Remaping
Author
Discussion

krissharm

Original Poster:

2,223 posts

170 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Yes there is a torrent of information on google...(read internet) about them, but how about some real world opinions?

It seems particually the diesel remaps offer a huge amount of HP increase and also seems to promise better fuel economy, better power? What is the catch?

It seems to me that if the simple remap provided all this why did the car builder not just ship it like this? What is the real benefit? What is the real risk?

If you have had one, was it on a new car? One with 100k miles on already? Did you change anything else?

bearman68

4,942 posts

163 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi, remapping almost always offers what's advertised in my experience.

I have a 90 bhp 406 remapped to 130. Goes like a train now, and does more MPG (about 5%). Gone from 140k to 250 no worries
My parents 406 has been remapped for economy, and does nearly 60 mpg, while retaining the 110 bhp. (175k)
My BMW 525 has been remapped to about 220 Bhp and goes like a bat out of hell, and returns about 49 mpg at a steady 75 (140k)

If your driving style doesn't change, you will get more MPG, and more power / torque whern you need it

The Pug in particular is a good example - I took the clutch out recently, mainly because it needed a major service, and it was almost perfect, even after 250k - amazing.
If you go ahead with your remap, I'd suggest getting the egr removed while your at it. It will save some very dirty oil.

Where are you?

bearman68

4,942 posts

163 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Hi, remapping almost always offers what's advertised in my experience.

I have a 90 bhp 406 remapped to 130. Goes like a train now, and does more MPG (about 5%). Gone from 140k to 250 no worries
My parents 406 has been remapped for economy, and does nearly 60 mpg, while retaining the 110 bhp. (175k)
My BMW 525 has been remapped to about 220 Bhp and goes like a bat out of hell, and returns about 49 mpg at a steady 75 (140k)

If your driving style doesn't change, you will get more MPG, and more power / torque whern you need it

The Pug in particular is a good example - I took the clutch out recently, mainly because it needed a major service, and it was almost perfect, even after 250k - amazing.
If you go ahead with your remap, I'd suggest getting the egr removed while your at it. It will save some very dirty oil.

Where are you?

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Remap of what? Remapping a NA small petrol will do bugger all in reality. Remapping a VAG 2.0 Turbo charged petrol will produce significant (up to 45%) gains in power. Remapping a large bore TDi will also produce good gains.

On a recent VAG 2.0l TSi a simple stage 1 remap will see you get about 40 extra BHP and associated torque curve lift. It will in all reality transform the car. A stage 2 with associated hardware (sports cat and larger bore DP) will improve it again significantly to around 290bhp and 280 ft-lbs torque. As a real world example, Octavia vRS 2.0T (2010) starts off with circa 197hp out of the factory gate and will return about 7.2 seconds 0-60 time. On a stage 1 that will be circa 260bhp and drop to about 6 secs 0-60 and stage 2 about 290bph and 5.5 secs. (at this point traction becomes a huge issue), however the in gear acceleration improvements on a stage 2 is enormous. At this point the stock IHI turbo is pretty much at max. You can stage 3 such an engine for a couple of grand more hardware (fuel pump, turbo, intercooler etc) but without seriously changing the suspension, brakes etc there is no point. I know of someone that has stage 3'd an Octavia vRS and it is truly mental and will happily out drag 99% of the metal on the roads. But it wasn't cheap.

So TL;DR: Given the right engine yes remapping is a very good way of improving a fairly standard car's performance cheaply (Don't forget the potential insurance hit).


HughS47

616 posts

165 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
It is my understanding that manufacturers have a base tune/map for all cars that roll off the production line that has an element of protection built into it to take account for poor RON fuel in other countries and poor service schedules etc. Remapping simply removes these built in safety parameters to get the best out of the equipment available. Providing you keep up with maintanence and don't start thrashing it, there shouldn't be any negatives but the components will obviously wear faster with more power/aggressive driving.

As a note - I don't have a remapped car, but have friends who did it problem free. I have been looking at a REVO remap for a GT TDI 140 golf and the results look astonishing, only negative is a £150 or so hike in the insurance premium and my concerns over what would happen to the DSG box.

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
HughS47 said:
It is my understanding that manufacturers have a base tune/map for all cars that roll off the production line that has an element of protection built into it to take account for poor RON fuel in other countries and poor service schedules etc. Remapping simply removes these built in safety parameters to get the best out of the equipment available. Providing you keep up with maintanence and don't start thrashing it, there shouldn't be any negatives but the components will obviously wear faster with more power/aggressive driving.

As a note - I don't have a remapped car, but have friends who did it problem free. I have been looking at a REVO remap for a GT TDI 140 golf and the results look astonishing, only negative is a £150 or so hike in the insurance premium and my concerns over what would happen to the DSG box.
The 6 Speed DSG is very strong...much hardier than the manual box/clutch. If you do some digging you will find it is good for well over 350ft-lbs of torque*. Of course any "hidden issues" that may already exist in your box will more likely become apparent if you increase the power through it.

Another issue is that to see the best of any remap (petrol) you need to be using a higher RON fuel. Sure a remapped engine will run on 95 RON but it will respond noticeably better on 98RON or above.

The internetz is awash with forums full of people who have remapped their cars (especially the VAG ones as it is "encouraged" by VAG on their TSi range).

  • Keep the "Launch Control" starts to a minimum though.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
HughS47 said:
It is my understanding that manufacturers have a base tune/map for all cars that roll off the production line that has an element of protection built into it to take account for poor RON fuel in other countries and poor service schedules etc. Remapping simply removes these built in safety parameters to get the best out of the equipment available. Providing you keep up with maintanence and don't start thrashing it, there shouldn't be any negatives but the components will obviously wear faster with more power/aggressive driving.
Sort of this - yes, manufacturers work with a considerable 'safety factor' when designing their engines. This is because the expected life cycle for an engine is around 300,000 miles, and there are a lot of variable factors involved it its manufacture and use over that sort of period, so the calculation of what's needed is then padded a bit to add some 'spare durability' in case of hard use, parts being close to tolerance limits, etc. But I would not say that a remapped engine is 'obviously' going to wear faster, in fact I wouldn't say increased wear is a necessity at all - if you have a semi-decent engine all well within tolerance, you probably won't take it out of its designed operating window (temperatures, pressures, mean piston speeds etc) by remapping it - so you'll be fine.

Engine durability is only half the story. You also have to remember that a manufacturer makes a massive compromise when setting up an engine. You have to juggle that durability with power, response, delivery, efficiency and emissions - as a result you have to make something that is jack of all these trades but ultimately master of fkall because it has to appeal to such a wide market and satisfy so many conflicting targets.

You, however, know just what you want from your engine - not silly loss of durability (but nowhere near as bothered as an OEM has to be), bearable economy, but massive performance and sod the emissions - so a remapper can essentially take all the compromise out to deliver that spec, rather than the wide-ranging one the car was sold with.

Edited by McSam on Sunday 28th April 10:15

VolvoT5

4,155 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I wouldn't bother - with an older car as it may lead to premature failure of already old/tired components and with a newer car you of course invalidate the manufacturer warranty. I remapped a Leon TDI and almost immediately the clutch started slipping, I also had a Volvo T5 remapped and about 3 weeks later the head gasket failed and the car terminally overheated


McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
So the Leon's clutch only had a tiny amount of life left in it, and the Volvo had already been overheated a couple of times to weaken the head gasket?

Any reputable company has solid, thoroughly tested maps that aren't going to make any otherwise sound car go pop. What they could do is accelerate the appearance of failures that were already imminent!

krissharm

Original Poster:

2,223 posts

170 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies guys.
I suppose the reason I am curious is the whole too good to be true thing. I am indeed looking at a diesel car with a turbo, but perhaps I have more questions as I am not sure what is meant by the ERG valve?

I suppose it is logical that any potential problems would surface faster. And intresting comment about the clutch, I didn't think about that...

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
The remapped figures should be taken with a pinch of salt. diesels remap well some engines too but some not so much. (230k)


VolvoT5

4,155 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
McSam said:
So the Leon's clutch only had a tiny amount of life left in it, and the Volvo had already been overheated a couple of times to weaken the head gasket?

Any reputable company has solid, thoroughly tested maps that aren't going to make any otherwise sound car go pop.
What they could do is accelerate the appearance of failures that were already imminent!
edit: If you look at my post you will see that is what I said, although I don't agree with imminent. Had the remap from the Leon removed and the clutch was fine for another 10k (sold it after that).

The VAG group cars are well known for eating the clutch when remapped - can't handle the torque apparently. The Volvo was fine before the map.

My point is if you look on the net there are plenty that have had bad experiences with the remap itself or with the issues it can cause after. Too much guff is written about manufacturer 'safety zones' and 'non optimal maps' to justify a remap - people should ask themselves do they really believe they can increase the power by 30% with no/low risk?

The other thing that annoys me is those who claim a remap is 'invisible' - no, it many cases it is not. And you can be sure the insurance co or car dealer will go nosing about when they are asked to pay up for a big smash/warranty claim.


Edited by VolvoT5 on Sunday 28th April 10:33


Edited by VolvoT5 on Sunday 28th April 10:34

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
VolvoT5 said:
to premature failure of already old/tired components
Your 2 points suggest worn components already, the remap wasn't the issue.

VolvoT5

4,155 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
The Spruce goose said:
Your 2 points suggest worn components already, the remap wasn't the issue.
Stupid point. Any car that has ever been driven will have 'worn' components, at what point does it become acceptable for a remap to cause failure of those 'worn' parts which may have otherwise been usable for many thousands of miles?

krissharm

Original Poster:

2,223 posts

170 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I've googled the EGR thing and I can not find a simple answer, (simple answer for a simple man lol)

So the idea is that an older car as with any older car is more at risk for having components fail? I certianly wouldnt want to have to replace the clutch and duel mass flywheel a month after a remap just because I wanted a bit more power and better fuel ecomony

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
VolvoT5, perhaps imminent is the wrong word, but certainly failures that were more than capable of happening with the standard settings, if you see what I mean.

What I've written about safety factors above isn't "guff", it's well-known fact and it's exactly why such large gains can be had from aftermarket map tuning, but it's important that I also mentioned durability will be sacrificed. Most likely you'll not cause a failure, and perhaps you won't even notice any problem over the lifetime of the car, but you will (indisputably) make the engine less durable than it was to begin with. The question is just how over-engineered it was for your purposes, and how far you're happy to push it! Obviously other driveline components are affected, and their rated loads and states of wear will be a consideration.


OP: EGR, or exhaust gas recirculation, is an emissions control system fitted to almost all modern cars. It aims to reduce the emission of nitrogen oxides (NOx) from the engine. NOx are only formed at high temperatures (above about 1800K, if I remember right), and by recirculating a small amount of already-burnt gas back into the intake, an EGR system attempts to reduce the temperatures in the combustion chamber to limit NOx production.

The system exists purely for emissions control, and in fact reducing the temperatures in the combustion chamber is quite the opposite of what you'd want to do for optimum efficiency. As we, the users, aren't concerned by all the EU emissions hoops manufacturers must jump through, advantages can be had by removing the EGR effect - a moderate efficiency improvement at part load, ie, better fuel economy. The only disadvantage is higher NOx production, which all but the most tree-hugging of drivers will agree isn't our problem, and won't ever cause MOT issues or anything like that. Blanking plates/disabling kits are sold for most cars, and disabling EGR at the same time as carrying out a remap is common practice.

krissharm

Original Poster:

2,223 posts

170 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
McSam said:
VolvoT5, perhaps imminent is the wrong word, but certainly failures that were more than capable of happening with the standard settings, if you see what I mean.

What I've written about safety factors above isn't "guff", it's well-known fact and it's exactly why such large gains can be had from aftermarket map tuning, but it's important that I also mentioned durability will be sacrificed. Most likely you'll not cause a failure, and perhaps you won't even notice any problem over the lifetime of the car, but you will (indisputably) make the engine less durable than it was to begin with. The question is just how over-engineered it was for your purposes, and how far you're happy to push it!


OP: EGR, or exhaust gas recirculation, is an emissions control system fitted to almost all modern cars. It aims to reduce the emission of nitrogen oxides (NOx) from the engine. NOx are only formed at high temperatures (above about 1800K, if I remember right), and by recirculating a small amount of already-burnt gas back into the intake, an EGR system attempts to reduce the temperatures in the combustion chamber to limit NOx production.

The system exists purely for emissions control, and in fact reducing the temperatures in the combustion chamber is quite the opposite of what you'd want to do for optimum efficiency. As we, the users, aren't concerned by all the EU emissions hoops manufacturers must jump through, advantages can be had by removing the EGR effect - a moderate efficiency improvement at part load, ie, better fuel economy. The only disadvantage is higher NOx production, which all but the most tree-hugging of drivers will agree isn't our problem, and won't ever cause MOT issues or anything like that. Blanking plates/disabling kits are sold for most cars, and disabling EGR at the same time as carrying out a remap is common practice.
McSam, thanks for that, simply put that makes sense. And I suppose the work at the same time as the remap makes sense. Would the ECU detect this change and throw up a fault? Or is that why you do it with the Remap? Because the software that makes the change also accounts for the EGR?


McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
No worries smile

On most cars I don't think it causes the ECU to have a strop, though I suppose it depends on how the system operates and how you disable it. But, as you rightly say, if you did it while having a remap the settings can be changed to remove the EGR - you could do this by changing the conditions under which the EGR operates to impossible ones, for example, so the ECU still has control of the system but never tries to engage it!

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
VolvoT5 said:
Stupid point.
i thought i was clear but my point being is your clutch was sufficiently worn to indicate any increase in power would not allow it to do it's job. the remap you had highlighted this.

not knowing your remap criteria/changes could invalidate any points, as the remap may have been higher than the clutch specification.

krissharm

Original Poster:

2,223 posts

170 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
The Spruce goose said:
VolvoT5 said:
Stupid point.
i thought i was clear but my point being is your clutch was sufficiently worn to indicate any increase in power would not allow it to do it's job. the remap you had highlighted this.

not knowing your remap criteria/changes could invalidate any points, as the remap may have been higher than the clutch specification.
In my case (I think, from what I have read) i'd be going from 140 -170ish bhp, the 6 speed manual box in my 140, is the same one they put in the 170 version of the car, I think. By all means correct me if I am wrong, but that would leave me to belive that the clutch is a similar spec?