BMW E46 reliability? - 330i vs M3
Discussion
Hello all,
I made a whatcar post a few weeks ago - to summarize - This is my 1st car in the UK having come from the land of Mustangs (USA). I've settled on either an EP3 Civic or a E46 BMW - and i'm leaning to ze german car, just because it's a bit more grown up and i'm starting to feel my age (35)!
What i'm wondering is what I would be getting myself into if I go the Bimer route. Is the E46 a generally reliable ride? My budget is anywhere form £4-6k - though I am very tempted to stretch to £7000 if it would get me a decent M3?
So, any E46 owners reading this? Tell me about your cars and any issues you have had, and what I can expect from an E46 with 80-100k miles.
Is the M3 any more or less reliable than the 330 - assuming of course the M would be a high mileage car on the low price range, and the 330 more in the average price bracket.
My biggest concern is that i'm not yet settled, have no tools or place to work on my car, and have never allowed anyone else to work on my cars for me - so I want something fairly bullitproof that I don;t have to open the bonnet on at all - at at least very often.
Any insight or guidance would be appreciated!
I made a whatcar post a few weeks ago - to summarize - This is my 1st car in the UK having come from the land of Mustangs (USA). I've settled on either an EP3 Civic or a E46 BMW - and i'm leaning to ze german car, just because it's a bit more grown up and i'm starting to feel my age (35)!
What i'm wondering is what I would be getting myself into if I go the Bimer route. Is the E46 a generally reliable ride? My budget is anywhere form £4-6k - though I am very tempted to stretch to £7000 if it would get me a decent M3?
So, any E46 owners reading this? Tell me about your cars and any issues you have had, and what I can expect from an E46 with 80-100k miles.
Is the M3 any more or less reliable than the 330 - assuming of course the M would be a high mileage car on the low price range, and the 330 more in the average price bracket.
My biggest concern is that i'm not yet settled, have no tools or place to work on my car, and have never allowed anyone else to work on my cars for me - so I want something fairly bullitproof that I don;t have to open the bonnet on at all - at at least very often.
Any insight or guidance would be appreciated!
Both are very reliable cars, they have issues but buy carefully and you can get a good one, I have a 330, owned it 3 years with no issues, its snapped a few rear springs though, the main running cost difference is servicing and parts, you will pay an M tax, however the 330 is an awesome cruiser, practical , comfy, cheapish to run, the M3 is a f
king madman, over 100bhp difference.
It all depends what you want, they are simple cars to work on, I would look into the servicing costs on the M3, if you can live with that buy one, insurance was similar for me, MPG is roughly the same, mines in the readers car section, have a look at a nice 330, then buy an M3.
king madman, over 100bhp difference.It all depends what you want, they are simple cars to work on, I would look into the servicing costs on the M3, if you can live with that buy one, insurance was similar for me, MPG is roughly the same, mines in the readers car section, have a look at a nice 330, then buy an M3.
I have an m3. I would not be stretching to £7k as decent ones aren't that cheap, Maybe 8 or 9. With that and higher running costs.... The 330 looks more appealing for reliability and keeping costs down. M3 servicing costs a lot more too.
I get low 20's mpg but my mileage is low and drive in town a bit.
But if you can afford it and can find a decent independent go for the M!!
I get low 20's mpg but my mileage is low and drive in town a bit.
But if you can afford it and can find a decent independent go for the M!!
I started off by looking at an e46 330 a year ago but it seems the e46 has reached the E39 stage - complex and very expensive to repair, while being very prone to rust (the mot failing variety) and electrical problems.
I purchased a far older merc- I'd far rather run a w124 on a budget than an e46, as much as the M3 version of that car is a car I will own.
I purchased a far older merc- I'd far rather run a w124 on a budget than an e46, as much as the M3 version of that car is a car I will own.
M3 can rip a hole in it's own backside (boot floor), engine can sometimes have bearing trouble at high mileage, and bits are more expensive than 330 parts. Manual is more reliable than the SMG.
The standard E46 is pretty much bullet proof, apart from rusty arches, suspension bushes and springs, nothing major.
What there is on the car is fixable on a budget - pattern parts are cheap, and the knowledge base is huge on both the 330 or M3.
Graduate to an E90 or something even more electronic and things get very silly very quickly.
The standard E46 is pretty much bullet proof, apart from rusty arches, suspension bushes and springs, nothing major.
What there is on the car is fixable on a budget - pattern parts are cheap, and the knowledge base is huge on both the 330 or M3.
Graduate to an E90 or something even more electronic and things get very silly very quickly.
Ive owned a 330Ci for 5 years & had no major problems 100 > 150k miles.
Take a look at my readers cars thread for some details on the maintenance I've done in this time: http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=...
I'd thoroughly recommend one for reliability, mines on nearly 160k miles & I did a 300 mile trip in the car today with no issues at all and in total comfort.
Sounds like an M3 may be more suitable though if you are used to muscle cars!
Take a look at my readers cars thread for some details on the maintenance I've done in this time: http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=...
I'd thoroughly recommend one for reliability, mines on nearly 160k miles & I did a 300 mile trip in the car today with no issues at all and in total comfort.
Sounds like an M3 may be more suitable though if you are used to muscle cars!
We've owned a 330ci for 3-4 years now, and I had a friend who had an E46 M3 - he sold it due to crazy servicing costs and expensive bespoke parts.
As mentioned, the cooking 6 cyl engines aren't too expensive for spares, but they do have a number of common niggles.
One common one on the 6cyl petrol is coolant system failing from around 70k, water pump failures, radiator bowing, cracked expansion tank, iffy thermostat. I replaced all of ours for peace of mind at around 85k, the radiator looked like it was ready to split when I got it out.
Other common issues are rusting around front & rear arches (keeping front arches clean inside helps), and cracking of subframe mounts at rear.
Common niggles include sticking 5th gear centring spring (ours has this), sticking door lock actuators (pass one has this on ours), heater FSR fails giving battery drain or erratic fans (ours had this), and probably a few other issues.
They are quite hard on front suspension arms & bushes, I replaced ours with Meyle HD ones which weren't too expensive but were very well made.
All in all, a good car, but they do have a few minor issues which if you're not the DIY type - could cost you a bit.
A 7k M3 would be an option if you buy carefully, and again, work on your own cars, but otherwise could soon get costly.
Ours has been a great car over the last few years though, rides nicely, quick enough, well specced - missus thought about replacing it recently, but I think she's having trouble deciding on a replacement!
As mentioned, the cooking 6 cyl engines aren't too expensive for spares, but they do have a number of common niggles.
One common one on the 6cyl petrol is coolant system failing from around 70k, water pump failures, radiator bowing, cracked expansion tank, iffy thermostat. I replaced all of ours for peace of mind at around 85k, the radiator looked like it was ready to split when I got it out.
Other common issues are rusting around front & rear arches (keeping front arches clean inside helps), and cracking of subframe mounts at rear.
Common niggles include sticking 5th gear centring spring (ours has this), sticking door lock actuators (pass one has this on ours), heater FSR fails giving battery drain or erratic fans (ours had this), and probably a few other issues.
They are quite hard on front suspension arms & bushes, I replaced ours with Meyle HD ones which weren't too expensive but were very well made.
All in all, a good car, but they do have a few minor issues which if you're not the DIY type - could cost you a bit.
A 7k M3 would be an option if you buy carefully, and again, work on your own cars, but otherwise could soon get costly.
Ours has been a great car over the last few years though, rides nicely, quick enough, well specced - missus thought about replacing it recently, but I think she's having trouble deciding on a replacement!
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


