BMW E39 530D - Should I?
BMW E39 530D - Should I?
Author
Discussion

sgtbash

Original Poster:

766 posts

167 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

So im looking at getting one of these in a month, I will be spending around 3k on one. I just love the look of the car itself, and it will be my first car that isnt a Corsa (I currently have a Corsa C 1.8).

I drove an E39 535i last year and just loved the look and feel of the car itself, it was wonderful to drive compared to my current car, and now that my insurance is getting affordable (im 21 now) im looking for a car thats more grown up.

The only thing im thinking about is running costs, I know that the fuel bill will be huge compared to the Corsa (Saying that I spend £60 for 230 miles in the Corsa)

Am I making a bad decision going for an expensive "older" car like this?

Edited by sgtbash on Saturday 27th April 20:20

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
There is a rule that says if you couldn't afford to run it new, you cannot afford it now. It will be a big, complex, old car and cost you a fortune if you aren't careful. If you must, get a petrol.

Bitzer

4,553 posts

199 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I think you meant you'd driven an E93 335i?

As for the 530, any reason for not choosing the petrol 530i? It should be cheaper to buy and has less to go wrong.

surveyor

18,708 posts

215 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm not convinced by the rule. The E39 530D is not going to be complex by todays standards.

I say go for it.

I run a E320 cdi, of a similar vintage, and the diesel technology really does not frighten me as much as the Mercedes rot.

Very different car from a Corsa, but in a good way.

sgtbash

Original Poster:

766 posts

167 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Bitzer said:
I think you meant you'd driven an E93 335i?

As for the 530, any reason for not choosing the petrol 530i? It should be cheaper to buy and has less to go wrong.
Nope, id driven a '02 E39 535i !

I always assumed that its better to go diesel in these bigger cars?

Bohally

943 posts

178 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Do it.

Life is too short to be sensible.

winshent

1,174 posts

226 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I run an E39 530i..

The difference in mpg wont be big unless your sitting in town traffic a lot.. I'd look at the 530's, you'll save a lot on the initial outlay and can offset that against fuel bills..

Plus, you wont have any scary injector bills..

sgtbash

Original Poster:

766 posts

167 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I am happy I created this thread, I never realised the Diesel are such a big nono.

I would really love a 335i however I think the V8 is a bit too much in regards to running costs!

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
sgtbash said:
I am happy I created this thread, I never realised the Diesel are such a big nono.

I would really love a 335i however I think the V8 is a bit too much in regards to running costs!
They aren't-I've just done a Amsterdam to a very congested central London and back in a day trip, averaged 48mpg and cruised at 90ish most of the way in my E39 manual 525d. A petrol car would have been in the mid to high twenties.

Of course in the uk you get shafted on the price of diesel and a manual E39 530i is possibly the best car Bmw have ever made.

winshent

1,174 posts

226 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
sgtbash said:
I am happy I created this thread, I never realised the Diesel are such a big nono.
They arent a big no-no, but you can get some scary bills and mpg althgough, is still way off the mark of todays diesels..

A 530i will easily do 40mpg on a run.. A 530d will achieve around 6- 7 mpg more.. So unless your doing big miles its probably not worth going diesel..

surveyor

18,708 posts

215 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
winshent said:
sgtbash said:
I am happy I created this thread, I never realised the Diesel are such a big nono.
They arent a big no-no, but you can get some scary bills and mpg althgough, is still way off the mark of todays diesels..

A 530i will easily do 40mpg on a run.. A 530d will achieve around 6- 7 mpg more.. So unless your doing big miles its probably not worth going diesel..
530i easily doing 40mpg on a run? I'm really not convinced by that argument - weakens your point. I'd like to see your car adds!. 35mpg maybe.

Edited by surveyor on Saturday 27th April 21:19

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Get the e39 530i.

I ran one for 60k miles a few years back. Probably the best all-rounder I've ever had.

Either look through the history for the receipt to show it's been done, or budget for a new rad/cooling system - to be fair, most will have been done.

sgtbash

Original Poster:

766 posts

167 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
E39 530i it is.

How much should I be spending on one? What mileage are they good for?

winshent

1,174 posts

226 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
530i easily doing 40mph on a run? I'm really not convinced by that argument - weakens your point. I'd like to see your car adds!. 35mpg maybe.
My 530i manual sits at around 40mpg doing 75mph on a motorway run.. This is according to the computer.. I'm not anal enough to do the precise calcs.. I just fill up and drive..

A friend also had one and he used to achieve similar mpg..

winshent

1,174 posts

226 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
sgtbash said:
E39 530i it is.

How much should I be spending on one? What mileage are they good for?
Spanish E39 530i's are rare compared to autos, but are worth seeking out..

Looking on auto trader you can see that a lot of them have 150- 200k on the clock.. I bought my 530i M Sport with 80k for £2,500 last year.. Buy on condition and with good history..

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
My E39 530i Auto struggled to manage 30mpg on a steady 300 mile motorway run.

It's a supremely delightful car to drive, everything feels like it's expertly put together (except the heater controls)

It was the most comfortable car I've ever driven

It did 15mpg around town (congested Brighton, managed 20mg around Sunderland town)

It looked good even compared to modern stuff

It cost £2000 in repairs over a period of three months

The "comfort" seating package was the best I've ever owned

It had a wobble through the suspension that was utterly incurable desite the £2K in various repairs to wheels and suspension bits and bobs

I loved owning an auto

After spending the £2K on repairs over three months the autobox died and I had to scrap it frown

What I'm trying to say is that in good condition they are a fantastic car, but don't be under any illusions, they are a complex old beast with LOTS to go wrong and will RUIN you if you want to keep it running nicely.

ETA - I ended up buying a 56 reg Mondeo and it's not as good as the E39 when it was at it's best, but it's so much less painful than the E39 when it was at it's worst.

Bitzer

4,553 posts

199 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
sgtbash said:
Bitzer said:
I think you meant you'd driven an E93 335i?

As for the 530, any reason for not choosing the petrol 530i? It should be cheaper to buy and has less to go wrong.
Nope, id driven a '02 E39 535i !

I always assumed that its better to go diesel in these bigger cars?
Of course, I'd forgot about the 535i thumbup

200Plus Club

13,828 posts

309 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
i had a 5 speed manual 530D sport in Imola Red and i loved the car. it handled beautifully, and i had it reflashed for a bit more power. loads of toys, perfect driving position and feel. would have one again tomorrow.
used to get great mpg when cruising.

downside- horrendously expensive cats- like 900quid expensive at bmw and silly money elsewhere, managed to get a second hand one and flexi when mine went. decent servicing costs, as mentioned its a bmw and they aint cheap to run.

my bootlid rusted in the usual spot which needed baremetalling and painting to put right.

highly recommended imho with the model i had. the original owner spec'd it right up from new, it was mentally expensive on the original bill of sale for the yr!


Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
winshent said:
My 530i manual sits at around 40mpg doing 75mph on a motorway run.. This is according to the computer.. I'm not anal enough to do the precise calcs.. I just fill up and drive..

A friend also had one and he used to achieve similar mpg..
Lordy I'm talking about several hours in rush hour traffic in central London and Amsterdam with mixed high speed touring and still averaging in the high 40s...........my 330ci with the same engine struggled to manage mid 20's in the same circumstances.

Re: Shimmy- the previous owner of my car changed the bushes and suspension arms all round for powerflex and uprated arms. It drives like a newish car in terms of tightness. No shimmy and a sublime ride in most circumstances. It's an SE touring.......

Edited by Motorrad on Saturday 27th April 21:57


Edited by Motorrad on Saturday 27th April 21:59

sgtbash

Original Poster:

766 posts

167 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
So I really do need to make sure I get the best I can otherwise I will be in trouble!