, buy an R32 GTR, you can just about get an R32 for that.

TotalControl

8,307 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
deltashad said:
Id invest in the clio. Getting quite rare now and will be worth a lot of money in a few years.
Buy a new engine. Wheel bearings. Bushes. Track rod ends and suspension. Then leather the interior and install a decent sound system.
10k should cover that and leave you a few quid for bork fund.
hehe

ashmashcash

Original Poster:

58 posts

163 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
renrut said:
Is this serious? You're talking about buying a house with the 10K saved but then in the same breath considering chopping in a heap of a car for a 335d which at the price you're talking about could have one expensive failure worth more than you got for the clio. FFS a set of tyres a service and insurance for a 335d will be more than the clio is worth and you're balking at spending a few hundred on it.

So I say sell the clio, buy an R32 GTR, you can just about get an R32 for that.
From where in my post did I gave the assumption of spending money on the 355d? It's not a car that came into my mind anyway, i was responding to a post where someone mentioned the 355d and the Mx5 where I was merely saying if I were to get a 355d, it would have to be a sport one!

Talk about getting on your high horse!

ryanthescot

287 posts

185 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
ashmashcash said:
From where in my post did I gave the assumption of spending money on the 355d? It's not a car that came into my mind anyway, i was responding to a post where someone mentioned the 355d and the Mx5 where I was merely saying if I were to get a 355d, it would have to be a sport one!

Talk about getting on your high horse!
it's a 335d.

jmflare

413 posts

172 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
If it were me I'd shoot the clio first then stay at home and buy a nice car for 4k e.g. Mx5, Mr2, E30, E36, Celica, etc... in very good condition, then do a tour of Europe in it and then save up and buy/rent a cheap house/apartment.

I'm 19 aswell btw... but i'm poor, i'm going live at uni in sep and i already have a nice car so in no way in a position anything like yours.

The majority of people on here will probably recommend you spend no money at all on anything interesting, only eat bread and put any left over money in a savings account so you can spend it on the heating bill when your 70.



renrut

1,478 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
ashmashcash said:
renrut said:
Is this serious? You're talking about buying a house with the 10K saved but then in the same breath considering chopping in a heap of a car for a 335d which at the price you're talking about could have one expensive failure worth more than you got for the clio. FFS a set of tyres a service and insurance for a 335d will be more than the clio is worth and you're balking at spending a few hundred on it.

So I say sell the clio, buy an R32 GTR, you can just about get an R32 for that.
From where in my post did I gave the assumption of spending money on the 355d? It's not a car that came into my mind anyway, i was responding to a post where someone mentioned the 355d and the Mx5 where I was merely saying if I were to get a 355d, it would have to be a sport one!

Talk about getting on your high horse!
I'm always on a high horse - its the next best thing to a 355d. You talk about buying a more expensive car - which isn't the same thing as a more reliable one, from the sound of it your clio is an expensive car.

Anyway if you can get 1K for the clio do so - then buy something for 1K that wasn't built by the french. Ideally soemthing old and japanese that will still be around after the nuclear holocaust i.e. nissan micra / honda civic / toyota avensis. I'd recommend a 1.2 or 1.3 Micra either K12 or K11 respectively - plenty of poke, more reliable and serviced properly will outlive most things on this planet.

chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
ashmashcash said:
I want to get rid of it and upgrade to a more expensive car, but I also want a house and currently have 10k savings for it.
Why a more expensive car?

You could buy something more interesting for a couple of grand, still keep saving for the house and I guarantee you that being under 25 and owning your own home will pull more birds than having a £25k Audi on a PCP and living with you mum would.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
OP's original post said:
and mucky yellow crap inside underneath the oil cap and engine management light is on.
Mucky Yellow crap....so that will most likely be water ingress into the oil will it.....I can't understand why no one has yet picked up on this, that is walk away territory on any car unless the buyer is feckless and knows nothing about cars and the workings of an internal combustion engine.

I would drive it until it dies and then get something else unless you really need something bigger/better/more expensive. OP sounds like you are saving for a house, so why waste money one a new motor unless you have to?