Which barge shed?
Author
Discussion

pd2

Original Poster:

305 posts

180 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Evening everyone,

My pcp on my car ends this month and it's going back. I am going to get a shed for a year or so and save some cash for a change.

My choices have came down too a nice looking 1998 Lexus gs300 3L Straight 6 with 87k or one of the hoards of 3L V6 Jag S-types out there.

I like the GS and the wife likes the Jags.

Does anyone have any experience with either of these cars? Advice? Anything specific to look out for? Etc, etc, etc.

I've been trawling the classifieds, AT, etc for the last few months and I'm still not 100% what I'm going to do!

Cheers!

Paul.

deeen

6,413 posts

276 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
A chap I know who owns an independent Jag garage said the S-type was the worst of the "modern" crop of Jags for reliability.

pd2

Original Poster:

305 posts

180 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
deeen said:
A chap I know who owns an independent Jag garage said the S-type was the worst of the "modern" crop of Jags for reliability.
Not a good start for the wife then!!

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
deeen said:
A chap I know who owns an independent Jag garage said the S-type was the worst of the "modern" crop of Jags for reliability.
Plus have you seen its face?

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
a lexus of some flavour . take a look at the bargain basement thread . honda legend etc

eltax91

10,797 posts

237 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Surely the Lexus is the one that won't let you down. Ever!

Sir Fergie

795 posts

166 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Wasn't 1998 the change over from the Mk 1 GS to the Mk 2??.

Early S types weren't supposed to be the best in terms of driving, they started getting better from 02 on i believe. The Lexus will be a lot more reliable though.

Could you consider skipping those 2 altogether and going the full hog and going LS or XJ instead???.

Sir Fergie

Jw Vw

4,927 posts

194 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Lexus all day long.

giblet

9,157 posts

208 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Whats your budget? If fuel isn't an issue then how about an LS400 or an XJ as already suggested? Legend is a good left field choice, again as already suggested

BE57 TOY

2,628 posts

178 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
What's the pcp car going back out of interest?

pd2

Original Poster:

305 posts

180 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Sir Fergie said:
Could you consider skipping those 2 altogether and going the full hog and going LS or XJ instead???.

Sir Fergie
I personally prefer these but again, the wife.........


This is the GS in question....

http://www.gumtree.com/p/cars-vans-motorbikes/1998...

Shed budget £1000

The car going back is a smart fortwo. Only bought as my wife was traveling from Glasgow to Edinburgh 5 days a week!
She won't be doing this anymore from the middle of May.

Engine size, well, as much as I would love a V8 the wife isn't convinced. Kind of limiting it to 3.0L straight/V6's.
I am open to options as I was originally considering C230k and I am never out of the barge thread on here!! smile

Paul.


Edited by pd2 on Saturday 27th April 16:44

Xtriple129

1,173 posts

188 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm a huge Jag fan and I'd have the Lexus all day long! Next door neighbour had an S type, was always in the garage being fixed (badly). Dreadfully unreliable.

Sir Fergie

795 posts

166 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
pd2 said:
I personally prefer these but again, the wife.........


This is the GS in question....

http://www.gumtree.com/p/cars-vans-motorbikes/1998...

Shed budget £1000

The car going back is a smart fortwo. Only bought as my wife was traveling from Glasgow to Edinburgh 5 days a week!
She won't be doing this anymore from the middle of May.

Engine size, well, as much as I would love a V8 the wife isn't convinced. Kind of limiting it to 3.0L straight/V6's.
I am open to options as I was originally considering C230k and I am never out of the barge thread on here!! smile

Paul.


Edited by pd2 on Saturday 27th April 16:44
Nice exterior and interior combination on that - should be a nice place to be sat in.

Highly tempting to go Jag to keep wifey happy - but alas - if your going S type at the same age - the early ones weren't amazing by all accounts. Probably a perfectly nice car still - but they also have a reputation for going wrong.

Go for the Lexus biggrin

Sir Fergie

Baryonyx

18,297 posts

190 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
The Lexus is the one. Better than the Jaguar in every way!

0a

24,160 posts

225 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd also add a W124 merc to the list - I was looking for a mini barge myself and had never considered one until mine came up at the right time. Female family members all love the comfortable ride and the classic styling. The don't have the "wrong" image that other bargain basement cars do.

I added a couple of hundred miles to the 155k on the clock with ease today, and regularly ferry people about in it and get positive comments.

The 4 doors are plentiful and the problems well documented. I believe most parts are available and not highly priced, and in my experience mechanics like working on them as they are well built but relatively simple (my early 4 speed 300e uses a very old fashioned but pretty robust transmission /engine).

Vince70

1,944 posts

225 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
How about a small engined Audi A8, you should get an early one for around a bag with a 2.8, plus your never going to have to worry about rust issues..


Sir Fergie

795 posts

166 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
0a said:
I'd also add a W124 merc to the list - I was looking for a mini barge myself and had never considered one until mine came up at the right time. Female family members all love the comfortable ride and the classic styling. The don't have the "wrong" image that other bargain basement cars do.

I added a couple of hundred miles to the 155k on the clock with ease today, and regularly ferry people about in it and get positive comments.

The 4 doors are plentiful and the problems well documented. I believe most parts are available and not highly priced, and in my experience mechanics like working on them as they are well built but relatively simple (my early 4 speed 300e uses a very old fashioned but pretty robust transmission /engine).
One of my most memorable rides in a car was in a 230E - lovely lovely cars.

Ride quality on the W124 (if that 230 is typical) was sublime - and Mercedes have a way of designing their cars that you cannot feel the harshness of the outside world.

Got a lift in a CLS a few years ago - and again - even with big wheels - the car seemed to keep the harshness of the road from entering ones awareness inside.

Its like your on air suspension even though the W124 didn't have air suspension - i don't know about the CLS though.

Sir Fergie

surveyor

18,708 posts

215 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Old man has a V8 s-type. He's had a couple of 6 cylinder engined one as well.

One of his cost a fair bit in bills, but he bought it that way - neglected. The others have not been too bad really.

They like to eat bushes apparently.

pd2

Original Poster:

305 posts

180 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
Old man has a V8 s-type. He's had a couple of 6 cylinder engined one as well.

One of his cost a fair bit in bills, but he bought it that way - neglected. The others have not been too bad really.

They like to eat bushes apparently.
Whatever I decide on I'm going to try and run it for a year or two.

I emailed the guy about the GS yesterday, so hopefully that's still available to look at.

Will have a look at w124's, I did look at a couple of 190E's, but again, other things got involved..... Wife.......
(it's never easy, is it?!)