Intermittent clutch / gearbox problem
Intermittent clutch / gearbox problem
Author
Discussion

mx5tom

Original Poster:

573 posts

204 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm having an intermittent issue with my car and was just wondering if anyone knew what might be causing it. It's an MX5 1.8 Mk3 with about 67k miles.

The problem is noticeable in two situations, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was the same issue causing both problems.

The most common occurrence is that the car won't go into reverse. It doesn't seem to make a difference whether the car is warmed up or not. The vast majority of the time it's absolutely fine, but occasionally (and what seems to be more frequently recently) the gear lever will only move about half way into reverse before feeling like it's reached the end of its travel. Obviously I haven't forced it any further.

In this kind of situation, sometimes going to fifth, back to neutral and bringing the clutch back up, before trying to put it into reverse again works. Other times this doesn't work, but keeping a light pressure on the gear stick whilst slowly lifting the clutch pedal up results in it 'popping' in to gear without any drama.

The second situation can be where I try to change gear whilst driving and it doesn't quite go into gear. Again, whether the car is warmed up or not doesn't seem to matter nor does the specific gear. It happened yesterday when changing to second but it's happened changing to third and fourth quite recently too. Imagine changing gear with the clutch pedal 'almost' fully depressed and the ensuing grinding of gears and that's pretty much it, except that the clutch pedal is completely depressed.

Aside from these specific issues, the car normally drives fine and there's no odd noises, changes gear fine, etc... Does anyone have any idea what could be causing this?

The fact that it's intermittent is what bugs me. I would have thought if something was mechanically wrong, it would always do it rather than just now and then.

digger the goat

2,868 posts

176 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like a selector... Cheap fix..

TallPaul

1,524 posts

289 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Or possibly the clutch needs adjusting? If its hydraulic it may need bleeding, or the cable needs a bit of a tweak.

mx5tom

Original Poster:

573 posts

204 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
If this makes any difference: When stopped with the engine off, there are no issues at all in selecting a gear. In fact the gear lever can be moved far easier than it ever is whilst driving.

In comparison, when driving most gears seem to have much more resistance.

Would this be more indicative of a clutch problem than a selector?

Xtriple129

1,173 posts

188 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I'd say, definitely clutch needs adjusting. Not sure if hydraulic or cable but either way there must be adjustment. Go on MX5 nuts or similar and the answer will be yours in seconds smile

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Hydraulic clutch on these if the internet can be believed. Were it a knackered old MG I would say it was a failing seal in either the clutch master or slave cylinder. If that's the case there will possibly be a bit of clutch fluid leaking. Check the level in the reservoir and see if it goes down over the week.

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Simple things first. I'd bleed the clutch and see what difference it makes. It sounds like clutch drag to me.

Tim

iridebikes

63 posts

169 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I would try a gearbox/gear shaft thingy oil change..

mighty kitten

431 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Clutch slave cylinder leaking , check the reservoir then pull the boot off the Slave to check for any leakage

mx5tom

Original Poster:

573 posts

204 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice:

Gearbox oil: This was changed about a year ago. I'm pretty sure it's not due on the service schedule for another couple of years at least.

Clutch fluid: The reservoir bottle was wet and so 'could' be leaking. But I haven't noticed any wet patches on my drive, and the fluid level is just below the max. mark. I've cleaned it off and will keep an eye on it. The clutch/brake fluid (they share a reservoir) looks completely black, is this normal?

I'm not a very mechanically minded person, but not through lack of trying... So I'll look in to how to bleed the clutch and see if it makes any difference. smile

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
The brake/clutch fluid should be clear. It sounds like the seals could be breaking up. As I said earlier, change the fluid. It degrades after time anyway, as it absorbs moisture.

Some say that it should be changed every 2 years or so, as a matter of routine. Do this first.

Tim