Why is the Lexus Is mk1 not the darling of PH ?
Discussion
okie592 said:
Always wondered why people don't rave about these like the beloved e46, they are good to drive. Straight 6 RWD stuffed with kit reliable, comfy. And yet never see it mentioned. It's even got the mx5s jap swag sewn up.
Am I missing something?
They have pretty appalling fuel economy for the engine size, and the 3.0 one only comes in automatic with a 0-60 time of almost 8 seconds.Am I missing something?
In comparison, the 330i uses less fuel and is almost 2 seconds faster to 60mph, and comes with a manual box.
TotalControl said:
The is300 (same engine as the supra) was good but came in auto. The beams engined (3sge Yamaha tuned) was a better car but somewhat overshadowed by the fleets of BMWs available at the time as it was JDM only.
The Altezza RS200 as mentioned above looks an interesting but they only seem to turn up in quite bright colours?How strange that this should come up when I was thinking the same thing an hour ago when there was one behind me on the way home from work.
The two litre straight six as sold in the UK is very smooth and sounds nice but it just hasn't got the power to back it up. It didn't need that much more, I think if it had been 190bhp ish rather than 160ish that would probably have been enough to liven it up.
The two litre straight six as sold in the UK is very smooth and sounds nice but it just hasn't got the power to back it up. It didn't need that much more, I think if it had been 190bhp ish rather than 160ish that would probably have been enough to liven it up.
Its a mystery to me as well.
I have owned a Lexus IS300 for getting on for 4 years. I use it as my business car, and have had an MGF, MR2 and now a GTM Rossa Kitcar for fun. Recent barges have been Audi A8, Saab 9000, Lexus IS400 and GS430.
My best friend bought a Manual BMW 330ci at about the same time, I have driven his car and he mine, so we have a fairly strong comparative bases of similar cars over similar mileage and use.
First, performance. Stats wise, it looks like the BMW has a clear advantage, in BHP and 0-60. However. it doesnt tell the whole story. For some unknown reason, they decided to make second gear 58mph in the Lexus, and the change into third hurts the 0-60 a lot. In reality, line the two cars up next to each other, floor them and the performance is nearly identical.
Secondly, handling. Stats wise the Lexus has a better slalom speed, and almost identical skidpad results. Everyone expects the Lexus to be soft and the BMW to be more involved. The reality is the two cars use different suspension systems, double wishbones on the Lexus and multilink on the BMW and they deliver opposite results to what most people expect. The BMW has less camber control, the Lexus slightly heavier unsprung weight. This means the Lexus actually has a harder primary ride and is noisier on the motorway, but tracks much better over mid corner bumps and compresions. The BMW on its 18 inch wheel feels a little quicker to turn in, and a little sharper to break away. The Gemometry of the Lexus standard includes quite a bit of camber and toe in..this makes it "feel" less stable under breaking, with the flipside being is it wants to turn in under braking more positively when cornering. However this can have tyre wear issues so many people remove the factory settings. The Lexus bodyshell is also much stiffer in 5 door format than the 330Ci coupe ( 30,000nm for the Lexus and around 12,000 for the BMW - BMW coupe suprisingly weak )and this translates into less creaks and rattles and a general feeling of tautness, the BMW really falls apart if you try to take a potholed corner at speed. The Lexus does have about 40kg more weight over the front due to iron block engine and doesn't have perfect 50/50 balance - it means its a litte more understeery on the way in and more oversteery on the way out.
The Lexus has the optional LSD ( not an option on the standard E46 ) and this makes a big difference to the ability to slide. The Lexus is far more playful and eaiser to provoke and will perform genuine drifts.. the BMW spins up the inside wheel and won't stay in a slide. It does mean the car will understeer more than the BMW if you floor it before the apex of a corner as the LSD will "lock" the rear wheels. The traction control/stability control on the Lexus is far more forgiving of such antics, the BMW will cut all power for about 2 seconds after it detects slip, feels really unpleasant. If you want to drift the car, the Lexus is miles ahead.
Steering feel - BMW E463 Series not considered a high point of steering feel.. The Lexus is better with less dead area around straight ahead and better at communicating camber and grip with excellent weighting.
Braking. The BMW is better under braking, and takes less time to stop in every test I have seen, about 10-15ft better. Leads the segment on this aspect, no question. Suspect better calipers and larger discs in BMW help this.
Gearbox.
The BMW will obviously please people who like manuals, the IS300 is not available with one. However, the auto box is very good, and you can change gear with the buttons on the steering wheel. It's not as good as an Audi DSG box, and there is a torque converter which means it feels slushy under 2500rpm, but unless you have no mechanical sympathy whatsoever it shifts just as fast as a human. I wanted an automatic as this means I can drive into London twice a week and not go insane, but you still blip down a couple of gears and balance the car on the throttle round a corner.. which is something I missed on my GS430 and IS400.
Ownership/Costs.
Lexus was 5000 pounds, the BMW 8300 at time of purchase.
The Lexus has has only mechanical problem during my ownership, worn steering balls joints, a known weakness. I have also replaced the front calipers/discs as they have had a hard life. Rear numberplate light went. The alloys also corroded and I had them refurbed. No rust on chassis.
In contrast, my friend has spent...a lot. Two sets of lower wishbones, balljoints, a steering rack, ignition barrel, window regulator, front AC radiator fan, Cam position sensor, Calipers and pads. The car has gone into limp home mode twice and then recovered inexplicably. The car has 3 rust spots, on the sill, one front arch and one rear arch. Alloys have also delaminated, but not quite as badly as the Lexus alloys did.
Neither of the cars have every failed to start or failed to finish a jorney.
The BMW gets better MPG, about 3mpg better overall. He averages around 28mpg and I am about 25mpg. However I suspect our driving patterns are different so this is not scientific. Both of them have a a tremendous thirst when pushed hard !
The BMW 18inch alloys are also much more expensive in rubber. ( Good year list 182pounds for the Sportcontact 5 in 255/35/18 vs 106 pounds for 225/45/17 )
So overall, he spent a lot more to buy and a lot more to maintain over 4 years, ( 3300 in my favour on purchase, and about 2000 on servicing in my favour ) . However he saved about 700 pounds on fuel over 30,000 miles overall lifespan. Lexus has ended up with me 4600 pounds better off overall than the BMW.
I have enjoyed my Lexus, I drove it to Germany, took it round the ring, then up through the Swiss alps and across the south coast to Montpellier. I have taken it down the Santa Pod strip, and never felt like was doing a bad job at any of these things. It's not as focussed but it manages to do all things well. My mid engined sports cars are where I get the majority of my driving thrills, and I won't pretend either the Lexus or the BMW get close to convertibles for enjoyment and involvement, but as a tool to cover miles and not bore myself to death doing it, the Lexus has done a great job and has lived up to its reputation as being bulletproof.
TL DR; BMW has been a great car for my friend and as the "ultimate driving machine" is maybe 10% better overall than the Lexus...but that 10% extra has cost him 100% of the cost and the Lexus is still better on many key handling metrics... .
I have owned a Lexus IS300 for getting on for 4 years. I use it as my business car, and have had an MGF, MR2 and now a GTM Rossa Kitcar for fun. Recent barges have been Audi A8, Saab 9000, Lexus IS400 and GS430.
My best friend bought a Manual BMW 330ci at about the same time, I have driven his car and he mine, so we have a fairly strong comparative bases of similar cars over similar mileage and use.
First, performance. Stats wise, it looks like the BMW has a clear advantage, in BHP and 0-60. However. it doesnt tell the whole story. For some unknown reason, they decided to make second gear 58mph in the Lexus, and the change into third hurts the 0-60 a lot. In reality, line the two cars up next to each other, floor them and the performance is nearly identical.
Secondly, handling. Stats wise the Lexus has a better slalom speed, and almost identical skidpad results. Everyone expects the Lexus to be soft and the BMW to be more involved. The reality is the two cars use different suspension systems, double wishbones on the Lexus and multilink on the BMW and they deliver opposite results to what most people expect. The BMW has less camber control, the Lexus slightly heavier unsprung weight. This means the Lexus actually has a harder primary ride and is noisier on the motorway, but tracks much better over mid corner bumps and compresions. The BMW on its 18 inch wheel feels a little quicker to turn in, and a little sharper to break away. The Gemometry of the Lexus standard includes quite a bit of camber and toe in..this makes it "feel" less stable under breaking, with the flipside being is it wants to turn in under braking more positively when cornering. However this can have tyre wear issues so many people remove the factory settings. The Lexus bodyshell is also much stiffer in 5 door format than the 330Ci coupe ( 30,000nm for the Lexus and around 12,000 for the BMW - BMW coupe suprisingly weak )and this translates into less creaks and rattles and a general feeling of tautness, the BMW really falls apart if you try to take a potholed corner at speed. The Lexus does have about 40kg more weight over the front due to iron block engine and doesn't have perfect 50/50 balance - it means its a litte more understeery on the way in and more oversteery on the way out.
The Lexus has the optional LSD ( not an option on the standard E46 ) and this makes a big difference to the ability to slide. The Lexus is far more playful and eaiser to provoke and will perform genuine drifts.. the BMW spins up the inside wheel and won't stay in a slide. It does mean the car will understeer more than the BMW if you floor it before the apex of a corner as the LSD will "lock" the rear wheels. The traction control/stability control on the Lexus is far more forgiving of such antics, the BMW will cut all power for about 2 seconds after it detects slip, feels really unpleasant. If you want to drift the car, the Lexus is miles ahead.
Steering feel - BMW E463 Series not considered a high point of steering feel.. The Lexus is better with less dead area around straight ahead and better at communicating camber and grip with excellent weighting.
Braking. The BMW is better under braking, and takes less time to stop in every test I have seen, about 10-15ft better. Leads the segment on this aspect, no question. Suspect better calipers and larger discs in BMW help this.
Gearbox.
The BMW will obviously please people who like manuals, the IS300 is not available with one. However, the auto box is very good, and you can change gear with the buttons on the steering wheel. It's not as good as an Audi DSG box, and there is a torque converter which means it feels slushy under 2500rpm, but unless you have no mechanical sympathy whatsoever it shifts just as fast as a human. I wanted an automatic as this means I can drive into London twice a week and not go insane, but you still blip down a couple of gears and balance the car on the throttle round a corner.. which is something I missed on my GS430 and IS400.
Ownership/Costs.
Lexus was 5000 pounds, the BMW 8300 at time of purchase.
The Lexus has has only mechanical problem during my ownership, worn steering balls joints, a known weakness. I have also replaced the front calipers/discs as they have had a hard life. Rear numberplate light went. The alloys also corroded and I had them refurbed. No rust on chassis.
In contrast, my friend has spent...a lot. Two sets of lower wishbones, balljoints, a steering rack, ignition barrel, window regulator, front AC radiator fan, Cam position sensor, Calipers and pads. The car has gone into limp home mode twice and then recovered inexplicably. The car has 3 rust spots, on the sill, one front arch and one rear arch. Alloys have also delaminated, but not quite as badly as the Lexus alloys did.
Neither of the cars have every failed to start or failed to finish a jorney.
The BMW gets better MPG, about 3mpg better overall. He averages around 28mpg and I am about 25mpg. However I suspect our driving patterns are different so this is not scientific. Both of them have a a tremendous thirst when pushed hard !
The BMW 18inch alloys are also much more expensive in rubber. ( Good year list 182pounds for the Sportcontact 5 in 255/35/18 vs 106 pounds for 225/45/17 )
So overall, he spent a lot more to buy and a lot more to maintain over 4 years, ( 3300 in my favour on purchase, and about 2000 on servicing in my favour ) . However he saved about 700 pounds on fuel over 30,000 miles overall lifespan. Lexus has ended up with me 4600 pounds better off overall than the BMW.
I have enjoyed my Lexus, I drove it to Germany, took it round the ring, then up through the Swiss alps and across the south coast to Montpellier. I have taken it down the Santa Pod strip, and never felt like was doing a bad job at any of these things. It's not as focussed but it manages to do all things well. My mid engined sports cars are where I get the majority of my driving thrills, and I won't pretend either the Lexus or the BMW get close to convertibles for enjoyment and involvement, but as a tool to cover miles and not bore myself to death doing it, the Lexus has done a great job and has lived up to its reputation as being bulletproof.
TL DR; BMW has been a great car for my friend and as the "ultimate driving machine" is maybe 10% better overall than the Lexus...but that 10% extra has cost him 100% of the cost and the Lexus is still better on many key handling metrics... .
s m said:
The Altezza RS200 as mentioned above looks an interesting but they only seem to turn up in quite bright colours?
Most of the ones I see are silver or white, they're pretty common down here.Its a good engine, 210bhp IIRC and has a nice 6-speed manual box behind it, but does have to be revved to make progress as it doesn't have much torque down low.
At sub 1400kg they're not as heavy as some seem to think, a quick google suggests thats 100+kg lighter than any E46 3-series apart from the CSL. I expect the 6-cyl versions are 1500+ kg though.
Edited by GravelBen on Monday 29th April 23:50
rohrl said:
The two litre straight six as sold in the UK is very smooth and sounds nice but it just hasn't got the power to back it up. It didn't need that much more, I think if it had been 190bhp ish rather than 160ish that would probably have been enough to liven it up.
I wonder if that would have had a disastrous effect on the already poor economy figures? Not that economy is the be-all-and-end-all, but it is striking to consider that my 4.2 V8 Audi wasn't much worse!Baryonyx said:
rohrl said:
The two litre straight six as sold in the UK is very smooth and sounds nice but it just hasn't got the power to back it up. It didn't need that much more, I think if it had been 190bhp ish rather than 160ish that would probably have been enough to liven it up.
I wonder if that would have had a disastrous effect on the already poor economy figures? Not that economy is the be-all-and-end-all, but it is striking to consider that my 4.2 V8 Audi wasn't much worse!Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


