Premium car parts rip off
Premium car parts rip off
Author
Discussion

Shambler

Original Poster:

1,221 posts

175 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
A friend needed to replace the trailing arm bushes on a Jag X type. He contacted Jaguar and they sent the parts out at £27.60 each in a plastic Jaguar branded bag. The part had Ford stamped on it and after further investigation the exact same part was acquired from Ford for £6. How can Jaguar charge over 400% plus for the same part? Is there even worse examples out there?

AlpineWhite

2,164 posts

226 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Perhaps ford sell more of them than jaguar.

Perhaps ford buy them for less than jaguar.

Perhaps jaguar have higher costs in their supply and distribution.

Perhaps jaguar owners are willing to pay more than a ford owner.

Liokault

2,837 posts

245 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
AlpineWhite said:
Perhaps ford sell more of them than jaguar.

Perhaps ford buy them for less than jaguar.

Perhaps jaguar have higher costs in their supply and distribution.

Perhaps jaguar owners are willing to pay more than a ford owner.
Number 4


Eski1991

1,113 posts

164 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Is the X Type not based on a Ford platform and fairly similar to the Mondeo? Maybe this caused Jaguar to think that he paid Jag money for a Ford car and that maybe he would pay Jag money for Ford parts also? Still think it's unfair regardless. Worse still are the garages that charge a premium for parts for UK cars that are made by foreign companies, Japanese cars for instance.

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
If ford are selling them for £6, then they cost less than a £1 to manufacture.

I have worked on a number of products and I think the largest mark up I've seen was a turbo costing ford £70, sold by a ford dealer for £700, but the largest %age was a solenoid which cost £3.50 to make, and ranged from £65 to £95 depending on the brand on the box. VW was highest, Rover was lowest IIRC

AlpineWhite

2,164 posts

226 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Liokault said:
Number 4
Probably all of them, in my opinion. But number 4 first hehe

BRMMA

1,908 posts

203 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
When I wanted to replace the ignition switch in my Boxster the cost was about £40 from Porsche, £15 from Audi or £8 from VW. For a set of brake disks for my GS Maserati want over 2k, buying the same part from Brembo who make them for Maserati brings the cost down to £350

Shambler

Original Poster:

1,221 posts

175 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
BRMMA said:
When I wanted to replace the ignition switch in my Boxster the cost was about £40 from Porsche, £15 from Audi or £8 from VW. For a set of brake disks for my GS Maserati want over 2k, buying the same part from Brembo who make them for Maserati brings the cost down to £350
That is a crazy mark up by Maserati.

lexusboy

1,101 posts

174 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Premium car, premium prices. I thought that was known by everyone?

DCLXIV

362 posts

166 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
1. Jaguar can get away with charging more
2. Jaguar will have to buy their parts from Ford, who will no doubt charge a premium rate

Lozw86

903 posts

163 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Goes to show it is always worth shopping around

jamoor

14,506 posts

246 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
why not just get an aftermarket part.

james280779

1,931 posts

260 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Try owning a Lotus Esprit - parts from Lotus are extortionate, quick internet search reveals and 'alternative parts list' and as usual most are manufactored by Toyota, Land Rover, GM etc so I just buy those parts and they all fit as they should.

Learnt this from my old TVR. Most sports cars of that ilk have 'borrowed' parts

gavgavgav

1,569 posts

260 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
This is why you need to be very afraid of the past 'noises' of limiting car parts to OEM only.

Nobby Diesel

2,120 posts

282 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
AlpineWhite said:
Perhaps ford sell more of them than jaguar.

Perhaps ford buy them for less than jaguar.

Perhaps jaguar have higher costs in their supply and distribution.

Perhaps jaguar owners are willing to pay more than a ford owner.
I think you missed the 5th option.......

most Jag drivers are old duffers, on their way to the golf club, who don't go on the internet and don't know about independant parts retailers. Therefore, they charge as much as they think they can get away with.

mattikake

5,119 posts

230 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
lexusboy said:
Premium car, premium prices. I thought that was known by everyone?
There's a reason capitalism has well out-stayed it's welcome... it's because the comsumer is stooooopid. wink

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
1. Because they can.

2. Because they can.

3. Because...

You get the idea...

GenePoolReject13

1,970 posts

220 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
A guy walked in to us today asking if he could borrow a locking wheel nut key as the one for his X-type had sheared in 2. All he wanted to do is whip off the 4 locking wheel nuts but Jaguar wanted to charge him £104 for the privilege of doing it for him or £70 for a new key. £70 for the new key although expensive is to be expected but £104 just to undo 4 bolts is an absolute piss take. Unfortunately the one we had did not fit.

jamoor

14,506 posts

246 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
GenePoolReject13 said:
A guy walked in to us today asking if he could borrow a locking wheel nut key as the one for his X-type had sheared in 2. All he wanted to do is whip off the 4 locking wheel nuts but Jaguar wanted to charge him £104 for the privilege of doing it for him or £70 for a new key. £70 for the new key although expensive is to be expected but £104 just to undo 4 bolts is an absolute piss take. Unfortunately the one we had did not fit.
Most tyre places can remove locking wheel nuts.

I like BMW as their prices aren't extortionate, for example that key would be a tenner or thereabouts.

HustleRussell

26,715 posts

191 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
jamoor said:
why not just get an aftermarket part.
Because once you've considered the labour cost to fit the bushes, fitting inferior copies is a false economy. I find you have to pick your aftermarket parts very carefully because while some represent decent value, most are cheaper for a reason unless you can get OEM manufactured ones from another source (which, as the OP had found, happens often).