What is the point of SEAT?
What is the point of SEAT?
Author
Discussion

thinkofaname

Original Poster:

401 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I know that the VW group exploits multiple brands in a rather clinical fashion -- Audi for the "executive" market, Volkswagen itself as the premium mainstream brand, Skoda as the good-value-but-still-decent-quality option. It's mostly horrible marketing bullst which right-thinking people should despise... but nevertheless, I find myself wondering where SEAT fits into this diabolical scheme for world domination. It's a cheap brand like Skoda, except Skoda has an established position of unglamorous, no-nonsense quality. SEAT doesn't. So why buy a SEAT when you can buy a Skoda for the same money?

I have seen a few rumours that VW bosses think the same way, and that the SEAT brand is in the last chance saloon. Any truth in that?

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I've often wondered the same. I think they used to be the "sporty" brand but then they started making cars that looked like MPVs, which doesn't really fit with that image.

I don't know about the feelings within VAG, but you certainly don't see a tenth as many recent SEATs around as Skodas, VWs or Audis.

Jimbo.

4,239 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
SEAT being sold off has been on the rumour mill for ages. Seat are, IIRC, the cheaper, "sporty" end of the VAG spectrum, supposed to appeal to the younger, more fashionable buyer.

Cheap? Skoda.
Cheap, but don't want a Skoda? Seat
Mainstream: VW
Cock: Audi

However, via aspiration, finance and the realisation that there's nothing actually wrong with the Skoda badge (coupled to some Seat duds as of late), the would-be Seat buyer is happy to go to Skoda (esp. with the VRS models), or to VW for a bit more neighbourhood driveway status.

Mr Adds

264 posts

180 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I think seat had lost their way but the new ibiza is nice ( I would say that as I have one!) And I like the look of the new leon, although as the 'sporting' arm of vag need more sporty cars like the tango concept of a few years ago. I think the fr's and cupras are now level with skoda vrs in terms of image.

talksthetalk

10,821 posts

166 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
To me, on my second SEAT, they started off(VAG era) at the cheaper end of the sportyish mainstream market. More recently they seem to be aiming at the fleet market, probably because people want something cheaper than the competition, but now they don't have to give discounts on VWs, protecting their main brand.
Finally, quite a few companies have an image issue with sending their staff out and about in Skodas still.

Nemo Sum

163 posts

167 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Not enough differentiation between the VAG stable mates for the brand. If you want quality without badge kudos/value for money buy Skoda. If you care about the badge then get VW. Forget AUDI as they simply aren't in the same league as far as the average consumer would think. With that said why would you pick a SEAT car.

Also add to mix the relatively recent attractiveness of some of the Korean manufactured cars and there is nothing that Seat offers that can't be equaled bettered by someone else in every department whether that be price, quality, aesthetics, sportiness, image etc.


thinkofaname

Original Poster:

401 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
talksthetalk said:
To me, on my second SEAT, they started off(VAG era) at the cheaper end of the sportyish mainstream market. More recently they seem to be aiming at the fleet market, probably because people want something cheaper than the competition, but now they don't have to give discounts on VWs, protecting their main brand.
Finally, quite a few companies have an image issue with sending their staff out and about in Skodas still.
Don't get me wrong - I have nothing against SEATs. It would be silly to be anti-SEAT, since it is just another VAG brand. But that is my point - VAG is normally so calculated about these things, and yet they have these two budget brands that seem to compete with each other. Maybe they weren't sure which brand to back and put it to some kind of Darwinian contest, which Skoda turns out to have won.

Zyp

16,178 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
SEAT being sold off has been on the rumour mill for ages. Seat are, IIRC, the cheaper, "sporty" end of the VAG spectrum, supposed to appeal to the younger, more fashionable buyer.

Cheap? Skoda.
Cheap, but don't want a Skoda? Seat
Mainstream: VW
Cock: Audi

However, via aspiration, finance and the realisation that there's nothing actually wrong with the Skoda badge (coupled to some Seat duds as of late), the would-be Seat buyer is happy to go to Skoda (esp. with the VRS models), or to VW for a bit more neighbourhood driveway status.
Where does Porsche fit into your list?

wink

Jimbo.

4,239 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Zyp said:
Where does Porsche fit into your list?

wink
Similar place to Lamborghini and Bugatti i.e. a different space/time continuum to the cars discussed here tongue out

Zyp

16,178 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
But they're owned by VW, so must fit in somewhere like SEAT.

Jimbo.

4,239 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Zyp said:
But they're owned by VW, so must fit in somewhere like SEAT.
OK:
Cock: Audi
Performance: Porsche
Footballer: Lamborghini
Oil Sheikh: Bugatti.

Blayney

2,949 posts

217 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd take a SEAT over VW, Audi or Skoda.

I know they are all basically one and the same. But an Ibiza looks better than a polo or a fabia or an A1 to my eyes.

Zyp

16,178 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
OK:
Cock: Audi
Performance: Porsche
Footballer: Lamborghini
Oil Sheikh: Bugatti.
Like it laugh

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm on my second SEAT and rather like them. I've found the cars (Ibiza and Leon) to be well equipped, good looking and great value for money when compared to the equivalent VW. But those two are both cars that SEAT had the freedom to be creative with and do a lot of in-house design with. The problem is they get stuck with cars that are just straight rebrands of other VW products like the Mii (Citigo/ Up), Toledo (Skoda Rapid), Exeo (Old A4) and Alhambra (Sharan). Its these models that appear pointless to many and end up been slow sellers with weak residuals as they offer nothing unique and don't represent SEAT.

The solution IMO is to take an Alfa Romeo approach and really whittle down the range. Alfa currently only offer the MiTo and Giulietta and seem to sell reasonably well, so SEAT should do the same with its core products the Ibiza and Leon. To supplement that they could also offer cars unique to the VAG product range, maybe a small 2-seat roadster (a tier below the TT) or a Nissan Juke/ Qashqai style crossover.

They need to capitalise on the strong points of the brand as it offers youthful image (most SEAT drivers wouldn't be seen dead in a Skoda) and great looking well equipped cars.

The new Leon SC looks very promising and is a good example of this. Its a hugely good looking car with the very latest MQB platform, a new range of engines and very competitive list prices along with innovative features such as all LED headlights.


b0rk

2,412 posts

177 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
SEAT being sold off has been on the rumour mill for ages.
I really can't see VAG selling SEAT ever it would technology transfer par excellence to the Chinese. IMHO if SEAT runs out of time VAG will go for full wind down and closure. Actually I'm not sure closure would be needed as VW already produce Audi Q3's at Martorell, a bit of downsizing and production shifting could see the SEAT brand vanish with no factory closures.

Your point however is valid with finance deals you can get a VW or Audi for close to SEAT money. Skoda in trying to shake off the poor image has actually done a better of job trying to be youthful and sporty.

Speed_Demon

2,662 posts

219 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Skoda: Cheap and boring for the oldies (the perception)
SEAT: Cheap but cool for the young uns!

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Speed_Demon said:
Skoda: Cheap and boring for the oldies (the perception)
SEAT: Cheap but cool for the young uns!
I'd agree with that. Skoda do a better job of projecting a quality image though, as people seem happy to trade down from an Audi, BMW or Mercedes to them. SEAT is more of a stepping stone before getting that VW or Audi. Seen quite a few examples of this on the various owners forums.

CarlT

3,424 posts

278 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Just think about the business model of SEAT for a second and the reason why it exists is quite clear!

dvs_dave

9,040 posts

256 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Jimbo. said:
OK:
Cock: Audi
Performance: Porsche
Footballer: Lamborghini
Oil Sheikh: Bugatti.
What about Bentley?

And what do you drive? Not something that falls into an "hilarious" PH stereotype I hope?

Jimbo.

4,239 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
dvs_dave said:
What about Bentley?

And what do you drive? Not something that falls into an "hilarious" PH stereotype I hope?
Absolutely! An old Volvo shed that predates Jesus. That carrys lots of things. Quite often from Ikea.

Oh, and Bentley? Jordan, Paris Hilton and other such wonderful, worthwhile people.