Moving on from the M3
Author
Discussion

M3Alan

Original Poster:

93 posts

174 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi Guys,
Decided its time for a change, selling my E46 M3 and I'm really stumped as to what to get next.
I've got a budget up to £12.5k, but the less I spend the better as I am on the look out for a house at the moment aswell.

Requirements:
Decent mpg, I do alot of short journeys but would like something that is going to return at least 25mpg day to day.
Have rear seats.
Nice interior.
Still have a fun factor, I really enjoy driving my M3. However, Ive owned it for 2 years now and I'm just bored now, also want better economy.
Ideally less than 6years old. No massive mileage either so sub 80k.

Ideas please...

oj121

1,548 posts

203 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Think your really gonna struggle to be honest. Theres not a lot you can buy that wil get you near the M3.

BMW 130 if you like the BMW ethic.
Audi S3 maybe?


Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
You really will struggle to better the e46 M3 at that price point.

An edition 30 Golf GTI might be worth a look, or perhaps a MINI Cooper S. Both entertaining drives but neither will provide the thrills of the M3.

Your "25mpg for short journeys" criteria will be the breaker.

M3Alan

Original Poster:

93 posts

174 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Cheers for the replies so far.
I can live with less mpg, on longer journeys it would be nice to be able to achieve better fuel consumption though. Edition 30 Gti is probably the top runner at the moment, I have owned a mk5 Gti before and was a great all rounder.

Schermerhorn

4,353 posts

220 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
R32 Golf? They are as nippy as the M3 point-to-point (except when you are really going for it), they have a great DSG gearbox and quite a lot of kudos.

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
M3Alan said:
Cheers for the replies so far.
I can live with less mpg, on longer journeys it would be nice to be able to achieve better fuel consumption though. Edition 30 Gti is probably the top runner at the moment, I have owned a mk5 Gti before and was a great all rounder.
I'm reluctant to suggest diesels, but...

A 123d might be worth looking at. The old 1er had a lovely chassis and the 123 engine is entertaining in its own way. No substitute for a 340bhp S54, but then not much else is.

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Schermerhorn said:
R32 Golf? They are as nippy as the M3 point-to-point (except when you are really going for it), they have a great DSG gearbox and quite a lot of kudos.
In my experience, the R32 is nowhere near as quick as an e46 M3 and it's thirstier. Sounds nice, but not really an answer to the question posed.

SBN

1,030 posts

183 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
335i or 330i saloon or coupe can be had at that price.

You'd get a nice place to be, rear wheel drive and room for four adults

My 330i e90 is currently averaging 26mpg over 15,000 miles.

VWAUDI

342 posts

188 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Schermerhorn said:
R32 Golf? They are as nippy as the M3 point-to-point (except when you are really going for it
By that logic any old remapped diesel hatch is as fast as an M3 point to point. An R32 is nowhere near as fast an E46 M3.

Maxus

1,257 posts

212 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
MINI Cooper S JCW? Small rear seats though. If you came on here with your criteria the answer would probably be M3!

fausTVR

1,442 posts

181 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Not as clinical and souless as the tuetonic machines, but never the less £12k gets you a nice Cerbera these days. Proper bragging rights for life if nothing else.

8Ace

2,836 posts

229 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Standard PH response, but with some degree of seriousness:

Cracking xjr for 6k and change for petrol.



cheddar

4,637 posts

205 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
M3Alan said:
Cheers for the replies so far.
I can live with less mpg, on longer journeys it would be nice to be able to achieve better fuel consumption though. Edition 30 Gti is probably the top runner at the moment, I have owned a mk5 Gti before and was a great all rounder.
I owned an ED30, very good all round car, produced more than the quoted 230bhp and used pretty much the Audi S3 engine but VW kept quiet about it so as not to upset Audi sales. Got bored of it quite quickly though.

Also had the previously suggested 123D Coupe, probably a better all round car than the ED30 but it needs a bit more poke, quick car but deceptive, a re-map might help.

Someone mentioned a JCW Mini and that's where my 12k would go.

It's a tough ask when coming from an M3, especially with your tight budget.

Richie C

653 posts

237 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
fausTVR said:
Not as clinical and souless as the tuetonic machines, but never the less £12k gets you a nice Cerbera these days. Proper bragging rights for life if nothing else.
I think you'll struggle to get 25mpg from a Cerbera.

rumple

15,445 posts

182 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
335d, 90% of the performance, much more economical.

Bonefish Blues

36,997 posts

254 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
If you didn't need the rear seats that would open more options like Boxsters et al, but this one's a problem - you really sure you need to sell?

S3000

513 posts

190 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
rumple said:
335d, 90% of the performance, much more economical.
much more boring also...

M3Alan

Original Poster:

93 posts

174 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
I don't have to sell, it's just like I said I've owned the car 2 years and just want to get into something a bit newer. Mine is an 02 reg.

CampDavid

9,145 posts

229 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Gruber said:
Your "25mpg for short journeys" criteria will be the breaker.
Our 1.6i Megane only does 25mpg day to day, during it's permanent short journey life.

Can't think of much really to compete with the M3, Boxster?

Edit: Boxster lacks rear seats.

Errrr. Ummmm. An M3 CS?

Wills2

29,941 posts

206 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all

Only issue is all roads point the car the OP has.